Eastern in the West, Western in the East: Deliberate and ambivalent facets of the identity of early Republican Turkey abroad

This paper represents an attempt to reflect on the Turkish identity in the formation period of the Republic, from its constitution in 1923 until 1939. The discussion is focused around two buildings that were constructed in 1939, both of which were built abroad to represent the new state; the Embassy of Turkey in Tehran and the Turkish pavilion at the New York World's Fair. These buildings were both featured in the same issue of the architectural magazine Mimar, and offer a fruitful starting point for delving into historical and theoretical issues in identity discourse. That said, the paper goes beyond merely analyzing the different formal vocabularies and personalities of the different architects and patrons involved in commissioning these structures. Rather than addressing only the different cultural and architectural responses to the contemporary national identity debate, the paper will also consider the question of whether the host countries and the addressees of these rather symbolic buildings also had a role in their design and evaluation stages. In other words, the study aims to understand how representation in a location in the "West" or in the "East" affects the identity of a nation characterized by its duality of "West" and "East".


Architectural interpretations of modernity cultural identity : a comparative study on Sedad Hakkı Eldem and Bruna Taut in early Republican Turkey
Uysal, Zeynep Çiğdem; Altan, Tomris Elvan; Department of Architecture (2004)
The thesis aims to reveal the decisive influence of the tension that stems from the contemporary searches for cultural identity on the architectural production of the early Republican Turkey. It attempts to demonstrate the conceptual and practical strategies that were devised in contemporary architecture for the resolution of the cultural tension by examining the architectural attitudes and practices of Sedad Hakki Eldem and Bruno Taut in the late 1930s and the early 1940s. In the first part, ءcultural iden...
The formation of Iraqi nationalism under The British mandate (1920- 1932)
Akın, Pırıl; Boztemur, Recep; Department of Middle East Studies (2009)
This thesis examines the development of a national identity and the ideology of nationalism, and the formation of nation-state in Iraq under the British Mandate from 1920 to 1932. The study focuses on the influences of the early Arab nationalist movements during the last decades of the Ottoman Empire and under the British Mandate over Iraqi nationalism and nation-state process. The study specifically examines the Mosul question and its effects on the formation of the territorial unity of the state in Iraq. ...
Kayıp Bellek: Mübadeleden Önce Gölde (İncesu)
Eken, Esra (2019-09-25)
This paper aims to reveal the collective memory of Gölde (İncesu), a neighborhood of Kula-Manisa, before the population exchange in line with the Lausanne Treaty of 1923. Before the population exchange, Rum Orthodox and Turkish Muslim communities were living together in Gölde. The built environment, economic activities, daily life practices, and rituals were shaped by the existence of these two different communities that shared a common life. After the population exchange, the Rum community left the settlem...
Nationalism and religion in the formation of modern state in Turkey and Egypt until World War I
Boztemur, Recep (2005-12-01)
This study discusses the formation of national identity and the nation state in the modern Middle East in comparison with Turkey, one of the earlier models, of national state formation in the region. The basic aim of the study is to examine the position of religion and religious identity as the source of legitimacy in the modern state. In order to have a better understanding of the relationship between nationalism and religion in the Middle East, the study attempts to look at the development of Egyptian nat...
Potential for popular dissemination: an analysis of the "ideal home" discourse in the weekly Yedigün magazine
Tuncer, Melike Usalp; Cengizkan, Ali; Department of Architecture (2006)
The social transformations beginning by the end of the nineteenth century and the political and economic changes of the Early Republican Era (1923-1938) and the Transition Era (1938-1950) had important effects on Turkish architecture. The effects of the ‘new’ and ‘ideal’ life accelerated by the establishment of the new democratic nation state brought rapid changes and transformations to all aspects of life including housing. This study deals with the housing discourse in Yedigün magazine which was published...
Citation Formats
M. H. Zelef, “Eastern in the West, Western in the East: Deliberate and ambivalent facets of the identity of early Republican Turkey abroad,” NEW PERSPECTIVES ON TURKEY, pp. 93–144, 2014, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/53290.