Perspective of Academics on the Impact of Academic Practice

Date

2021-5-24

Author

Kondakçı, Yaşar
Zayim Kurtay, Merve
Şenay, Hanife Hilal
Kaya Kaşıkcı, Sevgi
Kulakoğlu, Büşra

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

270
views

0
downloads

The pressure on the universities to take a visible place in the rankings has caused anachronistic policies and practices in evaluating the performance of universities. The value attributed to the rankings results in policies prioritizing the criteria imposed by rankings while evaluating the performance of academics, which successively causes several issues in assessing the real impact of the academic practices. Considering these criticisms and concerns about the impact assessment, this study aimed at exploring the perceptions of academics about the impact of their academic practices. Adapting the interpretive phenomenological design, the data were collected through semi-structured interviews with 20 participants from the field of education in five flagship universities of Turkey. The findings of the study revealed that, although impact assessment understanding of the academics and their institutions go parallel with covering the practices around three basic missions of the university, many activities go in between without recognition by the same impact assessment practices. Interestingly, the academics exhibited their commitment to institutional policies in impact assessment practices; however, they exhibit resentment for the same policies due to failing to recognize the localized mission of the university, threatening the deeply rooted values of the academy, fouling the academy with ethical violations, and causing further detachment between academic practices and societal needs. The concerns and criticism of the current impact assessment are likely to alter the priorities of the universities and push them to adapt an impact assessment, which is less relevant to the local needs of their societies.

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/71497

Journal

Research Evaluation

DOI

https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1093/reseval/rvab015

Collections

Department of Mathematics and Science Education, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Inevitable Cycle of Higher Education (ICoHE): Exploring the Impact of World Ranking Systems on Higher Education Institutions and their Public Communication on University Performance. Emil, Serap; Acartürk, Cengiz (null; 2018-09-03) The evidence on the impact of university rankings on the ways higher education institutions (HEIs) represent themselves to their stakeholders is needed. It is a matter of common knowledge that rankings or performance metrics developed for academic evaluation are utilized to imply “high quality” education that HEIs provide. In what ways the institutions present themselves on the results of world rankings to the public are yet to be discovered for it is a complex task. The complexity lies in the fact that big...
Uncovering the relationship between student engagement and organizational culture in a public university in Turkey Borhan, Ersan.; Emil, Serap; Department of Educational Administration and Planning Education (2020) Student engagement has become a seminal phenomenon in recent higher education studies since it is associated with both desirable student outcomes and the quality of higher education policies and practices. It is defined as the time and energy devoted by the students to their studies and institutional efforts to create effective educational environment. Although the literature has given in-depth comprehension about the role of organizational characteristics in engagement, there has been few studies touching ...
Antecedents of Trust in Buyer-Supplier Relations in Developing Countries: The Case of the Turkish Automotive Sector Wasti Pamuksuz, Syeda Nazlı (2009-03-01) Despite the fact that academic literature on interfirm trust initially focused on US and Japanese firms, there has been an increase in studies of other nations in recent years. In particular, these studies have underlined the different dynamics of trust formation in developing countries. The purpose of this study is to develop a model demonstrating how the antecedents of trust differ as to the inherent environmental and cultural characteristics of developing nations. Based on Dyer and Chu's (2000) model, th...
Conflicting Perspectives on the Internationalization of Higher Education: Evidence from the Turkish Case Bulut Şahin, Betül; Kondakçı, Yaşar (2022-09-01) The internationalization of higher education (IHE) has become a key policy issue for governments, a research field for scholars, a strategic priority for universities, and a career orientation for administrative staff. Yet, with recent social, political, and economic trends heavily embellished by globalization and neoliberalism, the term IHE has resulted in conflicting perspectives. Although there are numerous analyses on IHE, these analyses seldom focus on conflicts among different constituencies of the un...
A comparative analysis of global and national university ranking systems Çakır, Murat Perit; Acartürk, Cengiz (2015-06-01) Recent interest towards university rankings has led to the development of several ranking systems at national and global levels. Global ranking systems tend to rely on internationally accessible bibliometric databases and reputation surveys to develop league tables at a global level. Given their access and in-depth knowledge about local institutions, national ranking systems tend to include a more comprehensive set of indicators. The purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic comparison of national an...

Citation Formats

Y. Kondakçı, M. Zayim Kurtay, H. H. Şenay, S. Kaya Kaşıkcı, and B. Kulakoğlu, “Perspective of Academics on the Impact of Academic Practice,” Research Evaluation, 2021, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/71497.