Particle Size Distributions via Mechanism-Enabled Population Balance Modeling

Handwerk, Derek R.
Shipman, Patrick D.
Whitehead, Christopher B.
Özkar, Saim
Finke, Richard G.
Mechanism-enabled population balance modeling (ME-PBM) was recently defined as the use of experimentally established (i.e., disproof-based, deliberately minimalistic, and pseudo-elementary step-based) mechanisms as more rigorous input for population balance models. ME-PBM addresses three long-sought goals: mechanism-based prediction and control of particle size distributions (PSDs), fitting PSDs by various mechanisms to test which mechanisms are refuted versus supported, and then also extracting rate constants for the most strongly supported mechanism from the wealth of kinetics information buried within the PSD. A full ordinary differential equation (ODE) approach is developed to the PBModeling that is a resurrection of Smoluchowski's 1918 approach, a little used, but powerful approach that in turn allows fitting of the information-laden PSD including its shape. The full details are reported of the 12 different particle-formation, pseudo-elementary step mechanisms tested in a disproof-based approach to the ME-PBM analysis of the PSDs and kinetics data for a prototype Ir(0)(n) nanoparticle-formation system. The ME-PBM analysis led to the discovery of a new particle formation mechanism that is a 1-step, but key, expansion of the classic Finke-Watzky two-step mechanism of nucleation, A -> B, followed by autocatalytic surface growth, A + B -> 2B. Specifically, the ME-PBM analysis yielded the new three-step particle-formation mechanism of A -> B (rate constant k(1)), A + B -> C (rate constant k(2)), and A + C -> 1.5C (rate constant k(3)), where A represents the monomeric nanoparticle precursor, B represents "small" nanoparticles, and C represents "larger" growing nanoparticles. A list of key conclusions is provided including the paradigm shifts for particle formation that (i) nucleation needs not be "instantaneous" or "burst" "to achieve narrow PSDs as postulated by the classical 1950s LaMer model; that (ii) instead nucleation can be and often is continuous, as first shown in 1997, yet still leads to narrow PSDs; and critically that (iii) narrow PSDs can and do result in spite of continuous nucleation because smaller particles grow faster than larger ones (k(2) > k(3)), thereby allowing the smaller particles to catch up to the more slowly growing larger particles. Surface-ligand capping and other possible reasons that k(2) > k(3) are presented and discussed, as are additional conclusions, implications of the present studies, caveats, and needed additional studies. The goal of the present contribution is to follow up our first report of ME-PBM by providing the full details of our work to date so that others who wish to use ME-PBM in their own particle formations across nature, while fitting their own PSDs and testing their own mechanistic hypotheses, can readily do so.


Pentacene Multilayers on Ag(111) Surface
METE, ERSEN; Demiroglu, Ilker; Danışman, Mehmet Fatih; Ellialtioglu, Sinasi (American Chemical Society (ACS), 2010-02-18)
The structural profiles and electronic properties of pentacene (C22H14) multilayers on Ag(111) surface has been studied within the density functional theory framework. We have performed first-principle total energy calculations based on the projector-augmented wave method to investigate the initial growth patterns of pentacene (Pn) on Ag(111) surface. In its bulk phase, pentacene crystallizes with a triclinic symmetry while a thin film phase having an orthorhombic unit cell is energetically less favorable b...
A comparative study of the dipole polarizability of some Zn clusters
Papadopoulos, MG; Reis, H; Avramopoulos, A; Erkoc S, Erkoc S; Amirouche, L (American Chemical Society (ACS), 2005-10-13)
We have employed a hierarchy of basis sets and computational techniques in order to approach the polarizability (alpha) of Zn-m, m = 2-20, in a systematic way. This procedure allows the proper approximate results to be selected and validated. More specifically, we have developed in a systematic way a series of basis sets that have been employed for the computation of the polarizability of the Zn atom. Comparison of the computed with the experimental and the best theoretical results allows us to comment on t...
Nanoparticle Formation Kinetics and Mechanistic Studies Important to Mechanism-Based Particle-Size Control: Evidence for Ligand-Based Slowing of the Autocatalytic Surface Growth Step Plus Postulated Mechanisms
Özkar, Saim (American Chemical Society (ACS), 2019-06-06)
Ligands are known to affect the formation, stabilization, size, and size-dispersion control of transition-metal and other nanoparticles, yet the kinetic and mechanistic basis for such ligand effects remains to be elucidated and then coupled to predictions for improved particle size and narrower particle size distribution syntheses. Toward this broad goal, the effect of the added excess ligand (L) and the stabilizer, L = POM9- (= the polyoxometalate, P2W15Nb3O629-) is studied for the formation of POM9--stabi...
Effect of molecular and electronic structure on the light-harvesting properties of dye sensitizers
Mete, E.; Üner, Deniz; Cakmak, M.; Gulseren, O.; Ellialtoglu, S. (American Chemical Society (ACS), 2007-05-24)
The systematic trends in structural and electronic properties of perylenediimide (PDI)-derived dye molecules have been investigated by DFT calculations based on the projector-augmented wave (PAW) method including gradient-corrected exchange-correlation effects. Time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations have been performed to study the visible absorbance activity of these complexes. The effect of different ligands and halogen atoms attached to PDI were studied to characterize the light-ha...
Interaction of BrPDI, BrGly, and BrAsp with the Rutile TiO2(110) Surface for Photovoltaic and Photocatalytic Applications: A First-Principles Study
Cakir, D.; GÜLSEREN, Oğuz; METE, ERSEN; Ellialtıoğlu, Süleyman Şinasi (American Chemical Society (ACS), 2011-05-12)
The adsorption of perylenediimide (PDI)-based dye compounds (BrPDI, BrGly, and BrAsp) on the defect-free unreconstructed (UR) rutile TiO2(110) surface has been studied using total energy pseudopotential calculations based on density functional theory. All dye molecules form moderate chemical bonds with the defect-free UR rutile (110) surface in the most stable adsorption configurations. Electronic structure analysis reveals that HOMO and LUMO levels of the adsorbed dye molecules appear within the band gap a...
Citation Formats
D. R. Handwerk, P. D. Shipman, C. B. Whitehead, S. Özkar, and R. G. Finke, “Particle Size Distributions via Mechanism-Enabled Population Balance Modeling,” JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL CHEMISTRY C, pp. 4852–4880, 2020, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: