Identifying buildings with high collapse risk based on samos earthquake damage inventory in Izmir

2022-01-01
Samos Earthquake caused the collapse of about fifty buildings in Izmir city center, resulting in over 120 fatalities. The response spectra of the ground motions at the soft soil sites in Izmir revealed that the spectral accelerations in the period range of 0.5-1.5 s are similar to the spectral accelerations defined by the response spectrum corresponding to the 72-year return period. Despite experiencing accelerations lower than those defined by the Turkish Code design spectrum (475-year return period), significant damage was observed due to the deficiencies of the building stock. Several factors such as soft story, lack of code-compliant transverse steel reinforcement, and low concrete strength have contributed to the devastating loss. Studies in the last two decades on deformation capacity estimation of RC columns showed that key parameters for collapse drift limits are the axial load ratio (i.e., axial force demand to capacity ratio) and transverse reinforcement amount. Most of the collapsed buildings in the past Turkish earthquakes had low concrete strength resulting in high column axial load ratios with limited drift capacity. In order to identify the collapse of vulnerable buildings, a simple procedure is proposed based on vertical and lateral pushover analysis results. The method relies on estimating the average axial load ratios of the most critical columns and their seismic drift demands. An axial load ratio-drift demand limit state model was developed to identify the buildings with high collapse risk. The model was validated with the damaged buildings in Izmir after the Samos earthquake to capture the buildings with poor performance even under service level earthquakes. The proposed model is practical as it only requires the floor plan and concrete compressive strength. It is found to be legitimately accurate to identify and prioritize the buildings prone to collapse.
BULLETIN OF EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING

Suggestions

Preliminary seismic vulnerability assessment of existing reinforced concrete buildings in Turkey - Part I: Statistical model based on structural characteristics
Ozcebe, G; Yücemen, Mehmet Semih; Aydogan, V; Yakut, Ahmet (2003-05-13)
The 1999 earthquakes caused huge damage and economic losses in Turkey. The city of Duzce, hit by the second earthquake of Mw=7.2, suffered widespread damage to many RC buildings. Survey teams conducted post-earthquake evaluations on selected buildings that suffered various degrees of damage. The information collected was analyzed to set up a correlation between the attributes affecting seismic performance and the observed damage. A procedure, developed using a statistical method called discriminant analysis...
Preliminary seismic performance assessment procedure for existing RC buildings
Yakut, Ahmet (2004-08-01)
A preliminary procedure to assess rapidly the likely seismic performance of existing reinforced concrete buildings is presented. In this procedure, a Capacity Index is computed considering the orientation, size and material properties of the components comprising the lateral load resisting structural system. This index is then modified by several coefficients that reflect the quality of workmanship and materials, and architectural features. The procedure has been tested and calibrated based on the data comp...
Relationships between felt intensity and instrumental ground motion parameters for Turkey
Bilal, Mustafa; Askan Gündoğan, Ayşegül; Department of Civil Engineering (2013)
Earthquakes are among natural disasters with significant damage potential; however it is possible to reduce the losses by taking several remedies. Reduction of seismic losses starts with identifying and estimating the expected damage to some accuracy. Since both the design styles and the construction defects exhibit mostly local properties all over the world, damage estimations should be performed at regional levels. Another important issue in disaster mitigation is to determine a robust measure of ground m...
An experimental study on two different strengthening techniques for RC frames
Erdem, Ibrahim; Akyüz, Uğurhan; Ersoy, Ugur; Ozcebe, Guney (Elsevier BV, 2006-11-01)
Thousands of RC buildings were severely damaged or collapsed in Turkey during the past major earthquakes due to various deficiencies. This has initiated extensive experimental studies on strengthening methods. In this study, two 1/3-scale, two-story, three-bay undamaged frames were tested to compare two types of strengthening techniques experimentally. Both undamaged frames were designed such that they had the common deficiencies of existing buildings in Turkey. One of the frames was strengthened with RC in...
Performance-based seismic rehabilitation of damaged reinforced concrete buildings
Sucuoğlu, Haluk; Gunay, MS (American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 2004-10-01)
A building stock consisting of 130 medium-rise reinforced concrete buildings were damaged moderately during the recent earthquakes in Turkey. These buildings were rehabilitated by using simple, cost-effective methods where the newly added shear walls comprised the primary lateral load resisting system. In the presented study, different seismic performance evaluation procedures are tested first on the samples of damaged buildings for predicting their observed performances. Then the expected performances of t...
Citation Formats
B. Binici, A. Yakut, E. Canbay, and K. Tuncay, “Identifying buildings with high collapse risk based on samos earthquake damage inventory in Izmir,” BULLETIN OF EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING, pp. 0–0, 2022, Accessed: 00, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/95316.