The effect of regulation scaffolds on online formative peer assessment activities: a mixed methods study

Alemdağ, Ecenaz
The primary purpose of this research was to investigate the effect of the regulation scaffolds on online formative peer assessment (FPA) activities. To this end, first, it analyzed the effect of the regulation scaffolds on peer feedback provision, feedback uptake, and perceived contributions of the online FPA environment. Second, it described students’ use of the regulation scaffolds and experiences in the FPA activities. The study was an embedded experimental mixed methods research conducted with 70 ninth-grade students from a high school for two writing tasks. The students were assigned to the two groups to use the online FPA environment with regulation scaffolds (WRS) and without regulation scaffolds. The results revealed that the group WRS gave a higher quality of peer feedback and more attention to the received peer feedback in the first task, whereas there was no significant difference between the groups in the second task. In addition, the regulation scaffolds did not contribute to the revision of the writings in both tasks. However, the students in the group WRS perceived greater contributions of the online FPA environment to the peer interaction and knowledge gains. Descriptive and qualitative findings regarding students’ use of the scaffolds and experiences elucidated both contributions and problems of the scaffolds. Overall, this study delved into the whole online FPA process in depth to provide a comprehensive account of the role of FPA activities and scaffolds. The study also proposes design guidelines to enhance FPA practices and directions for future research based on empirical evidence.


The Effect of peer helping training program on peer helpers’ personal and social competency
Taşkın, Dilanur; Hatipoğlu Sümer, Zeynep.; Department of Educational Sciences (2019)
The present study aimed to investigate the effect of a peer helping training program on peer helpers’ personal and social competency. The study, which employed a matching-only pretest-posttest control group quasi experimental design, was implemented in a public middle school in Eskişehir. Non-parametric statistical tests were used to analyze the quantitative data, the results of which revealed that, subsequent to the implementation of the peer helping training program, the aggressiveness post-test scores of...
Capturing Peer Research Mentoring Experience in Undergraduate Education: A Qualitative Case Study Lisans Eğitiminde Akran Araştırma Danışmanlığı Deneyimi: Nitel Bir Durum Çalışması
Can, Iclal; Burakgazi, Sevinç Gelmez; Çapa Aydın, Yeşim; Coşkun, Muhammet (2022-1-01)
All rights reserved.The purpose of this study was to capture the peer research mentoring experience of pre-service school counselors who were involved in a Peer Research Mentoring Program deployed at an undergraduate level Research Methods course. We used a qualitative case study and employed criterion sampling to recruit 10 pre-service school counselors who had completed the Research Methods course at an international university in Northern Cyprus as research mentors. We paired up the research mentors with...
The effect of explicit embedded reflective instruction on nature of science understandings in advanced science students
Koksal, Mustafa Serdar; Çakıroğlu, Jale; Geban, Ömer (Informa UK Limited, 2013-12-01)
The purpose of this study is to investigate the effectiveness of explicit-embedded-reflective (EER) instruction in nature of science (NOS) understandings of ninth-grade advanced science students. This study was conducted with 71 students, who were divided into three groups, by using non-equivalent quasi-experimental design. In the treatment groups, the EER teaching was conducted, while in the comparison group NOS instruction was carried out in the same time interval by lecturing, demonstration and questioni...
The effects of constructive learning method on students' academic achievement, retention of knowledge, gender and attitudes towards science course in "matter of structure and characteristics" unit
Boğar, Yurdagül; KALENDER, SUNA; SARIKAYA, MUSTAFA (2012-02-05)
The purpose of this research is to examine on students' academic achievement, retention of knowledge and attitudes towards science course in matter of structural and characteristic subject with constructivist education version. This study was conducted with students 7/A (N=34) and 7/B (N=34) located in Ankara, during the spring period of 2008-2009 academic year. The study used a quasi-experimental research design with pre-test and post-test control group was used in this study. According to this research mo...
Engaging pre-service EFL teachers in the evaluation process: self-evaluation and peer evaluation as a reflective practice in the practicum /
Gümüşok, Fatma; Çopur, Deniz; Department of English Literature (2014)
This qualitative case study aims at exploring self-evaluation and peer-evaluation processes pre-service EFL teachers are engaged in during the practicum. Considering self-evaluation and peer-evaluation are a form of reflection, the study examines the content and quality of pre-service EFL teachers’ reflection. In relation to these, it analyzes pre-service EFL teachers’ attitudes toward written self-evaluation and peer-evaluation processes. Twenty seven pre-service EFL teachers, enrolled to the first course ...
Citation Formats
E. Alemdağ, “The effect of regulation scaffolds on online formative peer assessment activities: a mixed methods study,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2021.