Precarious manhood in Turkey: earned, lost, and threatened status of manhood

Türkoğlu, Beri
This dissertation aims to examine Precarious Manhood Thesis (PMT) in the cultural context of Turkey as well as examining the role of masculinity ideology on precarious manhood. According to PMT manhood is a hardly acquired anxious social status,it can be lost, and its anxiety results in maladaptive thinking patterns and behaviors in the face of gender threat. To test these assumptions, this dissertation conducts five studies. Study 1 develops traditional masculinity ideology scale with 23 items and four factors (i.e., head of family, dominance, emotional restriction, and avoidance of femininity). Study 2 examines participants’ agreement with the hard-won status of manhood/womanhood. Participants perceive manhood as more precarious (hard-won) compared to womanhood. In the same study, femininity avoidance component of masculinity ideology predict the perceptions of precarious manhood/womanhood. Study 3 tests the assumption that manhood/womanhood can be lost and show that participants attribute manhood loss more to social causes rather than physical/biological causes. However, they refer to social reasons equally for both manhood and womanhood loss in their open-ended interpretations. Study 4 tests the effect of gender threat on anxious thinking style but there was no significant effect of threat on anxiety. Study 5 examines the effect of gender threat on aggressive thinking style. In gender threat condition, men react with more physically-aggressive cognitions compared to women. Overall, the results partially meet the assumptions of PMT in Turkey. The results are discussed in the light of recent literature on cross-cultural differences and the characteristics of the Turkish cultural context.


Masculinity ideology and threat to manhood as precursors of violence against women in Turkey
Türkoğlu Demirel, Beril; Cingöz Ulu, Banu (2019-05-01)
This study aims to explore the effect of masculinity ideology (MI) and the threat to manhood (TM) on violence against women (VAW) in Turkey by testing two mediational models. The data is collected from a community sample by using quantitative research methods. The first model tests the effect of MI on attitudes towards VAW through TM. A second model employs the data of men in a relationship and tests the effect of MI on the actual perpetration of violence through TM and attitudes towards VAW. Endorsement of...
Making of new Islamism in Turkey transformation of the Islamist discourse from opposition to compliance
Özçetin, Burak; Ayata, Ayşe; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2011)
This thesis analyzes the transformation of Islamism from an anti-systemic and oppositional force to a compliant and submissive political ideology. The thesis locates the approach towards established political and economic relations at its centre. The thesis argues that the transformation, which led to formation of the Justice and Development Party, has begun in the late 1980s and early 1990s. To give the contours of this transformation, the thesis presents a detailed analysis of anti-systemic and systemic p...
Changing discourse on women and islam in Turkey in ethnographic studies
Onur, Petek; Saktanber, Ayşe Nur; Department of Sociology (2016)
This thesis provides an analysis of the change of ethnographic discourse on women and Islam in Turkey. Based on the theoretical framework of feminist postcolonial theory it analyses the ethnographic studies as texts and focuses on the concepts of subjectivity, subalternnes, otherness, and agency in Muslim women's discursive representations and binarism, Eurocentricism, essentialism in the way discourse is produced. It adopts Michel Foucault’s theorization of discourse, knowledge and power as a methodology t...
Patriarchal structures and practices in Turkey : the case of social realist and national films of 1960s
Yeşildal Şen, Hatice; Ecevit, Mehmet Cihan; Department of Sociology (2005)
This thesis highlights the significance of patriarchal structures and their reproduction in women̕s social position through the feminist perspective. Patriarchy is a dominant structure both on production and reproduction sphere. Patriarchy, which is a dominant structure in every sphere of social life has material basis and controls both women̕s labour and sexuality. With this framework some concepts such as the types of women̕s labour, paid and domestic labour, family, honour, violence and masculinity are u...
Man to Man: Understanding Hegemonic Masculinity in Turkey through Homosocial Interactions
Yunusoğlu, Enver; Ecevit, Fatma Yıldız; Department of Gender and Women's Studies (2021-4-27)
The aim of the current study is to understand hegemonic masculinity in Turkey by examining homosocial interactions between men. In order to better capture how male-male interactions contribute to hegemonic masculinity, I attempted to conduct a qualitative research based on feminist methodology. In the current study, I carried out semi-structured in-depth interviews with 20 men who belong to at least one homosocial group. In order to identify, analyze, and report themes within data, I undertook thematic anal...
Citation Formats
B. Türkoğlu, “Precarious manhood in Turkey: earned, lost, and threatened status of manhood,” Thesis (Ph.D.) -- Graduate School of Social Sciences. Psychology, Middle East Technical University, 2019.