From Complexity to Sustainability": Proposing a Holistic Management Approach for Sustainable Development of Complex Multi-Layered Cultural Landscapes: The Case of Gölyazı (Apolyont) -Bursa / Turkey”

2019-11-26
Multi-layered cultural landscapes are the products of the reciprocal interaction between nature, people and culture, which are dynamically shaped with political, economic, legal and administrative forces through a continual historical development process. Gölyazı (Apolyont) located within the province of Bursa in Turkey, is one of the good representatives of such multi-layered cultural landscapes in Anatolia. The settlement is located on a semi-island, which seasonally becomes an island, in the Uluabat Lake, has a very special natural context with endemic characteristics. The integrity of the natural and built-up environment based on the indigenous relationship and dialog between people, nature and island-coastal culture have sustained all through its continual inhabitancy from Apolyont in antiquity until today’s Gölyazı. This dynamic, complex and continual historical development process, shaped with natural, historical, socio-cultural, physical, economic, political, legal and administrative factors and forces, contribute to the identity and specificity of Gölyazı as a complex multilayered cultural landscape.However, significant changes in the economic, political, legal and administrative forces both in local and global scales mainly after 1980s, had various reflections in the urban and regional development and planning policies for the region. Hence, rapid industrialization and development of the neighboring mega-provinces of İstanbul and Bursa create an important threat for the natural and built-up context of the cultural landscape of Gölyazı. In addition to this, with its significant natural and cultural properties and its location at the vicinity of these mega-provinces, the place became an attractive target for tourism based development, which threatens not only the natural and built-up physical context, but also its socio-cultural context. Furthermore, again due to the variety of the natural and cultural values of Gölyazı (Apolyont) and its setting, there are different types of conservation sites ranging from natural, archaeological and urban conservation sites, in local, national, regional and international levels. These conservation sites, boundaries of which sometimes overlap with each other, have different status and limitations, while they are under the control and authority of different administrative and legal bodies. This top-down and fragmental conservation decision-making and management system also causes another chaos, and threatens the integrity and multi-layeredness of the settlement as well as its natural and socio-cultural contexts.All these top-down and fragmented conservation, development and management policies, mechanisms and decisions, which are incompatible with the indigenous character of Gölyazı, resulted in a gradual loss of various tangible and intangible values of the heritage place, as well as its natural, spatial and socio-cultural integrity. In this regard, today, there is a need to re-establish a holistic, balanced and sustainable conservation and development approach, in which the complex and multi-layered character of the cultural landscape is considered.This paper provides a discussion on how to consider and manage conservation and development with an inclusive, holistic and sustainable manner. Accordingly, the paper proposes a conservation management framework with a multi-temporal, multi-scale, multi-valued, dynamic and holistic approach, considering contextual relationships and historic continuity, for sustainable development of Gölyazı (Apolyont) as a representative of complex multi-layered cultural landscapes.
Heritage and the Sustainable Development Goals, International LDE-Heritage conference, 26-28 November 2019, (26 - 28 Kasım 2019)

Suggestions

State, property owners and barter system in conservation field
Mengilli Işıldak, Funda; Ersoy, Melih; Department of Urban Policy Planning and Local Governments (2010)
A conservation approach developed without considering the conflicts and inequalities of political, economic and social fields can not achieve that purpose of conservation of historical and cultural values as well as engendering conflicts within relations of property relations-conservation field, social justice-conservation field and tensions between relations of property owners in areas planned to be conserved – and- state. Justified as a preference of transferring from private to public ownership of the ar...
From an ancient road to a cultural route : conservation and management of the road between Milas and Labraunda
Durusoy, Elifnaz; Bilgin Altınöz, Ayşe Güliz; Restoration in Department of Architecture (2013)
The main subject of the thesis is revealing cultural routes, by the evaluation of ancient roads which have cultural accumulation on and around them. Considering the unique character of cultural routes, their formation as a consequence of cultural accumulation in a region is the main objective of the thesis. The thesis aims to explore the basic principles of cultural route planning and management in regard to the contexts of natural, man-made, temporal, social and cultural, functional, visual and aesthetic, ...
Diplomasi dili olarak Türkçe: Kırım diplomatik yarlıkları
Başer, Banu (2018-06-01)
Devletlerin resmî yazışma gelenekleri, onların uygarlık seviyeleri, idari teşkilatlanma konusundaki başarıları, içişleri ya da dışişleri ile ilgili meseleleri çözme yöntemleri, kültürel etkilenmeleri gibi konularda pek çok göstergeyi içerir. Bu nedenle hem tarihî hem de çağdaş dönemlere ait resmî yazışmalar, söz konusu devletlerin siyasi ve kültürel tarihi ve ayrıca dilleri konusunda da çok şey söylerler. Bu anlamda, resmî yazışmalar üzerine yapılacak incelemeler hem tarih hem dilbilim hem de diplomatik gib...
ADAPTING TO ABANDONMENT: SUSTAINABILITY OF DEPOPULATED HISTORIC RURAL LANDSCAPES, THE CASE OF NALLIDERE
Atamtürk, Berna; Bilgin Altınöz, Ayşe Güliz; Asrav, Emine Çiğdem; Conservation of Cultural Heritage in Department of Architecture (2022-12-2)
Historic rural landscapes are the phenomenon shaped the reciprocal interaction between human and nature, containing cultural, natural, social, economic as well as built environment which are the result of this interaction. Their formation and transformation depend on three factors; time that makes landscape ‘historic’ as memory and knowledge vector, people as connective contributor of the traits of ‘rural’, nature as stage of the ‘landscape’. These interrelations create local tangible and intangible charact...
The role of institutions in promoting public interest within the context of cultural and natural heritage conservation: the case of Gökova
Özdemir, Gizem Ergüç; Kayasü, Serap; Department of City and Regional Planning (2009)
This thesis discusses the role of institutions in promoting public interest within the context of cultural and natural heritage conservation. Due to the fact that the concept of public interest is controversial and may differ from one context to another, and that there are numerous institutions, the role of institutions in public interest promoting process limited to the context of conservation. A large number of public institutions develop policies that have significant implications for the conservation of...
Citation Formats
G. Okumuş and A. G. Bilgin Altınöz, “From Complexity to Sustainability”: Proposing a Holistic Management Approach for Sustainable Development of Complex Multi-Layered Cultural Landscapes: The Case of Gölyazı (Apolyont) -Bursa / Turkey”,” presented at the Heritage and the Sustainable Development Goals, International LDE-Heritage conference, 26-28 November 2019, (26 - 28 Kasım 2019), TU Delft, The Netherlands, 2019, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.academia.edu/44772082/From_Complexity_To_Sustainability_Proposing_A_Holistic_Management_Approach_For_Sustainable_Development_Of_Complex_Multi_Layered_Cultural_Landscapes_The_Case_Of_Gölyazi_Apolyont_Bursa_Turkey.