A Young Brother at the Forefront of a Nuclear War: The Role of Robert F. Kennedy in the Resolution of the Cuban Missile Crisis

2019-12-24
The event of 1962 known as the Cuban Missile Crisis was the conglomeration of a series of diplomatic negotiations, maneuvers resembling a chess game which was more complex than it appears today. In this complexity, though his own views evolved throughout the ExComm meetings, Robert F. Kennedy had undoubtedly the key role in many aspects as the brother and the closest advisor to the President John F. Kennedy. As the meeting facilitator during the discussions of ExComm with his flexible views and as the secret messenger and negotiator of his elder brother with the Soviets, influenced the process and the dissolution of the crisis positively. This study will argue the significance of Robert Kennedy’s role in decision making and the resolution steps of the Cuban Missile Crisis. Robert Francis (Bobby) Kennedy was an American politician, a Democratic Senator from New York, and a well-known civil rights activist. Referred as an icon of modern American liberalism, he was the younger brother of John F. Kennedy, i.e., the President’s confidante and acted as his closest advisor along with his influential post as the US Attorney General. His role in such a significant event during the Cold War was also an indicative of how the US President at that time ruled American Foreign Policy and his country, which resembled a series of meetings of a board of trustees for a big private company. Another pinpoint of Kennedy administration concerning the crisis was that being a dominant foreign policy issue, Cuba, as physically the closest but everlasting enemy to the States, was at one of its peaks during Kennedy administration. On the one hand, communist led Castro administration was aligning with the Russians and requesting for military protection from Moscow; but on the other hand, Kennedy and his team were planning either to overthrow Castro or to invade the island to turn it into a place where they assumed the Cuban island would be immune to communism. Their understanding would appear itself as the famous `quarantine` term during the crisis. The Cuban Missile Crisis was a confrontation between the Soviet Union, Cuba and the United States in October 1962, during the Cold War. In September 1962, the Cuban and Soviet governments began to build bases in Cuba for a number of medium and intermediate-range ballistic nuclear missiles with the ability to strike most of the continental United States. The Soviets publicly balked at the U.S. demands when the crisis became a public issue, but in secret back-channel communications involving Bobby Kennedy and initiated a proposal to resolve the crisis. Two weeks later the confrontation ended when on October 28, 1962 President John F. Kennedy and the United Nations Secretary-General U Thant reached an agreement with the Soviets to dismantle the missiles in exchange for an agreement to never invade Cuba. In his negotiations with the Soviet Ambassador Anatoly Dobrynin, U.S. Attorney General Robert Kennedy informally proposed that the Jupiter missiles in Turkey would be removed within a short time after this crisis was over. Cuban Missile Crisis proved how important the flexible and unorthodox way of crisis management was. In this particular crisis management, many actors were involved ranging from Soviet leader N. Khrushchev to McNamara and from ExComm to Former secretary of State Dean Acheson with various and time to time controversial ideas. However, one of the most striking and significant ones came from Robert F. Kennedy, the Attorney General and the younger brother of the President. Although the Cuban Missile Crisis was a very complex issue involving nuclear war, back door diplomacy, ExComm meetings, containment policy and superiority race of the big powers, it taught us some lessons. Robert F. Kennedy emerged as one of these lessons by demonstrating how rigid and hawkish ideas may end up with rather dovish and moderate ones when country and humanity were concerned as well as proved how brotherhood, trust may help the crisis to resolve. Evolution of Robert F. Kennedy’s ideas, even within a month period, indicated his adoption capacity to new situation in world politics, which in fact originated as very fix and rigid views. As personal characteristics of Robert F. Kennedy, flexibility, intelligence, brotherhood, idealism all contributed to help resolve the Cuban Missile Crisis. When the world was right on the brink of a nuclear war, these traits along with the trajectory of the crisis worked hand in hand for the solution of a serious problem and more towards a positive direction. This stood as a permanent model and should be used as examples even for today’s complicated political and humanitarian issues.

Suggestions

Miscarriages of Revisionist Analysis of the Cold War
Akdan, Tolgahan (2016-12-04)
This paper attempts to make an analysis of the Cold War revisionism through which it will make a critical appraisal of how revisionist historians interpret the Cold War struggle between the US and the Soviet Union. Though now established as a specific episode in history, the Cold War has always been a subject of intense debate among historians, political scientists as well as scholars of International Relations throughout the past half century, not only for its historical significance in shaping the fate of...
The security perception of the Russian Federation and its military doctrines in the post-cold war era
Denker, Nilüfer Eda; Adalı, Orhan; Department of Eurasian Studies (2006)
In this thesis the Russian Federation is investigated to understand if it still tries to continue its classic Soviet style of security perception in the post-Cold War era and its views concerning national security as reflected in Russia's military doctrines. It is so obvious that the disintegration of the Soviet Union and the emrgence of Russia as an independent entity in the post-cold war era have compelled the Russian Federation to redefine its national interest. In this context it experienced a crisis of...
Russian compatriots in the near abroad and the construction of the post-soviet russian identity
Kaya, Rüştü; Kuşçu Bonnenfant, Işık; Department of Eurasian Studies (2016)
This thesis examines the impact of the existence of multimillion Russian diaspora in the former-Soviet republics on the nation building policies of the post-Soviet Russia. With the dissolution of the Soviet Union, twenty-five millions of ethnic Russians found themselves beyond the borders of the Russian Federation. The responsibilities of the newly independent Russian state toward the Russian communities in the Near Abroad and regarding them as an integral part of the Russian state and nation have bocome th...
A Clausewitzian reading of Russian intervention in the Syrian civil war
Al, Nazife; Tür Küçükkaya, Özlem; Department of International Relations (2017)
This thesis aims to analyse Russian intervention in the Syria civil war by taking into account Clausewitzian approach to war and strategy theories. In this context, the thesis focuses on two dimensions of the case in terms of its relevance to Clausewitzian approach. After giving a review of Clausewitzian dictum of war and strategy by an assessment of his Trinitarian approach to war, transformation of Russian strategic thinking in 2000s and Russian Federation's view of international system is being assessed ...
Shifting alliances in Europe from the Congress of Vienna to the Congress of Berlin (1815- 1878)
Keyvanoğlu, Merve Cemile; Soykut, Mustafa; Department of History (2015)
The aim of this thesis is to examine the historical background of the alliances that European Great Powers created for the first time in terms of mutual benefits after wars had ended with the Congress of Vienna in 1815, and the interruption of these alliances with the wars between the Ottoman Empire and Russia (The Crimean War and Ottoman- Russian War, etc.) in the light of Ottoman archival documents. A number of social, political, and economic reasons had some effects on the foundation of these alliances w...
Citation Formats
İ. Yorgun, “A Young Brother at the Forefront of a Nuclear War: The Role of Robert F. Kennedy in the Resolution of the Cuban Missile Crisis,” Adana, Türkiye, 2019, p. 150, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.insackongre.com/incsesproceedings.