The Recent Debate on the Democratic Legitimacy of Judicial Review

Müderrisoğlu, Mehmet
The term 'Costitutional Democracy' is characterized by an underlying conceptual tension between the rule of law and populşar sovereignty. This is reflected in the controversy surrounding the judicial review of legislation in contemporary political systems. In this thesis, the development of the idea of 'governmernt under law' in political thought, contemporary debates on the doctrine of judicial review and normative relation between law and politics is analyzed. It is concluded that both 'constitutionality' and 'popular sovereignty' are essentil to modern democracy. Yet, it might be problematic to disassociate constitutional law from ordinary politics, since the latter is the principal means through which a polity shapes its future.


Turkey's asylum dilemma and process of EU harmonization
Su, Esra; Tanrısever, Oktay Fırat; Department of European Studies (2008)
Turkey has been one of the few countries that signed the 1951 Convention relating to the Status of Refugees with the provision of maintaining geographical limitation to that of offering protection only to European nationals. This is, however, expected to change as Turkey heads towards EU membership. Since 1999, Turkey has been declared as a candidate country to the European Union (EU), in the Helsinki Summit. It is expected to adopt EU Asylum Acquis into its legislation and to lift the geographical limitati...
A systematic critique of formal democracy in light of radical democracy: towards re-politization of the people
Akkın, İbrahim Okan; Parkan, Barış; Department of Philosophy (2011)
In light of the notions of freedom, legitimacy, equality, autonomy, plurality, publicity and action in the philosophies of Rousseau and Arendt, it can be seen that formal democracy, having ceased to be the expression of the sovereignty of the people, fell into a legitimacy crisis and has become a system which makes the people apolitical. Behind these problems, there are many reasons like the ethical deficiency of the monetarist system, deputies’ abuse of authority and tyranny of the majority. The facts in q...
Georges Bataille's concept of sovereignty: an ontological approach to international relations
Aksoy, Mete Ulaş; Polat, Necati; Department of International Relations (2009)
The critical tradition in International Relations Theory has placed great emphasis on the metaphysical nature of sovereignty, the concept assumed to be pivotal to the modern states system. The present study offers an explanation for the metaphysics that characterizes the prevailing notion of sovereignty via insights provided by Bataille. The study focuses on the ontological implications to which Bataille’s formulation of sovereignty gives rise. Underlying this endeavor is to probe into the ways in which the...
The possibility and limit of liberal middle power policies: the case of Turkish foreign policy toward the Middle East during the AKP period
Imai, Kohei; Altunışık, Meliha; Department of International Relations (2011)
The main aim of this dissertation is to understand the change of Turkish state identity related to foreign policy behaviors after the collapse of the Cold War structure. The research question of this dissertation is why and how Turkey has constructed middle power identity, which is based on liberal foreign policies. This dissertation examines two main purposes. First purpose is to analyze AKP’s liberalism based middle power policies from 2005 to 2010 toward the Middle East. In this dissertation, the liberal...
The common foreign and security policy : the European Union's quest for being a coherent and effective actor in global politics
Kaya, Taylan Özgür; Bağcı, Hüseyin; Department of International Relations (2004)
The objective of this thesis is to evaluate European States̕ efforts to develop a coherent and effective foreign and security policy in the context of historical evolution of the CFSP. In this thesis, European States̕ efforts to develop a coherent and effective foreign and security policy will be evaluated in three international political contexts. First period is Post World War II Period, second one is Post-Cold War Period and third one is Post September 11 Period. In the context of Post World War II perio...
Citation Formats
M. Müderrisoğlu, “The Recent Debate on the Democratic Legitimacy of Judicial Review,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2007.