Comparison of case-based reasoning and artificial neural networks

1999-07-01
Arditi, David
Tokdemir, Onur Behzat
The outcome of construction litigation depends on a large number of factors. To predict the outcome of such litigation is difficult because of the complex interrelationships between these many factors. Two attempts are reported in the literature that use, respectively, case-based reasoning (CBR) and artificial neural networks (ANN) to overcome this difficulty. These studies were conducted by using the same 102 Illinois circuit court cases; an additional 12 cases were used for testing. Prediction rates of 83% in the CBR study and 67% in the ANN study were obtained. In this paper, CBR and ANN are compared, and their advantages and disadvantages are discussed in light of these two studies. It appears that CBR is more flexible when the system is updated with new cases, has better explanation facilities, and handles missing data and a large number of features better than ANN in this domain. If the use of CBR and ANN is understood better and if, as a result, the outcome of construction litigation can be predicted with reasonable accuracy and reliability, all parties involved in the construction process could save considerable money and time.
Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering

Suggestions

Parallel Hybrid Genetic Algorithm and GIS-Based Optimization for Municipal Solid Waste Collection Routing
Düzgün, H. Şebnem; Uşkay, S. Onur; Aksoy, Ayşegül (American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 2016-01-01)
A vast majority of studies on municipal solid waste (MSW) collection routing do not consider the constraints pertinent to actual road networks such as unidirectional roads and terrain characteristics. As a result, good practices such as the avoidance of U-turns cannot be used. This study introduces geographic information system (GIS)-integrated software (RouteSW) for the optimization of MSW collection routes by considering path constraints. The software uses a parallelized hybrid genetic algorithm (PHGA) to...
Automated Generation of Customized Field Data Collection Templates to Support Information Needs of Cost Estimators
Kiziltas, Semiha; Akinci, Burcu (American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 2010-03-01)
While estimating activity production rates, cost estimators rely on historical production rates. To have realistic and useful cost estimates based on historical production rates, such production rate data should be augmented with historical contextual information that depict conditions under which activity production rates were achieved in past projects. This information is needed in determining which production rate to use among alternates for a similar activity existing in a new bid. Estimators need conte...
Analysis of Three Indoor Localization Technologies for Supporting Operations and Maintenance Field Tasks
Taneja, Saurabh; Akçamete Güngör, Aslı; Akinci, Burcu; Garrett, James H.; Soibelman, Lucio; East, E. William (American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 2012-11-01)
Locating building components that need to be worked on during maintenance tasks is critical for timely repair of the component and mitigation of the damage. The process of locating a component or a person in a facility is called indoor localization. The objective of this research study is to analyze the feasibility of three indoor localization technologies for supporting operations and maintenance (O&M) field tasks; namely, wireless local area network (WLAN), radio frequency identification (RFID) tags, and ...
Lifetime Performance Analysis of Existing Reinforced Concrete Bridges. I: Theory
Akgül, Ferhat (American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 2005-06-01)
In this first part of a two-part paper, a general methodology for lifetime performance analysis of existing reinforced concrete bridges is presented. The framework for the methodology is established by identifying four distinct categories: limit state equations, random variables, deterministic parameters, and constant coefficients. The limit state equations are derived by strictly adhering to the load and capacity formulas and requirements set forth in AASHTO specifications. Generality is pursued by establi...
Improving sub-contractor selection process in construction projects: Web-based sub-contractor evaluation system (WEBSES)
Arslan, Gokhan; Kivrak, Serkan; Birgönül, Mustafa Talat; Dikmen Toker, İrem (Elsevier BV, 2008-05-01)
One of the most important phases in the construction industry (CI) is the bidding process. During the bidding process, selecting the most appropriate sub-contractors (SCs) for the relevant sub-works is highly critical for the overall project performance. In order to select the most appropriate SCs for the project and prepare the most realistic and accurate bid proposal, general contractors (GCs) have to know all financial, technical and general information about these SCs. Within this context, GCs should co...
Citation Formats
D. Arditi and O. B. Tokdemir, “Comparison of case-based reasoning and artificial neural networks,” Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering, pp. 162–169, 1999, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/43154.