Inevitable Cycle of Higher Education (ICoHE): Exploring the Impact of World Ranking Systems on Higher Education Institutions and their Public Communication on University Performance.

2018-09-03
The evidence on the impact of university rankings on the ways higher education institutions (HEIs) represent themselves to their stakeholders is needed. It is a matter of common knowledge that rankings or performance metrics developed for academic evaluation are utilized to imply “high quality” education that HEIs provide. In what ways the institutions present themselves on the results of world rankings to the public are yet to be discovered for it is a complex task. The complexity lies in the fact that big portion of the data is produced by the outsiders, aka ranking agencies. Within this context, considering the fact that HEIs are defined as loose-coupling systems, there are weaker links between subsystems responding the incidents happen around HEIs slowly. For loosely coupled systems, it is harder to communicate, evaluate predictability, control their processes, and achieve their goals (Lutz, 1982). There is little known about the use of evaluation metrics provided by university rankings in university governance particularly in controlling these loosely coupled work systems of academia (Glaser et al., 2002). Before ranking systems have emerged, HEIs have had fewer side effects in terms their communication with the public in regards to its performance and quality. The traditional institutional communication on university performance would include reputation of the university alumni as well as its faculty members. This traditional communication would be more of a “word of mouth” than what it is right now. With the developments and innovations in information communication systems, this traditional apporach may have lost its power in public. Today’s world ranking systems interfere with this linear traditional communication in the sense that they now develop a data set through WoS or Scopus in addition to the institutional data that HEIs provide based on the ranking indicators. Ranking systems are now right in the middle of this communication network between HEIs and public where HEIs have even less control over the evaluation of their performances in regards to different matters. This new forms of communication, we call Inevitable Cycle of Higher Education (ICoHE), brings serious restrictions and concerns over HEIs in reflecting their performance. In De Ricjke et al. (2016)’s literature review on how evaluation practices and indicator use affect HEIs and provided four major implications: strategic behavior, goal displacement, task reduction and some potential biases toward interdisciplinarity. Leiden Manifesto with its ten principles (Leiden Manifesto Official Website, n.d.) clearly states that rankings are spreading fast but they are not well-informed and most of the time not applied it right. Therefore, it is critical to elicit how higher education leaders and administrators perceive and reflect world ranking results in their practices and decision making. Even though most higher education institutions are agains the idea of ranking, they can also not avoid the results and impact of ranking, which creates an ineviatable cycle for higher education. Thus, it needs to be examined how higher education institutions integrate or respond to the world rankings in their communication with the public on the university performance.
European Conference on Educational Research, 3 - 07 September 2018

Suggestions

Perspective of Academics on the Impact of Academic Practice
Kondakçı, Yaşar; Zayim Kurtay, Merve; Şenay, Hanife Hilal; Kaya Kaşıkcı, Sevgi; Kulakoğlu, Büşra (Oxford University Press, 2021-5-24)
The pressure on the universities to take a visible place in the rankings has caused anachronistic policies and practices in evaluating the performance of universities. The value attributed to the rankings results in policies prioritizing the criteria imposed by rankings while evaluating the performance of academics, which successively causes several issues in assessing the real impact of the academic practices. Considering these criticisms and concerns about the impact assessment, this study aimed at explor...
Uncovering the relationship between student engagement and organizational culture in a public university in Turkey
Borhan, Ersan.; Emil, Serap; Department of Educational Administration and Planning Education (2020)
Student engagement has become a seminal phenomenon in recent higher education studies since it is associated with both desirable student outcomes and the quality of higher education policies and practices. It is defined as the time and energy devoted by the students to their studies and institutional efforts to create effective educational environment. Although the literature has given in-depth comprehension about the role of organizational characteristics in engagement, there has been few studies touching ...
Modeling the college application decision process in a land-grant university
DesJardins, SL; Dundar, H; Hendel, DD (1999-02-01)
Over the past two decades as student recruitment has become increasingly important, numerous studies have examined the college choice process in an attempt to identify factors influencing students' decision making. The findings from these studies are particularly helpful for college administrators in identifying a potential pool of desirable students and in implementing new recruitment techniques. In this study we used a logistic regression model to investigate the effects of variables relating student char...
Improving academic advising: a case study
Demir, Ayhan Gürbüz; Ok, Ahmet (Hacettepe Üniversitesi, 2001-01-01)
The purposeof this study was to investigate the proposals of advisors and students for improving academic advising. The 287 academic advisors and 735 students from different departments participated in this study. Students and academic advisors were asked to state their proposals on how to improve the effectiveness of the presentacademic advising system at METU. The proposals obtained from academic advisors and students were qualitatively analysed regardless of studentgrade level and academic advisors' depa...
Is there a job after college?: Higher education’s impact on transition from school to work
Bayırbağ, Mustafa Kemal (Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi (Ankara, Turkey), 2013-12-1)
This article examines the impact of the design/organisation of higher education system on the determination of the career paths, and thus the patterns of post-graduate unemployment, of university students. The findings of the article come from a field research conducted among the 2011 graduates of the Faculty of Economic and Administrative Sciences (FEAS) of Middle East Technical University (METU). The research results highlight the existence of four different strategies as students cope with the transition...
Citation Formats
S. Emil and C. Acartürk, “Inevitable Cycle of Higher Education (ICoHE): Exploring the Impact of World Ranking Systems on Higher Education Institutions and their Public Communication on University Performance.,” presented at the European Conference on Educational Research, 3 - 07 September 2018, 2018, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/79898.