Popper's Axiomatic Probability System and the Value-Assignment Problem

Date

2018-12-01

Author

Demir, Mehmet Hilmi

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

132
views

0
downloads

In the standard theory of probability, developed by Kolmogorov, the concept of conditional probability is defined with what is known as the ratio formula: the probability of A given B is the ratio between the probability of A and B and the probability of B, i.e. P(AIB)=(P(AB))/(P(B)). Clearly, this ratio is not defined when the probability of the condition, P(B), is o. According to Popper, this problem, which is known as the zero-denominator problem, shows a serious conceptual shortcoming of the standard Kolmogorovian theory of probability. In order to overcome this shortcoming, Popper developed an alternative axiomatic theory of probability where conditional probability is taken as primitive. It should be noted that this axiomatic probability theory is different than and independent from Popper's philosophy of probability which is based on the propensity approach. Popper claims that his axiomatic theory is a better fit for the use of probability in the philosophy of science and statistics. Based on this claim, it is often stated that Popper's theory is conceptually superior to Kolmogorov's theory. The ultimate aim of this paper is to evaluate this claim by analyzing Popper's axiomatic theory within the context of the zero denominator problem.

Subject Keywords

Conditional probability, Popper, Kolmogorov, Hajek, Zero denominator problem

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/55051

Journal

BEYTULHIKME-AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY

Collections

Department of Philosophy, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Popper’ın Aksiyomatik Olasılık Kuramı ve Değer-Atama Problemi Demir, Mehmet Hilmi (2018-12-01) In the standard theory of probability, developed by Kolmogorov, the concept of conditional probability is defined with what is known as the ratio formula: the probability of A given B is the ratio between the probability of A and B and the probability of B, i.e. P(A|B)= (P(AB))/(P(B)). Clearly, this ratio is not defined when the probability of the condition, P(B), is 0. According to Popper, this problem, which is known as the zero-denominator problem, shows a serious conceptual shortcoming of the standard ...
The influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking: A case study with teacher candidates Olgun, Beyza; Işıksal Bostan, Mine (2019-12-21) This study investigates the influence of the context of conditional probability problems on probabilistic thinking processes of mathematics teacher candidates. Data were collected from four mathematics teacher candidates through semi-structured clinical interviews. Teacher candidates were expected to solve and explain three conditional probability problems, which were selected based on specific contexts. The findings revealed that, when the context is related to a social issue such as health or justice, tha...
APPROXIMATION OF EXCESSIVE BACKLOG PROBABILITIES OF TWO TANDEM QUEUES Sezer, Ali Devin (2018-09-01) Let X be the constrained random walk on Z(+)(2) having increments (1, 0), (-1, 1), and (0, -1) with respective probabilities A lambda,mu 1, and mu 2 representing the lengths of two tandem queues. We assume that X is stable and mu 1 not equal mu 2. Let tau(n) be the first time when the sum of the components of X equals n. Let Y be the constrained random walk on Z x Z(+) having increments (-1, 0), (1, 1), and (0, -1) with probabilities lambda, mu(1), and mu(2). Let tau be the first time that the components of...
ANALYTIC AND ASYMPTOTIC PROPERTIES OF LINNIKS PROBABILITY DENSITIES HAYFAVI, A; KOTZ, S; OSTROVSKII, IV (1994-11-03) The analytic and asymptotic properties of the probability density p(alpha) (x) introduced in 1953 by Ju. V. Linnik and defined by the characteristic function 1/(1 + \t\(alpha)), 0 < alpha < 2, are studied. Expansions of p(alpha) (x) into convergent and asymptotic series in terms of log \x\, \x\(k alpha) , \x\(k) (k = 0, 1, 2,...) are obtained. It turns out that the analytic structure of p(alpha) (x) depends substantially on the arithmetical nature of the parameter alpha.
Factorization of Joint Probability Mass Functions into Parity Check Interactions Bayramoglu, Muhammet Fatih; Yılmaz, Ali Özgür (2009-07-03) We show that any joint probability mass function (PMF) can be expressed as a product of parity check factors an d factors of degree one with the help of some auxiliary variables, if the alphabet size is appropriate for defining a parity chec k equation. In other words, marginalization of a joint PMF is equivalent to a soft decoding task as long as a finite field can be constructed over the alphabet of the PMF. In factor graph terminology this claim means that a factor graph representing such a joint PMF alw...

Citation Formats

M. H. Demir, “Popper’s Axiomatic Probability System and the Value-Assignment Problem,” BEYTULHIKME-AN INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHY, pp. 455–469, 2018, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/55051.