Analyzing generalizations through discourse

2016-11-03
Strachota, Susanne
İşler Baykal, Işıl
Fonger, Nicole
Blanton, Maria
Gardiner, Angela Murphy
Although generalizing is “intrinsic to mathematical activity and thinking” (Kaput, 1999, p. 137), students struggle to generalize, often make weak generalizations, and rarely justify their generalizations. Supporting generalizing in the mathematics classroom requires a better understanding of the source of students’ generalizing. What are the mechanisms that encourage students’ generalizing? This question is central to our research, which seeks to understand the nature of the discourse that supports students’ generalizing. This study explored the ways in which a fourth grade class generalized and justified their generalizations about even and odd numbers during a lesson. We conducted a multi-level analysis of the classroom discourse, identifying shifts and instances of re-centering. Based on the inferred goal of the speaker, each utterance was coded for purpose and technique for fulfilling that purpose (Gonzalez & DeJarnette, 2012). Additionally, we recorded generalizations (Ellis, 2011), and situated these generalizations in the discourse in order to describe the discursive moves that contributed to and resulted from the generalizations. Two important shifts in the discourse occurred during the lesson. First, the mode of representation shifted from an array to a number expression—a shift in representation that indicates a shift in discourse. Second, after establishing “cubes and left over cubes” as a shared way to describe even and odd number generalizations, students shifted from using “left over/leftover” as a modifier or adjective to using it as a noun, an indication of an evolving understanding of the shared idea. Although five generalizations occurred during the lesson, they all occurred during the second half of the lesson, subsequent to the shifts in discourse. Thus, the results suggest that the shifts in discourse may function as generalizing-promoting actions (Ellis, 2011). We also identified particular discursive techniques, and suggest that future research might focus on these aspects of discourse to further explore generalizing-promoting actions.
38th Annual Meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (3 - 6 Kasım 2016)

Suggestions

Developing a Learning Progression for Curriculum, Instruction, and Student Learning: An Example from Mathematics Education
Fonger, Nicole L.; Stephens, Ana; Blanton, Maria; İşler Baykal, Işıl; Knuth, Eric; Gardiner, Angela Murphy (2018-01-01)
Learning progressions have been demarcated by some for science education, or only concerned with levels of sophistication in student thinking as determined by logical analyses of the discipline. We take the stance that learning progressions can be leveraged in mathematics education as a form of curriculum research that advances a linked understanding of students learning over time through careful articulation of a curricular framework and progression, instructional sequence, assessments, and levels of sophi...
An analysis of middle school students’ generalization of linear patterns.
Kama, Zeycan; Işıksal Bostan, Mine; Department of Elementary Science and Mathematics Education (2020)
The purpose of the present study was to explore sixth, seventh, and eighth grade students’ generalizations of patterns using arithmetical generalization, algebraic generalization, and naïve induction. In addition to studying their generalization process, the study also focuses on how this process of generalization differs according to their grade level. The study employed a qualitative case study design. The data were collected from five sixth grade, four seventh grade, and five eighth grade students during...
Growth in children's understanding of generalizing and representing mathematical structure and relationships
Blanton, Maria; İşler Baykal, Işıl; Stroud, Rena; Stephens, Ana; Knuth, Eric; Gardiner, Angela Murphy (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2019-10-01)
We share here results from a quasi-experimental study that examines growth in students' algebraic thinking practices of generalizing and representing generalizations, particularly with variable notation, as a result of an early algebra instructional sequence implemented across grades 3-5. Analyses showed that, while there were no significant differences between experimental and control students on a grade 3 pre-assessment measuring students' capacity for generalizing and representing generalizations, experi...
The interplay between students’ understandings of proportional and functional relationships
Stephens, Ana; Strachota, Susanne; Knuth, Eric; Blanton, Maria; İşler Baykal, Işıl; Gardiner, Angela Murphy (Association of Mathematics Teacher Educators; 2017-10-08)
This research explores the interplay between students’ understandings of proportional and functional relationships. Approximately 90 students participated in an early algebra intervention in Grades 3– 5. Before the intervention and after each year of the intervention, we evaluated their understandings of proportional and functional relationships. Data revealed that among Grades 4 and 5 students who identified a correct function rule, a higher percentage were unsuccessful solving a proportional reasoning pro...
Investigation into prospective middle school mathematics teachers' noticing of students' algebraic thinking within the context of pattern generalization
Özel, Zeynep.; Işıksal Bostan, Mine; Department of Secondary Science and Mathematics Education (2019)
The purpose of this study was to investigate prospective middle school mathematics teachers’ noticing skills of students’ algebraic thinking within the context of pattern generalization. In order to obtain in- depth exploration and understanding of issue, the qualitative research method, in particular, the case study design was used. Thirty-two prospective teachers who were studying at one of the public universities located in Ankara were selected via purposive sampling as participants. Data was collected i...
Citation Formats
S. Strachota, I. İşler Baykal, N. Fonger, M. Blanton, and A. M. Gardiner, “Analyzing generalizations through discourse,” presented at the 38th Annual Meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (3 - 6 Kasım 2016), Tucson, Arizona, USA, 2016, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: http://www.pmena.org/pmenaproceedings/PMENA%2038%202016%20Proceedings.pdf.