Loss Of Intrinsic Qualities Of Urban Form And Local Social Processes In The Face Of Globalisation: Case Of Karachi’s Old Town

2020
Ahmed, Suneela
In their aspiration to imitate cities of the west, many cities in the context of the developing world blindly copy the built form being constructed in other contexts, irrespective of the fact that this imitation may lead to creation of built form which may not be climatically, socially and economically relevant. As a certain type of building is supposed to represent modernism and the future, thus this exercise of copy pasting continues. This practice is evident in all major cities of Pakistan. At ground reality, the perception of space, by the local communities, is not always related to the physical form. The social attachment of the communities with the built form cannot be translated, either linguistically or physically, into other languages. Through the influence of foreign imported design language, significant aspect of local built form is lost in newer developments that aspire to project a global image. There are certain words of the local language used by communities and residents that describe urban space and spaces within buildings, in a particular manner. These words lose their physical and conceptual essence if they are translated in foreign languages. Using mixed methods, based on semi structured interviews, focus groups, urban form documentation, archive review and personal observation, this research postulates lessons from its study of local built form production on the value given to local places by communities and the impact of global forces. This paper analyses an indigenous locality in Karachi, Pakistan, identifying certain words associated with urban spaces and local built form, which cannot be translated into the official planning language, which is English. The research identifies that urban anthropologists are better positioned to understand the way locals associate with built form because of their crossdisciplinary approach to analyzing the society, as compared to built form theorists. It also identifies that there is a requirement to analyze places at diverse global and local scales to understand what urban forms need to be retained and to understand that these spatial models are contextual, rather than universal. The research attempts to highlight the meanings associated with local form that contribute to social setups and is reflected through the usage of certain terminologies. This recognition can in turn help professionals understand which built form is valued by locals, and how and why is it valued.

Suggestions

Challenges and conflicts in achieving sustainable communities in historic neighbourhoods of Istanbul
Akkar Ercan, Zübeyde Müge (2011-04-01)
Although urban regeneration has been widely seen as a panacea to resolve the multi-faceted problems of cities over the last two decades, a broad section of literature suggests the need for questioning the impacts of urban regeneration projects as an integral part of neo-liberal policies. In the context of Turkey, by focusing on Istanbul, this article aims to investigate the success of the regeneration initiatives in achieving sustainable communities in deprived historic housing neighbourhoods. After definin...
Transformation of a public space in İstanbul: the Eminönü Square
Çin, Tümay; Bilsel, Fatma Cânâ; Department of City and Regional Planning (2006)
Urban public spaces have always been subjected to physical, economical,social, political and cultural transformations of the city. These changing dynamics could cause decay in the spatial qualities and could also lead to a loss of values and identities of urban spaces, especially in public spaces. This thesis explores the qualities of a particular urban space in Istanbul: the Eminönü Square. Providing a guideline for the future urban design projects,the structure and the identity of the historical public sp...
Transformative Urban Railway: Ankara Commuter Line and Lost Landscape
Baş Bütüner, Funda; Aral, Hacer Ela (2017-09-27)
Being major transportation infrastructure of the 19th and early 20th centuries, the impacts of railways on cities have highly directed urban studies,. deforming material edge of cities, encouraging urban extension, forming new territories, and speeding up urban development. However, in recent decades, with newly emerging landscape infrastructure practice, a new idea for a more integrated infrastructure and landscape system has started to be formulated. Railway strips, occurring as territories where solid-vo...
Changing Perspectives on the Planning of Ankara 1924 2007 and Lessons for a New Master Planning Approach to Developing Cities
Çalışkan, Olgu (2009-11-01)
As one of the newly planned capitals in the 20th century - like Islamabad, Canberra and Brazil-, Ankara represents an original case in planning history: from shaping a new town under the influence of early European urbanism to the control of a dynamic metropolitan form by structural planning approaches. Forming its urban core according to the initial planning perspectives between the beginning of 1930s and the mid-1970s, the city has entered a rapid phase of space production in its extensions for about the ...
Smart Cities and the Idea of Smartness in Urban Development - A Critical Review
Husar, Milan; Ondrejicka, Vladimir; Varis, Sila Ceren (2017-06-16)
The concept of smart cities is becoming another mantra for both developing and developed cities. For instance, Indian government in 2015 announced its objective to build one hundred smart cities all over the country. They clearly stated that they are choosing smart development as the underlying concept for their future growth as a way to foster economic development in smart way to avoid the paths of rapid industrialization and pollution of cities as it took place in Europe and United States. The first of th...
Citation Formats
S. Ahmed, “Loss Of Intrinsic Qualities Of Urban Form And Local Social Processes In The Face Of Globalisation: Case Of Karachi’s Old Town,” ODTÜ Mimarlık Fakültesi Dergisi, vol. 37, no. 1, pp. 149–168, 2020, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: http://jfa.arch.metu.edu.tr/archive/0258-5316/articles/metujfa2020110.pdf.