Between open source and commerce micropolitics of authorship and originality in a knitting community

Taşdizen, Burak
Kaygan, Harun
DIY communities are celebrated for they democratize design through empowering users and help display creativity and express personal identity; and they are often presented as a counterpoint to mainstream patterns of production and consumption (Atkinson, 2006; Edwards, 2006). However, the pro-user and anti-commercial aspect of DIY tends to be overplayed. Knitting, a DIY activity which has at its core the free circulation and building upon of existing knitting patterns, is an example in which we can witness everyday social interactions between DIYers that may help qualify DIY’s open and counter-commercial image. To understand this better, we have conducted a three-month ethnographic study at a knitting community in Ankara. The community gathers in a space that is reserved for this purpose in a shop, governed by the shop owners and two knitting tutors, where women knitters come together to knit, to practice, and to exchange ideas and critiques. In this special setting, the micropolitics that surround the authorship and originality of knitted artefacts become particularly visible. Conflicts arise between and among tutors and knitters over the circulation of knitting patterns, as participants claim ownership and authorship on the patterns, as well as their own interpretations of and improvements over the patterns, against those who try to decode and reproduce those. The aim of this paper is to demonstrate how an uncritical view of DIY as thoroughly democratic and transparent conceals the practices of value attribution around the patterns and know-how at the level of actual practice, and highlight the need to constantly watch out for gravitations from open-source sharing towards commercial ownership, from the collective towards the hierarchical, so that we can underline practices that strengthen the activist, countercultural potential of DIY.
15th Annual STS Conference: Critical Issues in Science, Technology and Society Studies, (9 - 10 Mayıs 2016)


Investigating open design using jugaad as a cultural probe
Hasan, Aleena; Pedgley, Owaın Francıs; Department of Industrial Design (2021-12-01)
Design democratization has been a growing movement around the world, blurring the boundary between the roles of users and designers and encouraging design-after-design that makes the process of designing more inclusive. Open Design is one such approach that encourages no limits in terms of the kind, time, or space of the contribution. While a very primary attribute of this approach is inclusivity, there is a lack of exploration in terms of actual application of the process in a tangible product design proce...
Harnessing children's creativity in contextmapping activities
Özakar, Aslı Deniz; Pedgley, Owaın Francıs; Gilen, Mathieu; Department of Industrial Design (2010)
Recently developed co-design methods ask for users’ creative outcomes all through the design process. Designers are familiar with the creative process but users are not. The heuristic tasks given to users should reveal their creativity and harness it for high-quality outcomes. Contextmapping is a new co-design method following the same need as others; the method involves generative sessions in which users are asked to create artifacts communicating their needs and dreams about future products. Children are ...
Perceived values of web based collective design platforms from the perspective of industrial designers in reference to Quirky and OpenIDEO
Hajiamiri, Milad; Korkut, Fatma (2015-03-01)
Web-based collective design platforms are virtual environments which highly rely on large-scale participation of people from diverse backgrounds in different phases of the design process. Understanding and motivating participants is important to enhance the diversity of solutions and approaches in such platforms. This study investigates the motivation factors for the designer members of the crowd, and explores the perceived values of these platforms from the perspective of industrial designers. An empirical...
Discourses of Exclusion and Hate in the Online Space in the Turkish Context: #ülkemdesuriyeliistemiyorum (#idontwantsyriansinmycountry)
Erdoğan Öztürk, Yasemin; Işık Güler, Hale (2020-06-01)
The new communicative affordances of online spaces have transformed the ways and domains we build and negotiate meaning. At the same time, they have introduced diverse channels to produce and disseminate animosity. This article explores online discourses as new communicative environments characterized by their unique textual and semiotic features to unfold the discursive constructions of hate and hostility towards Syrian refugees in Turkey. Building on the principles of the Social Media Critical Discourse S...
Analyzing and Predicting Privacy Settings in the Social Web
Naini, Kaweh Djafari; Altıngövde, İsmail Sengör; Kawase, Ricardo; Herder, Eelco; Niederee, Claudia (2015-07-03)
Social networks provide a platform for people to connect and share information and moments of their lives. With the increasing engagement of users in such platforms, the volume of personal information that is exposed online grows accordingly. Due to carelessness, unawareness or difficulties in defining adequate privacy settings, private or sensitive information may be exposed to a wider audience than intended or advisable, potentially with serious problems in the private and professional life of a user. Alt...
Citation Formats
B. Taşdizen and H. Kaygan, “Between open source and commerce micropolitics of authorship and originality in a knitting community,” presented at the 15th Annual STS Conference: Critical Issues in Science, Technology and Society Studies, (9 - 10 Mayıs 2016), Graz, Avusturya, 2016, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: