A socio-spatial approach to the question of class and consciousness formation in a local setting: the case of Bursa industrial workers

Download

index.pdf

Date

2007

Author

Büyükakça, Murat Çınar

Metadata

Show full item record

Item Usage Stats

196
views

71
downloads

This thesis attempts to challenge the way military historiography deals with the state of the Ottoman army between 1683 and 1792 and the military reform attempts prior to the Nizam-ı Cedid army. Western military historians have ascribed to the inferiority of the Ottoman military technology the waning of the Ottoman military power in the post-1683 period. Any attempt at reform was allegedly obstructed by religious reaction against borrowing European methods and technology. This thesis argues that technology was not the decisive factor in the Ottoman failure against the Austrians and Russians since those two were not too far ahead of the Ottomans with regards to the level of military technology to justify such a conclusion. The comparison with the Russian army, the archenemy of the Ottomans in the period under question, reveals that the Russian success in such departments as conscription, logistics, military leadership and continuous tactical adjustments made to accommodate the needs of steppe warfare, rather than outright application of Western methods of warfare, resulted in victories against the Ottomans. The Ottomans in the meantime were bothered by instability at the Porte, which could neither provide the necessary leadership on the battlefield nor carry out the military reforms. As a result, the vestiges of the Ottoman military organization in its classical form continued to take up economic resources and block any attempts at reform. Religion in this process served as nothing more than a rallying cry for a certain group who vied for power in Istanbul at a time of state formation.

Subject Keywords

Ottoman Army.

URI

http://etd.lib.metu.edu.tr/upload/12608192/index.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/16685

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Thesis

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

An example of strategic command and coordination problem in the Ottoman army: the battle of shipka during the Ottoman-Russian war of 1877-1878 Taşdemir, Ahmet; Turan, Ömer; Department of History (2021-3-05) This thesis analyzes the battle of Shipka during the Ottoman-Russian War of 1877-1878 within the context of its effect on the strategic command and coordination problems in the Ottoman army. The developments that took place during the war, the fall of the Shipka Pass and the attempts of the Ottoman forces torecapture the Shipka Pass will be discussed alongside the interventions from Istanbulto the front line, the effects of the commander appointments on the strategic command ...
The Transformation of the built environment in Amasya from the late Ottoman Empire to the early Turkish Republic Kalkan Açıkkapı, Duygu.; Altan, T. Elvan.; Department of History of Architecture (2019) This study focuses on the transformation of the built environment in the northern Anatolian town of Amasya from the late period of the Ottoman Empire to the early period of the Turkish Republic. The aim is to evaluate the settlement history of Amasya as a city with distinctive geographical characteristics, by analyzing the transformation of its built environment in relation to the changing socio-cultural, economic and political contexts. The analysis starts by focusing on the essential urban nodes formed by...
Identity Formation and the Political Power in the Late Ottoman Empire and Early Turkish Republic Şeker, Nesim (2005-09-01) This article examines the reasons, consequences and penetration ways of the nationalist movement in the lands that made up the Ottoman Empire. But if many academics have studied this issue and offered an agreed vision of the disruptive effect that nationalism had in the heart of the Ottoman Empire, an evaluation of the impact and consequences that this process had in the population and the political configuration of the new states that appeared after the end of the Turkish domination has not been made. This...
Reconsidering the annexation of the Sanjak of Alexandretta through local narratives Matkap, Sıtkıye; Şeker, Nesim; Department of Media and Cultural Studies (2009) The main aim of this thesis is to examine the history of Sanjak of Alexandretta in the Turkish nationalist historiography. In this respect, it is important to comprehend how this region as a territory was tried to present as a homeland with ethnic-nationalist connotations and idioms through the discipline of history by Kemalist nationalists in the late of 1930s. Thus, in order to pay attention to the process of annexation of the region into Turkey requires focusing on how and by whom this nationalist histor...
The impact of the Balkan Wars on Ottoman history writing Searching for a soul Boyar, Ebru (Informa UK Limited, 2014-01-01) Based on histories, accounts and articles published after the Balkan Wars, this article argues that, contrary to the commonly accepted thesis, the Balkan Wars did notmark the point at which Turkism became the dominant state ideology. There was in fact no clear-cut and definite shift toward Turkism at this point. Instead there was an increasing awareness of the need for a 'common soul' that would unite the population of the empire in the face of dramatic challenges such as the Balkan Wars

Citation Formats

M. Ç. Büyükakça, “ A socio-spatial approach to the question of class and consciousness formation in a local setting: the case of Bursa industrial workers,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2007.