An Assessment of BIM-CAREM Against the Selected BIM Capability Assessment Models

2018-10-04
YILMAZ, GÖKÇEN
Akçamete Güngör, Aslı
DEMİRÖRS, ONUR
Although various BIM capability and maturity models have been developed to meet different BIM capability/maturity assessment purposes, there has not been a model which is broadly used and commonly accepeted in the literature. A Reference Model for BIM Capability Assessment (BIM-CAREM) was developed based on the meta-model of ISO/IEC 33000 to be used for assessing BIM capability levels of AEC/FM processes. This paper aims to compare the components of BIM-CAREM with the assessment questions of the identified models from the literature. Moreover, data collected from a previously performed case study was used to carry out self-assessments by using these models. Then, these assessment results were compared with the findings gathered from assessments performed with BIM-CAREM. The comparison indicated that, BIM-CAREM has more detailed and specified questions for assessing BIM capability of different AEC/FM processes and has comparable assessment results to that of identified capability models.

Suggestions

A reference model for BIM capability assessments
Yilmaz, Gokcen; Akçamete Güngör, Aslı; DEMİRÖRS, ONUR (2019-05-01)
Various BIM capability and maturity models have been developed to assist architecture, engineering, construction and facilities management (AEC/FM) organizations in measuring the performance of their BIM utilizations. Due to differences in applicability and focus of these models, they are able to meet the demands of different BIM users. In this study, eight BIM capability and maturity models identified in the literature are compared based on several different criteria. The results show that there is no holi...
A review on capability and maturity models of building ınformation modelling
Yılmaz, Gökçen; Akçamete Güngör, Aslı; Demirörs, Onur (null; 2017-07-07)
Process assessment and maturity models in software engineering are widely used for process improvement. Likewise, assessing BIM capability and maturity have important effects on increasing BIM performance and enhancing benefits of BIM usage. Thus, there are various BIM capability and maturity models in the literature which are important for users to be able to select appropriate model for their BIM assessment purposes. This study aims to identify and analyse BIM capability and maturity models in the constru...
A comparative study on hyperelastic constitutive models on rubber: State of the art after 2006
Dal, Hüsnü; Acikgoz, K.; Denli, F. A. (2019-01-01)
The micromechanically based network models are known to be superior over the purely phenomenological models in the analysis of unfilled rubber. However, various factors play a crucial role in the selection of the appropriate constitutive model for the analysis of technical rubbers. These are; ( i) the number of available experiments under various loading conditions, (ii) maximum stretch level expected in the critical loading scenarios of the rubber component, and (iii) percentage of fillers and additives th...
An energy-based seismic response evaluation of simple structural systems with simulated ground motions
Karimzadeh, Shaghayegh; Ozsarac, V.; Askan, A.; Erberik, Murat Altuğ (Earthquake Engineering Research Institute; 2018-01-01)
In recent years, there has been a strong interest on energy-based design and assessment methods for structural systems. The underlying research has been mostly performed using real ground motion records taken from existing earthquakes worldwide. Results may involve bias due to lack of homogeneity of the available ground motion dataset in terms of magnitudes, source to site distances or soil conditions. In this study a large set of ground motion records is simulated within a parametric exercise to investigat...
An energy-based seismic response evaluation of simple structural systems with simulated ground motions
Karim Zadeh Naghshineh, Shaghayegh; Askan Gündoğan, Ayşegül; Erberik, Murat Altuğ (null; 2017-04-18)
In recent years, there has been a strong interest on energy-based design and assessment methods for structural systems. The underlying research has been mostly performed using real ground motion records taken from existing earthquakes worldwide. Results may involve bias due to lack of homogeneity of the available ground motion dataset in terms of magnitudes, source to site distances or soil conditions. In this study,a large set of ground motion records are simulated within a p...
Citation Formats
G. YILMAZ, A. Akçamete Güngör, and O. DEMİRÖRS, “An Assessment of BIM-CAREM Against the Selected BIM Capability Assessment Models,” 2018, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/48439.