A comparative analysis of thesis guidelines and master thesis abstracts written in english at universities in Turkey and in the USA

Download
2012
Ülker Eser, Meltem
This study examines master of art (MA) theses abstracts written in English in terms of their texual structures. In order to design a comparative study, abstracts are collected from universities (i) with a guideline in Turkey (ii) without a guideline in Turkey and (iii) with a guideline in the USA. 94 abstracts, randomly selected from these three groups of universities, are analyzed according to a content criteria list developed on the basis of Swales (1981, 1990, 2004), and Hyland’s (2000) textual structure models and content instructions provided in thesis writing guidelines. The analysis of data is accomplished using MS Excel 2010 ve SPSS 16.0. The comparison between abstracts written at universities with and without a guideline in Turkey revealed a significant difference in terms of methodology and statement of the problem. Also, with regards to the order of the rhetorical elements (Introduction+Methodology+Results+Conclusion), universities with a guideline in Turkey displayed more consistency than the universities without a guideline. As for the comparison between the universities with a guideline in Turkey and the USA, the results showed that there is a significant difference between the two abstract sets in terms of their methodology, results, and conclusion parts. Besides, the texual pattern analysis showed that abstracts collected from universities with a guideline in Turkey follow a more consistent order than their counterparts in the USA. The results of the thesis have pedagogical implicatons for students, teachers, academics who prepare thesis writing guidelines, and researchers who want to make publications internationally.

Suggestions

A CASE STUDY ON INSTRUCTORS' PERCEPTIONS OF WRITING EXAM GRADING CRITERIA
Tarkan-Yeloglu, Yesim; Seferoğlu, Gölge; YELOĞLU, HAKKI OKAN (2013-01-01)
This study was conducted to analyze the instructors' perceptions of the writing exam grading criteria used in the Faculty Academic English within the context of Freshman English courses at a private university in Turkey. Fifty-five instructors were involved in the study. The data were collected via quantitative and qualitative data collection instruments. Close-response items provided quantitative data and the qualitative data were derived from open-response items. The results indicate that the instructors ...
An Analysis of english language testing and evaluation course in english language teacher education programs in Turkey: developing language assessment literacy of pre-service efl teachers
Şahin, Sevgi; Hatipoğlu, Çiler; Department of Foreign Language Education (2019)
This thesis aims to draw a detailed portrait of the status quo of English Language Testing and Evaluation Course (ELTEC) in the English Language (EL) Teacher Education Programs in Turkey focusing on the construct of language assessment literacy (LAL) for prospective EFL teachers. To this end, it examines how ELTEC instructors plan, teach, and assess in the ELTEC, the problems encountered; suggestions and solutions to these problems for effective LAL development as well as pre-service EFL teachers' evaluatio...
A Study of the Prediction of Academic Achievement in the Chemistry Course
Yuksel, Mehmet; Geban, Ömer (2014-04-01)
The present research examines chemistry course achievement in relation to the academic self-concept, attitudes towards the chemistry course and logical thinking skills. The study sample consisted of 252 students in a vocational high school in Ankara who voluntarily participated with convenience sampling method. In the research, the academic self-concept and logical thinking were found be significant predictors on academic achievement. As a result of discriminant analysis, the academic self-concept and logic...
A Critical analysis of research trends in educational technology theses and dissertations in Turkey
Kara Aydemir, Ayşe Gül; Can, Gülfidan; Department of Computer Education and Instructional Technology (2017)
The first aim of this study is to explore the current research trends in the context of graduate programs in the field of Educational Technology in Turkey, and uncover the possible factors that influence these research trends from the perspective of faculty members working at Educational Technology graduate programs. Secondly, this study aims to understand faculty members’ expectations for the future of the field, and their suggestions on how to make Educational Technology field better than as it is today. ...
An assessment of academic writing needs of graduate students
Akcaoğlu, M. Öztürk; Çapa Aydın, Yeşim; Department of Educational Sciences (2011)
This study mainly aimed at investigating the academic writing needs and writing self-efficacy beliefs of graduate students studying at an English-medium university, Ankara. Furthermore, such areas that have a crucial role in determining writing needs as the frequency of writing tasks, usefulness of written sources, perceived importance of academic writing, and role of Turkish while writing were explored. In this study, quantitative data via “Academic Writing Needs Assessment Survey for Graduate Students” we...
Citation Formats
M. Ülker Eser, “A comparative analysis of thesis guidelines and master thesis abstracts written in english at universities in Turkey and in the USA,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2012.