Value assessment on Hagia Sophia complex in Trabzon /

2016
Özmen, Can
Hagia Sophia in Trabzon which was built in the 13th century was open to public as a museum after a restoration work held by Edinburg University between 1958 and 1962, however, the building was converted into a mosque by the Pious Foundations Directorate of Trabzon on 5 July 2013. The aim of this thesis is to define Hagia Sophia’s current condition and problems derived from re-functioning as a mosque, discuss its historical background and intervention history to assess existing and potential values for future interventions from a viewpoint of an art and architectural history and conservation of cultural heritage. For this aim, the historical background and intervention history, analysis of the current condition and effects of the latest interventions, and finally a comparative study and value assessment were made to determine the distinctive features and values of the heritage in this study. It is understood that the building witnessed several of change in functions and interventions which can be evaluated under four periods, and it is important to note that the building was seldomly used as a mosque and abandoned before the 19th century according to the notes of travelers. To conclude, today while the Hagia Sophia is in good condition structurally and displays distinctive historical, symbolic, artistic and architectural values, latest implementations resulted in the degradation of the values and they are inadequate for presenting and conserve the values of the of the heritage as frescoes which are not suitable for Muslim at the dome, naos, and bema of Hagia Sophia were covered with curtains and opus alexandrinum tiled floor at the naos under the dome bay was obscured under carpeting, and other interventions were distorting the perception of the space. 

Suggestions

Understanding the Lahore Museum for the definition of a conservation process /
Sami, Usman; Şahin Güçhan, Neriman; Conservation of Cultural Heritage in Department of Architecture (2017)
This thesis aims to study the Lahore Museum in Lahore, Pakistan to propose a conservation process for the building. The construction of the building was completed in 1893 and initially housed both the Museum and the Victoria Jubilee Institute, celebrating Queen Victoria’s Golden Jubilee in 1887. It was designed by John Lockwood Kipling along with Bhai Ram Singh, both central figures of the Arts and Crafts in the Punjab, while its construction was overseen by Sir Ganga Ram, the Executive Engineer of Punjab. ...
A Study on reusing Bouleuterion of Teos /
Çalışkan, Merve; Gökce, Fuat; Restoration in Department of Architecture (2015)
This study is constructed upon the question of “How should we approach to a building in an archaeological site for its compatible and sustainable utilization?” as a contemporary phenomenon which was and still has been considered for ancient places of performances and Bouleuterion in Teos Archaeological site - an architectural remain in excavation process, is assessed as the case of the study. For this reason, starting with a generic research on ‘reusing’ of historic buildings, the research on the utilizatio...
Causes and effects of urban transformation processes on the cultural heritage in Hacı Bayram area, Ulus /
Demiröz, Merve; Şahin Güçhan, Neriman; Conservation of Cultural Heritage in Department of Architecture (2015)
Hacı Bayram Area is located on the top ofa small hill on the north-westenı part of the Ankara Citadel in Ulus Historic Center. Co-existance of the Temple of Augus­ tus and Hacı Bayram Veli Mosque as a symbol of spatial continuity throughout the history and surrounding traditional neighbourhoods give the area its unique charac­ teristics. The Hacı Bayram Square and surrounding environment, which is called as Hacı Bayram Area throughout the history, has always became one of the focal points of huge interventi...
Re-construction of ghost buildings: taksim artillery barracks /
Kırbaş, Berrak; Zelef, Mustafa Haluk; Department of Architecture (2014)
This thesis is a critical assessment of the re-construction project of Taksim Artillery Barracks in the place of Taksim Gezi Park. In the meantime, it is an attempt to discuss the tendency of re-construction in architecture in relation to the “ghosts” in architectural discourse. In the scope of the thesis, the stimulation behind the resurrections of the “ghost” of the barracks and other “ghost buildings” are examined within three themes; “ghosts” in architectural discourse, “ghost building” as the haunted r...
Structural modelling, analysis, and evaluation of the historic buzlupinar bridge and recommendations for its reconstruction /
Çabuk, Ezgi; Türer, Ahmet; Şahin Güçhan, Neriman; Restoration in Department of Architecture (2015)
The Historic Buzlupınar Bridge is a timber pedestrian bridge, located in Buzlupınar Village, Rize, Turkey, which was constructed early in the 20th century and partially collapsed in 2008 at about 100 years of age. The wind loading was deemed responsible for the collapse of the bridge as stated by the locals. General Directorate of Highways has attributed special attention to Buzlupınar Bridge due to its rare value as a timber pedestrian bridge and has taken decision in 2012 to be rebuilt it again. In this t...
Citation Formats
C. Özmen, “Value assessment on Hagia Sophia complex in Trabzon /,” M.Arch. - Master of Architecture, Middle East Technical University, 2016.