Semantic discontinuities: investigating designers' product expressions versus users' product impressions

Download
2015
Khalaj, Javad
The doctoral thesis investigates issues in design communication between a designer’s semantic intention and users’ initial experience of a product, with a focus on visual qualities. The starting argumentation is that there can exist a level of discontinuity between meanings as intended to be expressed (by the designer of a product) and meanings as actually construed (by target users of that product). The primary purpose of the research is to develop and implement a methodology to identify where, and to what extent, semantic discontinuities related to connotative meanings are present in product design. A new experimental ‘Semantic Expression/Impression Comparison’ method (SEIC method) is developed and implemented to explore the main subject of the thesis. The SEIC method is applied to an empirical study considering 3 chairs and 3 lamps, designed and produced by three well-known Swedish designers. In total, four data collection and analysis stages are presented: 1) designers’ intended visual expressions, 2) users’ initial visual impressions, 3) users’ evaluations of designers’ intended visual expressions, and 4) designers’ evaluations of users’ realized visual impressions. The qualitative approach to data analysis leads to the creation of Semantic Discontinuity Maps, revealing that designers are able to influence users’ product perceptions, in many cases being considerably successful in eliciting their intended product expressions. However, users’ overall impressions are not limited to only positive experience (as preferably intended by designers), but also include negative and indifferent experiences, which are usually outside of designers’ intentions or expectations. Quantitative analysis of semantic discontinuity data is used to generate Banded Discontinuity Profiles, showing that the studied designers are generally successful in maintaining semantic intent within close tolerances (76 %), but are unable to successfully communicate semantic intent in approximately one-in-four instances (24%). A follow-up micro-analysis is presented and used to illuminate whereabouts design effort should be placed to better realize semantic intent through product visual form.

Suggestions

Visual structures for generative design search spaces /
Abbas, Günsu Merin; Gürsel Dino, İpek; Baykan, Ahmet Can; Department of Architecture (2014)
With the adoption of computational strategies in design, the act of design, the process of problem solving, and the interaction, understanding and the representation of design artefacts has changed. With generative design methods, the understanding of design as artefact gives way to design as process. Generative methods entail multiple design solutions, which enlarge the design search space due to the large number of possible design solutions. Regarding the automated design generation process, the interacti...
Experience reflection modelling (ERM) as a generative research method and student engagement in product design at undergraduate level
Turhan, Senem; Doğan, Çağla; Department of Industrial Design (2013)
Research approaches driven by design thinking have the potential to bridge early stages of design process to idea generation phases in design education. Generative research is emerged from participatory approach which is used at early stages of design process aims to elicit user needs, experiences, expectations and preferences by using generative tools and techniques through helping non-designer participants express their thoughts, feelings, opinions effectively independent of their skills and abilities in ...
Visual Structuring for Generative Design Search Spaces
Abbas, Günsu Merin; Gürsel Dino, İpek (2016-06-17)
With generative design strategies, the act of design, the problem-solving process, and the interaction, understanding and representation of design artefacts have changed. As such strategies entail a large number of possible design solutions, they also expand the design search space immensely. In addition, due to the automated design generation process, the interaction of the designer through the design process has decreased. This research problematizes two major points as (1) the broad design spaces of gene...
The dimensions of users' fun experiences with consumer products
Cila, Nazlı; Erbuğ, Çiğdem; Department of Industrial Design (2008)
User experience (UX) is a multi-dimensional user-product interaction involving positive and emotional usage. Fun experience is a component of UX which maintains distinctive dimensions. In this study these dimensions of the fun concept, namely the nature of the experience, the qualities of products that take place in the experience, and the emotional content of the fun experiences are investigated. The thesis is supported by arguments collected from the literature and the data from two empirical studies.
Investigation into adaptive structure in software-embedded products from cybernetic perspective
Yurdakul, E. Ertuğrul; Şener Pedgley, Bahar; Department of Industrial Design (2007)
This study investigates the concept of adaptivity in relation to the evolution of software and hence software embedded products. Whilst laying out the benefits of adaptivity in products, it discusses the potential future threats engendered by the actual change observed in the functionality principles of adaptive products. The discussion is based upon cybernetic theory which defines control technology in the 20th century anew. Accordingly, literature survey on cybernetic theory, evolution of software from co...
Citation Formats
J. Khalaj, “Semantic discontinuities: investigating designers’ product expressions versus users’ product impressions,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2015.