From US with Love: Community Participation, Stakeholder Partnership, and the Exacerbation of Inequality in Rural Jamaica

2011-05-01
This paper examines and argues against the neoliberal assumption that local community participation in market-based nature conservation projects is democratic and leads to community empowerment through economic development. It does so by analyzing the formation of Local Forest Management Committees, instigated by one of the largest US-based environmentalist NGOs - the Nature Conservancy - and its partnering local environmental NGOs for conserving the tropical forests of Cockpit Country, Jamaica. The paper dissects, specifically, the notion of "stakeholder partnership," frequently invoked in neoliberal conservation projects in the global south. Such flattening neoliberal terminologies imply a democratic platform, where different groups can express their political agendas and negotiate their differences with equal power. The language of "stakeholder partnership" flattens, this paper argues, the hierarchical set of power relations both inherited and exacerbated by free market-based conservation projects.
NEW PROPOSALS-JOURNAL OF MARXISM AND INTERDISCIPLINARY INQUIRY

Suggestions

Sustainability of historic rural settlements based on participatory conservation approach: Kemer Village in Turkey
Ekici, Simay Cansu; Özçakır, Özgün; Bilgin Altınöz, Ayşe Güliz (2022-04-01)
Purpose This paper aims to address the issue of the conservation and management of rural cultural heritage, with the aim being to gain an understanding of current problems and needs through a participatory approach, in recognition of the uniqueness of the relationship between nature, humankind and the built environment as an area of study. To this end, a comprehensive case study - Kemer Village in Turkey - focusing on the social sustainability and participatory approaches for the sustainable development of ...
Bringing Critical Political Economy Back In: Neoliberal State Transformations and the Anthropology of the State
Bodırsky, Katharına(2016-12-31)
The objective of the proposed study is to develop a critical political economic approach within the anthropology of the state, an approach that combines the respective strengths of critical political economy and anthropology: a systemic perspective on the role of the state in reproducing unequal social orders with an ethnographic sensibility for global differences and local complexities. The emphasis in the first part of the study in 2016 will be on developing a framework for the study of 1) uneven geograph...
Biomimicry for sustainability : an educational project in sustainable product design
Bakırlıoğlu, Yekta; Doğan, Çağla; Department of Industrial Design (2012)
The notion of sustainability has become an extensive area of research ever since the term emerged in the late 1980s, due to the negative effects of unsustainable production and consumption patterns on environmental stewardship, social equity and economic development. There have been various approaches developed for product design and education within the context sustainability. Biomimicry is one of those approaches, and its implications for product design education have recently started to be explored. In t...
Civic Participation in the Conservation of Multicultural Heritage in Mardin
Karaoğlu Köksalan, İpek; Serin, Ufuk; Department of Architecture (2021-8-05)
Conservation is a selective process, and through heritage policies and management approaches, governments influence what and how heritage is conserved. Adequate and efficient civic participation, implying the participation of the local civic society, local authorities, professional chambers, the third sector, and the private sector, is the only way to establish an equitable conservation process. The input of different stakeholders in a conservation project can bring in rich values and resources. Through com...
Critical Awareness in a Materials Analysis and Development Course
Tezgiden Cakcak, Sebahat Yasemin (null; 2019-02-15)
Recognizing the political nature of teaching English, critical applied linguists have called for including issues of inequality, injustice, social stratification, gender, poverty, exploitation or environmental destruction in language education (Doğançay-Aktuna, 2006; Grabe, Stoller & Tardy, 2001; Gray, 2013; Pennycook, 1994, 2000; Vergera, 2014). This paper tells the story of an attempt to address issues of inequality and injustice through a critical materials analysis and development course in a pre-servic...
Citation Formats
M. B. Kuymulu, “From US with Love: Community Participation, Stakeholder Partnership, and the Exacerbation of Inequality in Rural Jamaica,” NEW PROPOSALS-JOURNAL OF MARXISM AND INTERDISCIPLINARY INQUIRY, pp. 45–58, 2011, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/54004.