Rational choice theory: its merits and limits in explaining and predicting cultural behavior

Download
2016
Kılınç Adanalı, Yurdagül
The main goal of this dissertation is to examine whether instrumental rationality can predict and explain successfully human behavior in all walks of life. I have chosen Rational Choice Theory and Public Choice Theory as the focus of my investigation, since they are considered as the best models of instrumental rationality in philosophy and social sciences, and in particular in economics and politics. To see their merits and to determine their limits, I have applied Rational Choice Theory and Public Choice Theory to the problems of culture and identity, since they are generally regarded beyond the scope of rationality and are believed to represent the most complicated forms of human behavior. I have argued that culture and identity can be subjected to the criteria of rationality and that Rational Choice Theory and Public Choice Theory have relative success in explaining and predicting the complexity and subtlety of cultural behaviors. Their success, however, is limited, since they make unrealistic assumptions about human cognitive capacity, they disregard the content of preferences, they dismiss the role of emotions in decision making, they are empirically ungeneralizable, they reduce collective structures to individual decisions, among other shortcomings. Despite these criticisms, instrumental rationality still retains its philosophical value in investigating and explaining human decisions and acts.

Suggestions

Socio-Spatial Politics of Otherness: The Desire to Construct a Counterhegemony
Yoltay, Ece (2019-03-01)
This study is based on an empirical research to understand the production of nongovernmental spatial practices and representations with a counterformation to an authority, as well as an ontological discussion on the relations between public space and power. In this respect, the study is constructed on an alternative spatial reading of counterspaces (LGBTI-friendly spaces, political spaces, and resistance spaces) in the capital of Turkey, Ankara, benefiting from Henri Lefebvre’s theory on the production of s...
Bergson’s method of intuition: towards a philosophy of life /
Koçkan, Zöhre; Çırakman, Elif; Department of Philosophy (2014)
The purpose of this study is to show how a possible philosophy of life can arise by following Bergson’s method of intuition and to make emphasis on how Bergson’s two fundamental notions (intuition and duration) are capable of grasping the flux of life. The scientific methods, static concepts and classical philosophy are not able to understand the flow of life. Throughout this study it is pointed out a possible philosophy that is able to grasp the flow and the evolution of life. For this aim, Bergson’s metho...
Material Processuality: Alternative Grounds for Design Research
Tönük Kruıthof, Damla (Informa UK Limited, 2020-01-01)
This article opens discussion on the positivist epistemology underlying the understandings of materials in design research that have been brought along as a result of theory and methods inherited from engineering and psychology. Examining the ambitions of work that seeks to operationalize knowledge created by these methods in the design process, we propose that attending to the processuality of material forms is a more adequate way for design research to capture the multiplicity of materials. We develop thi...
Ethics Teaching in Higher Education for Principled Reasoning: A Gateway for Reconciling Scientific Practice with Ethical Deliberation
Akozer, Mehmet; Akozer, Emel (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2017-06-01)
This paper proposes laying the groundwork for principled moral reasoning as a seminal goal of ethics interventions in higher education, and on this basis, makes a case for educating future specialists and professionals with a foundation in philosophical ethics. Identification of such a seminal goal is warranted by (1) the progressive dissociation of scientific practice and ethical deliberation since the onset of a problematic relationship between science and ethics around the mid-19th century, and (2) the e...
Epistemological naturalism, skeptical threat and the question of normativity in post-apocalyptic times
Baç, Mutlu Murat (2007-01-01)
My aim in this paper is to critically deal with two issues confronting naturalist philosophers who want to steer a middle course between radical naturalism and total apriorism in epistemology. These issues are (1) the role of a priori in ordinary human knowledge, and (2) who succeeds and who fails in properly dealing with the skeptical challenge. I focus on the views of P. Kitcher and L. BonJour with an aim to display the strengths and weaknesses of the naturalist perspective. My conclusion is that there ar...
Citation Formats
Y. Kılınç Adanalı, “Rational choice theory: its merits and limits in explaining and predicting cultural behavior,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2016.