Preservice Science Teachers' Informal Reasoning about Socioscientific Issues: The influence of issue context

2010-01-01
TOPÇU, MUSTAFA SAMİ
Sadler, Troy D.
Yılmaz Tüzün, Özgül
The purpose of the current study is to explicitly test the extent to which issue contexts affect the informal reasoning processes engaged in by individuals. In order to address the research question framing this study, we engaged 39 Turkish preservice science teachers (PSTs) in interviews designed to elicit argumentation related to multiple socioscientific scenarios. Three scenarios related to gene therapy, another three related to human cloning, and the final scenario related to global warming. The data were analyzed using an interpretive qualitative research approach. Our work builds on a framework initially proposed by Toulmin in 1958. This study has provided new evidence related to informal reasoning in the context of socioscientific issues (SSI). At the sample level, there was strong consistency in informal reasoning quality among varying socioscientific scenarios. However, finer-grained analyses indicated a greater level of variability in the informal reasoning practices of individual PSTs. These results support previous conclusions that suggest context dependence for informal reasoning related to SSI. This study provides an initial picture of the reasoning practices of preservice teachers as opposed to science learners. The results indicate that teachers, at least those in this Turkish setting, would benefit from learning experiences that support their own informal reasoning practices as well as their ability to foster development of these practices among their students. We encourage the field to continue the investigation of SSI as contexts for education particularly as it relates to the education of teachers.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENCE EDUCATION

Suggestions

Preservice science teachers (PSTs) informal reasoning characteristics regarding socioscientific issues: The relationship between informal reasoning patterns and quality
Topçu, Mustafa Sami; Yılmaz Tüzün, Özgül; Sadler, Troy D. (null; 2009-08-31)
The purpose of the current study is to explicitly test the extent to which issue contexts affect the informal reasoning processes engaged in by individuals. In order to address the research question framing this study, we engaged 39 Turkish preservice science teachers (PSTs) in interviews designed to elicit argumentation related to multiple socioscientific scenarios. Three scenarios related to gene therapy, another three related to human cloning, and the final scenario related to global warming. The data we...
Preservice Science Teachers' Epistemological Beliefs and Informal Reasoning Regarding Socioscientific Issues
Ozturk, Nilay; Yılmaz Tüzün, Özgül (2017-12-01)
This study investigated preservice elementary science teachers' (PSTs) informal reasoning regarding socioscientific issues (SSI), their epistemological beliefs, and the relationship between informal reasoning and epistemological beliefs. From several SSIs, nuclear power usage was selected for this study. A total of 647 Turkish PSTs enrolled in three large universities in Turkey completed the open-ended questionnaire, which assessed the participants' informal reasoning about the target SSI, and Schommer's (1...
The relationship between eighth grade students' nature of science understanding and their informal reasoning on socioscientific issues
Irmak, Nesibe Fatıma Nur; Yılmaz Tüzün, Özgül; Çakıroğlu, Jale; Department of Secondary Science and Mathematics Education (2021-8-02)
The purpose of this study was to explore the relationship between eighth grade students’ nature of science understanding and their informal reasoning on socioscientific issues. The study was performed with 414 8th grade middle school students in four different public middle schools of Turkey in Ankara, Altındağ. In the present study, correlational research approach was used. Background information about participants was collected by personal information questionnaire. The participants’ nature of science (NO...
A discussion of the concepts of validity and reliability in qualitative and quantitative Research
Sadık, Olgun (2019-06-01)
: The purpose of this paper is discussing the main issues in conceptualizing reliability and validity between qualitative and quantitative research approaches. The researcher examined the arguments about validity and reliability in inquiry methodology and identified three main debates primarily in qualitative research. The first one was about qualitative inquirers’ limited emphasis on the data collection process to increase the robustness of their research efforts. Most of the strategies in qualitative rese...
Preservice science teachers SSI teaching self-efficacy beliefs
Öztürk, Nilay; Yılmaz Tüzün, Özgül; Çakıroğlu, Jale (null; 2017-05-21)
The main aim of the present study is to investigate nature of PSTs’ SSI teaching self-efficacy beliefs. The participants were 52 senior preservice science teachers (PSTs). The data were collected by utilizing SSI Teaching Self-Efficacy Beliefs Instrument and open-ended questions administered during the Science Technology Society (STS) course. The results revealed that PSTs’ had moderate levels of SSI teaching selfefficacy beliefs. Moreover, PSTs reported many challenges they encountered while preparing an S...
Citation Formats
M. S. TOPÇU, T. D. Sadler, and Ö. Yılmaz Tüzün, “Preservice Science Teachers’ Informal Reasoning about Socioscientific Issues: The influence of issue context,” INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENCE EDUCATION, pp. 2475–2495, 2010, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/36206.