Comparison of safety factors obtained from limit equilibrium methods and finite element analyses

2012-06-30
Engin, Volkan
Toker, Nabi Kartal
Designing with limit equilibrium methods involves a factor of safety as a measure of stability, i.e. how far the resisting structure is from the limit state, on the safe side. On the other hand, current engineering practice employs finite element programs (such as PLAXIS) which, instead of using a conventionally-defined factor of safety, reduces the overall shear strength of the soil by introducing a reduction factor that is applied to soil strength (i.e. tan  and c values). Such fundamental differences in the incorporation of safety into the design process leads to different results from limit equilibrium methods and finite element simulations. In this parametric study, retaining walls, both cantilever and supported at a single level, with variable height and soil properties, are analyzed as example problems. For each case, multiple factors of safety are determined using different limit equilibrium methods found in the literature. In computer models, safety factor is defined in a variety of ways, based on; working and ultimate loads or stresses, normal & shear stresses along failure planes and reduction of soil strength.The safety factors from different methods are compared and relations between them were investigated by least squares regression analysis. Consequently, correlations among and between the safety factors obtained from limit equilibrium methods and finite element modeling results are proposed. Results of different limit equilibrium solution procedures are found to be linearly correlated with each other without involving soil strength parameters. Success of the FEM-based methods is found to vary based on the soil and support type.

Suggestions

Comparison of factor of safety obtained from limit equilibrium methods with strength reduction factors in finite element modeling
Engin, Volkan; Toker, Nabi Kartal; Erol, Orhan; Department of Civil Engineering (2012)
Designing with Limit Equilibrium Methods involve a factor of safety (FS) in order to maintain the stability and to keep the resisting structure away from limit state on the safe side. Finite Element Program (such as Plaxis) on the other hand, instead of an FS, reduces the shear strength of the soil by introducing a reduction factor that is applied to tanɸ & c values, resulting in different analysis results compared with Limit Equilibrium Methods results. This study aims to associate tanɸ & c reduction facto...
Analysis of RC walls with a mixed formulation frame finite element
Sarıtaş, Afşin (2013-10-01)
This paper presents a mixed formulation frame element with the assumptions of the Timoshenko shear beam theory for displacement field and that accounts for interaction between shear and normal stress at material level. Nonlinear response of the element is obtained by integration of section response, which in turn is obtained by integration of material response. Satisfaction of transverse equilibrium equations at section includes the interaction between concrete and transverse reinforcing steel. A 3d plastic...
Influence of deformable geofoam bufers on the static and dynamic behaviors of cantilever retaining walls
Ertuğrul, Özgür Lütfi; Özkan, M. Yener; Department of Civil Engineering (2011)
Static and dynamic interaction mechanism of the retained soil-compressible geofoam buffer and yielding retaining structures requires further investigation. The present study, initiated on this motive, discusses the results of 1-g physical model tests and numerical analyses of cantilever retaining walls with and without deformable geofoam buffers between the wall and cohesionless granular backfill. 0.7m high walls with various wall thicknesses were utilized in the physical modeling. Dynamic tests were carrie...
Reliability analysis of a rock slope in Sumela monastery, Turkey, based on discrete element and response surface methods
Dadashzadeh, Neda; Düzgün, H. Şebnem; Department of Mining Engineering (2015)
It is widely recognized that a single factor of safety (FOS) calculated by traditional deterministic analysis methods may not represent slope safety due to involved uncertainties. The First Order Reliability Method (FORM) is one of the extensively used probabilistic methods in slope stability studies to quantify the uncertainties in the parameters. FORM can be easily applied when the slope is analyzed based on limit equilibrium methods. However, the recent numerical techniques are almost substituted by the ...
Probabilistic Assessment of Overtopping Reliability of a Dam
Yanmaz, Ali Melih (2006-05-23)
Probabilistic methods, which consider resistance and load parameters as random variables, are more realistic than conventional deterministic methods for determining the safety level of a dam. This study is based on a probabilistic assessment of overtopping reliability of a flood detention dam. In the analysis, the inflow hydrograph parameters and the initial reservoir level prior to the allocation of the flood in the reservoir are accepted as random variables. A bivariate flood frequency analysis is perform...
Citation Formats
V. Engin and N. K. Toker, “Comparison of safety factors obtained from limit equilibrium methods and finite element analyses,” Lefkoşa, Cyprus (KKTC), 2012, p. 811, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/73723.