Making The Modern City Visible: A Study on Montage, Collage and Photomontage

Download
2022-2-10
Öztürk, Elif Ezgi
The modern city is formed through the collision of social, cultural, economic, political, artistic, and architectural layers that are heterogenous, temporal, and multiple. The collision of these layers results in the emergence of complexities and contradictions. The complexities and contradictions of the modern city make its visual, experiential, and spatial attributes invisible, imperceptible and unproducible. In this context, reading, understanding, and reproducing the modern city requires a critical method based on movement and temporality to reveal the dialectical relations of overlapping or successive urban images. Therefore, this study proposes montage as the method of making the modern city and its experience visible and intelligible in consideration of Sergei Eisenstein’s theory of montage and Walter Benjamin’s “dialectical image.” For this work, montage unfolds two different aspects. The first aspect addresses the aesthetic shock created by the successive and conflicting impressions that are produced by the modern cities instantly through their multiplicities. And the second aspect considers the modern city as montage of these overlapped multiplicities. In this sense, this thesis is an effort to reveal the traces of montage in modern architecture and urban space, experience, and imagery. As a means of that, works of avant-garde artists and architects in the twentieth century and their engagement with other artistic and visual practices, including film, poetry, theatre, and historiography, are elaborated. In that respect, the thesis also traces the alternative practices, such as collage and photomontage, which cognate with montage methodologically. All these searches problematize the abandonment of these critical and intellectual aspects in architecture and repropose the montage to empower architects towards making the experience of the modern city visible and intelligible, again.

Suggestions

Construction of the republic in city space: from political ideal to planning principles
Karakaya, Emel; Keskinok, Hüseyin Çağatay; Department of City and Regional Planning (2010)
After the establishment of the Republic of Turkey, urban planning was one of the main instruments for the development of national economy. In this respect, urban plans for numerous cities and towns were prepared between 1923 and 1940 in Turkey. This thesis reveals the reflections of Republican ideology to urban planning principles. The aims of this study are to clarify the political concepts that were active in the Early Republican Period, translation of political concepts to spatial context and to reveal t...
Designing urban space with the tools of the development legislation
Baş, Yener; Barlas, Mehmet Adnan; Department of City and Regional Planning (2003)
Since 1960s, the scope of urban design broadened in a way that to control the formation process of urban space as a whole. In this respect urban coding became a distinct branch in urban planning as an integrating mechanism of planning and design processes. Thus, design control has become a crucial part of the development control systems especially in the western countries. Although the development legislation in Turkey as an urban coding system has various weaknesses about urban design and design control, i...
Transformation of a public space in İstanbul: the Eminönü Square
Çin, Tümay; Bilsel, Fatma Cânâ; Department of City and Regional Planning (2006)
Urban public spaces have always been subjected to physical, economical,social, political and cultural transformations of the city. These changing dynamics could cause decay in the spatial qualities and could also lead to a loss of values and identities of urban spaces, especially in public spaces. This thesis explores the qualities of a particular urban space in Istanbul: the Eminönü Square. Providing a guideline for the future urban design projects,the structure and the identity of the historical public sp...
Continuity and change of the urban character of Sinop
Can Çetin, Burcu; Gökce, Fuat; Department of Architecture (2011)
This thesis attemps to examine the continuity and change in the physical character of Anatolian city which have crucial impacts on conservation of cultural values of town. From the mid-nineteenth century to the present time; decline of Ottoman Empire, establishment of Turkish Republic with new regime, wars in National Struggle, natural disasters, the policies of both central and local authorities, new regulations for urban planning and conservation are the reasons determined as major causes for the continui...
The physical evolution of the historic city of Ankara between 1839 and 1944: a morphological analysis
Mıhçıoğlu Bilgi, Elif; Bilsel, Fatma Cânâ; Department of Architecture (2010)
The historic core of Ankara, has been subject to a rapid change and deterioration increasingly after 1950s, losing most of its original qualities. This thesis analyzes the spatial evolution of the historic city from 1839 to 1940s with the objective to restitute the preexisting urban fabric and the transformation that took place before 1950s. The Early Republican period was critical in the transformation of the historic core as well as in the development of Ankara that was to be shaped as the ‘model city’ fo...
Citation Formats
E. E. Öztürk, “Making The Modern City Visible: A Study on Montage, Collage and Photomontage,” M.Arch. - Master of Architecture, Middle East Technical University, 2022.