Fire Vulnerability Assessment for Heritage Places: A Case of the City of Safranbolu World Heritage Site

2022-6-24
Uluç Keçik, Aynur
Fire incidents threaten cultural heritage and lead to irreversible damages. Loss of life, destruction of buildings, and traditional urban tissues are possible consequences of a fire. Major causes of fires at cultural heritage buildings include deficiencies in electrical installations, electrical appliances used during restoration works, unmaintained chimneys, and fire safety negligence. Historic urban tissues in Turkey are highly vulnerable to fires because of using timber as a building material, lack of maintenance, state of condition of buildings, and difficulties accessing narrow streets in emergencies. Fires are often preventable if measures are undertaken in all decision-making processes. The existence and implementation of fire risk management policies based on international and national policies are critical to preventing fires through practical actions. However, studies on fire vulnerability assessment for heritage places on an urban scale are limited in numbers and have deficiencies concerning time requirements and financial aspects. In this respect, this thesis aims to propose a preliminary fire vulnerability assessment method for heritage places on an urban scale. It has three potential contributions to related literature. It defines fire vulnerability assessment indicators, a simplified method, and policies. In addition, it aims to contribute to UNESCO World Heritage Site management processes by providing a fire vulnerability assessment approach, methodology, and procedures. Fire vulnerability of heritage places is related to different factors at building and neighborhood scales. In this study, four categories of factors are classified: (i) The existence of ignition sources, (ii) The existence of flammable materials, (iii) the Fire Combat within the building scale, and (iv) the Fire Combat within the Neighborhood scale. In this sense, a fire vulnerability assessment for the City of Safranbolu World Heritage Site is conducted. Site surveys were done at different times, and interviews with diverse local stakeholders were conducted for data collection. Analysis using geographical information systems revealed that 59 % of traditional buildings have a medium, high, and very high level of fire vulnerability in the Çeşme Neighborhood. This study suggested a policy framework for fire risk management of cultural heritage. Namely, fire risk management of cultural heritage should be considered in different planning scales such as regional, urban, and building. Participatory processes, including different actors, sufficient technical capacity, and a national fire incidents database are required. In conclusion, the new policy-making process for cultural heritage fire vulnerability assessment can be adapted for current Turkish decision-making mechanisms and other heritage places exposed to fire risk.

Suggestions

Fire tests of cut and cover tunnel roof segments at positive moment region
Arsava, Kemal Sarp; Arsava, Kemal Sarp; Department of Civil Engineering (2011)
The most important issue during a tunnel fire is safety of human life. The tunnel fire structural research and investigations have gained more importance in the last decade but studies show variable results depending on the concrete quality and tunnel design fire. For instance, a certain type of concrete with high moisture content can tend to explode in the first 10-15 minutes of fire with rapid increase of heat release rate. A sudden collapse of the tunnel roof during the fire is unacceptable. Especially i...
Risk assessment of archaeological heritage at territorial scale the case of İzmir metropolitan area
Yıldırım Esen, Sibel; Bilgin Altınöz, Ayşe Güliz; Bakırer, Ömür; Restoration in Department of Architecture (2014)
Archaeological heritage has been increasingly facing severe threats such as urbanization, infrastructure development, mass tourism, illicit digging, earthquakes, floods, and many others. As most of the risks deriving from natural and human factors affect large areas and aggregates of sites, archaeological heritage can be conserved only if it is managed at territorial scale based on priorities and through effective risk management strategies. Accordingly, a thorough assessment of factors contributing to the ...
Exploring the Role of the City as a Learning Environment for Heritage Education
Şimşek, Gökçe; Acar, Esin; Çayırezmez Atalan, Nurdan; Elitok Kesici, Ayşe (Middle East Technical University, Faculty of Architecture, 2013-12-1)
Günümüzde, toplumların kültürel miras üzerine eğitimi önemli küresel uğraşlardan biri haline gelmektedir. Kültürel miras eğitimi, tarih, koruma, eğitim gibi farklı disiplinlere çalışma konusu olmakta ve geçmişe ilgi uyandırmak, geleneklerin devamlılığını sağlamak, kentlilerde yaşadıkları çevreye yönelik farkındalık oluşturmak, kentliler arasında birlik duygularını, dayanışmayı sağlamak gibi çeşitli amaçlar doğrultusunda gerçekleştirilmektedir. Küresel düzeyde, özellikle kentlerin yaşam alanı olarak önem kaz...
Seismic vulnerabilities and risks for urban mitigation planning in Turkey
Saner, Tugce Sonmez (2015-09-01)
Chronic seismic hazards and resulting secondary impacts as natural conditions of the country, and the loss of robust building and prudent settlement practices as aggravated by rapid population growth make cities the most vulnerable geographical and social entities in Turkey. For the development of risk reduction policies, an essential step is to prioritize settlements according to their vulnerability levels. This could be determined by hazard probabilities and attributes of the building stock of each settle...
Critical Success Factors of Partnering in the Building Design Process
Doğan, Sevgi Zeynep ; Kılıç Çalğıcı, Pınar ; Arditi, David ; Günaydın, Hüsnü Murat (Middle East Technical University, Faculty of Architecture, 2015-12-15)
Etkin olamayan ortaklıklar bina projelerinin yönetiminde, tasarım tekrarlarına ve pahalı değişikliklere sebep olmaktadır. Ortaklığın etkileri, bina projesinin yapım evresi bağlamında etraflıca tartışılmaktadır; ancak tasarım evresi için çok nadir ele alınmaktadır. Bina tasarım sürecinin çokdisiplinli ve işbirlikçi yapısı göz önüne alındığında tasarım evresindeki ortaklığın uygulanabilirliğini, faydasını ve niteliğini inceleyen sistematik ve derin araştırmaya ihtiyaç duyulmaktadır. Bu çalışma, bina tasarım s...
Citation Formats
A. Uluç Keçik, “Fire Vulnerability Assessment for Heritage Places: A Case of the City of Safranbolu World Heritage Site,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2022.