“That’s a grand story:” Reading J. M. Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World as a postnational allegory

Çimen, Rıza
Ünlü Çimen, Esra
The concept of “national allegory” formulated in Fredric Jameson’s work on the third-world literatures has been the subject of much critical debate, especially in the context of postcolonial studies. The dispute surrounding the term is closely tied to Jameson’s controversial suggestions such as the view that “all” third-world literary texts inevitably fall into the category of “national allegory”. The “nation” in this sense provides the main conceptual framework out of which literary texts imbued with “allegorical resonances” develop by specifically addressing the nation state. Jameson’s formulation acquires further significance when it is reciprocally held with his concept of the “political unconscious”, which refers to the implicit political aspect behind creative works. Jameson suggests that artistic works are the products of unconsciously felt political and cultural conditions laid out by latent historical and economic realities. J.M Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World lends itself to a Jamesonian reading in that the Irish efforts to achieve independence from British rule are transmuted into the dramatic world of the play in the form of an Oedipal tension between a father and a son. However, the play does not put forward a simplistic allegory of the nation since the text itself avoids reproducing a picture of a clear-cut nationhood. This essay argues that Synge’s play addresses a “postnational” condition transcending the militant nationalist ideologies and produces a “postnational allegory” in which the suggestive background points at a new rationale for defining the nation with a call for imagining a nomadic “beyond”.
RumeliDE Dil ve Edebiyat Araştırmaları Dergisi


Closing open systems: Two examples for the ‘double hermeneutic’ in economics
Özel, Hüseyin (Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi (Ankara, Turkey), 2003-12-1)
The present paper, which takes as its starting point the criticisms by Roy Bhaskar directed to the Humean conception of causality as constant conjunctions of atomistic events, as the basic characteristic of “closed system” theorizing, emphasizes the importance of complexity, or the prevalence of “open systems,” emanating from the hermeneutic character of the social world. It is argued in the paper that because of the ubiquity of open systems in the social world, economics is not only concerned with explaini...
”The Refutation of Gorgias: Notes on a Contradiction”
Güremen, Refik (2017-11-01)
This paper claims that Socrates’ refutation of Gorgias in the eponymous dialogue is designed not to find out the truth about the nature of the art of rhetoric itself but to refute the master of rhetoric himself. I try to justify this claim by displaying some major contradictions between the conclusions reached at with Gorgias and those reached at with Polus. When these contradictions are taken into account, the discussion with Polus is to be seen as reflecting the genuine Socratic position about rhetoric, w...
Sense through nonsense reading difficult poetry
Taşkesen, Bengü; Sönmez, Margaret Jeanne M.; Department of English Language Teaching (2004)
This thesis analyses the difficulties in reading modern poetry that arise out of not the references but the unconventional use of language, and presents them in a theoretical framework based on Julia Kristeva̕s semanalytic theory and Melanie Parsons̕s application of it to a comparison of Nonsense literature and twentieth century poetry. Then aspects of the works of G. M. Hopkins, Dylan Thomas and Edith Sitwell are discussed and poems by these poets are analysed within this framework.
A Benjaminian re-reading of the “urban image” at the verge of the 21st century
Binboğa, Seçil; Erzen, Jale Adile; Sargın, Güven Arif; Department of Architecture (2013)
The aim of this thesis is to put forward a critical perspective into the metropolis of the 21st Century through the critical materialist historiography of Walter Benjamin, and in the light of the idea of montage by Dziga Vertov. For this purpose, the methodological approach of these two authors, called “thinking in images”, and their basic montage concepts; “dialectical image” and “interval” will be assessed in order to develop a critical reading of the dialectic between the urban image and the urban readin...
Sources of the exoticism in the architecture on Louis Sullivan : the primitive, the oriental, the natural
Köse, Selçuk; Peker, Ali Uzay; Department of Architecture (2004)
The aim of this study is to demonstrate the idea of Exoticism and its effect on nineteenth century architectural tendencies and especially on the philosophy and the works of Louis Sullivan (1856-1924). The study begins with an elucidation of the concept أexoticism.ؤ After the thoughts of a group of nineteenth century European intellectuals are discussed, the philosophy of Sullivan is analyzed. Following chapters are dedicated to the works of Sullivan. Exotic world was the source of a stimulating discourse f...
Citation Formats
R. Çimen and E. Ünlü Çimen, ““That’s a grand story:” Reading J. M. Synge’s The Playboy of the Western World as a postnational allegory,” RumeliDE Dil ve Edebiyat Araştırmaları Dergisi, no. 28, pp. 508–521, 2022, Accessed: 00, 2022. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/98087.