Truth as a discursive object in architecture: communication through aesthetics in the post-truth era

2022-6
Tanrıdağ, Sarp
One of the ways in which the post-truth era affects architecture is the question of communication and exchange. Architecture does not translate into tangible and objective forms with ease. The discipline is susceptible to losing value, depth, and truth in being subjected to measurement and judgment standards. The post-truth era is entangled with the problem of communication in architecture. It brings about a wholesale-like environment for the processes of exchange and communication, where universal standards for commensuration are lacking. In the context of post-truth, this thesis scrutinizes an object-oriented architecture for its potential to provide the discipline with a form of universal communicability based on aesthetics. More particularly, this study reviews Mark Foster Gage’s translation of the contemporary philosophy of Object-Oriented Ontology into architecture. His criticism involves architecture’s reduction to the more marketable, easily comprehendible, over-simplified concepts, relations, and narratives that disjoin the speech, truth, and being in the conversion of the discipline into more commensurable forms. Firstly, the thesis provides an examination of money-sign, which serves a double function in the scope of architecture: (a) to understand how money and rhetorics operate in the contemporary discipline—not solely for deception and profit, but also for “objective” facilitation of communicability and exchangeability; (b) to provide a comparative model for the examination of aesthetics in Object-Oriented Ontology. Following an examination of an object-oriented architecture in general, the study scrutinizes the case study of M. F. Gage Architects’ “The Tower on the 57th Street, NYC” project, the listing and kitbashing techniques.

Suggestions

Complexity management and mutability in architectural form conception: form-blindness and softform
Kızılcan, Egemen Berker; Mennan, Zeynep; Department of Architecture (2015)
Expressions in architecture, as modes of conveying information, have the power to shape perception and thinking, as well as architectural production. Architectural conception is today induced by custom information models with the advent of technologies and methodologies associated with the computational paradigm and therefore are capable of inhabiting complex orders that arise from a multiplicity of concerns. Architecture is no longer constituted by the fixity of a single instance of form, instead possibili...
An Ontological inquiry on potentials of criticality and conceptualization of program in architecture
Kızıl, Sinan Cem; Sargın, Güven Arif; Department of Architecture (2017)
The relation between architecture and social change is one of the key themes in historical discourse of architectural theory. The tradition of criticality has been consolidated after enlightenment and it caused distrust towards norms of architecture. Even though this tradition of criticality eventually turns to its roots and criticises the ideals of enlightenment in postmodern discourses, it is clear that namely postmodern architectures still subjected to criticism similar to their modernist predecessors. I...
Digital architecture as the extension of physical spaces : asymtote's New York Stock Exchange virtual reality environment
Ayoğlu, Halil; Yalınay, Şebnem; Department of Architecture (2005)
The aim of this thesis is to develop an understanding of digital architecture as an extension to the physical spaces. The thesis claims that Virtual Reality Environments (VREs) coexist, supplement, support and extend the physical environments. VREs enable the users to deal with manipulable, multi-dimensional, interactive digital environment. Asymptote2s New York Stock Exchange Three-Dimensional Trading Floor (NYSE 3DTF) VRE is a significant example to analyze digital architecture in this perspective. The 3D...
Perspective for the Reproduction of Architectural Space: ARCH524 as a Pretext
Kapusuz, Bilge Beril; Savaş Sargın, Ayşen; Department of Architecture (2012)
Discovery of the linear perspective of the Renaissance is momentous in terms of the appearance of a new “way of seeing” that is central to the “subject” and emergence of a “subjective” “way of representing” the world. With the assumption that “perspective” is a cultural constituent of the “Renaissance paradigm” that generates the representational notions of art and architecture, perspective is considered as a “convention” and a “mode of representation” that has been influential until the “paradigm shifts” i...
Tracking continuities between the modern and vernacular architecture: courtyard in the west mediterranean architecture as a case study
Arıkan, Fuat Deniz; Güzer, Celal Abdi; Balamir, Aydan; Department of Architecture (2015)
The main aim of this thesis is to search for the possible continuities of a particular spatial organization in the West Mediterranean culture, where the presence of modern and vernacular architecture will be shown to be affecting and integrating into each other. In the first chapter, the structure of the thesis is built upon the term Mediterraneanism. The general background of the region is also given with significant references to two publications; Fernand Braudel’s The Mediterranean and the Mediterranean ...
Citation Formats
S. Tanrıdağ, “Truth as a discursive object in architecture: communication through aesthetics in the post-truth era,” M.Arch. - Master of Architecture, Middle East Technical University, 2022.