A comparative analysis of global and national university ranking systems

2015-06-01
Recent interest towards university rankings has led to the development of several ranking systems at national and global levels. Global ranking systems tend to rely on internationally accessible bibliometric databases and reputation surveys to develop league tables at a global level. Given their access and in-depth knowledge about local institutions, national ranking systems tend to include a more comprehensive set of indicators. The purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic comparison of national and global university ranking systems in terms of their indicators, coverage and ranking results. Our findings indicate that national rankings tend to include a larger number of indicators that primarily focus on educational and institutional parameters, whereas global ranking systems tend to have fewer indicators mainly focusing on research performance. Rank similarity analysis between national rankings and global rankings filtered for each country suggest that with the exception of a few instances global rankings do not strongly predict the national rankings.
SCIENTOMETRICS

Suggestions

Evaluating research performance of Turkish universities
Tekneci, Pelin Deniz; Taymaz, Erol; Department of Science and Technology Policy Studies (2014)
This dissertation employs different methodologies to evaluate research performance of 94 Turkish universities over the period between 2008 and 2010, compares their results, and identifies factors that enhance their performance. It consists of three papers revolving around the research performance of Turkish universities. First, we apply different Data Envelopment Analysis models and identify the best-fitting model. Second, we investigate the impact of selected factors on different research outputs using pan...
Uncovering the relationship between student engagement and organizational culture in a public university in Turkey
Borhan, Ersan.; Emil, Serap; Department of Educational Administration and Planning Education (2020)
Student engagement has become a seminal phenomenon in recent higher education studies since it is associated with both desirable student outcomes and the quality of higher education policies and practices. It is defined as the time and energy devoted by the students to their studies and institutional efforts to create effective educational environment. Although the literature has given in-depth comprehension about the role of organizational characteristics in engagement, there has been few studies touching ...
Perspective of Academics on the Impact of Academic Practice
Kondakçı, Yaşar; Zayim Kurtay, Merve; Şenay, Hanife Hilal; Kaya Kaşıkcı, Sevgi; Kulakoğlu, Büşra (Oxford University Press, 2021-5-24)
The pressure on the universities to take a visible place in the rankings has caused anachronistic policies and practices in evaluating the performance of universities. The value attributed to the rankings results in policies prioritizing the criteria imposed by rankings while evaluating the performance of academics, which successively causes several issues in assessing the real impact of the academic practices. Considering these criticisms and concerns about the impact assessment, this study aimed at explor...
A need analysis study for faculty development programs in METU and structural equation modeling of faculty needs
Moeini, Hosein; Alpsan, Doğan; Department of Computer Education and Instructional Technology (2003)
The purpose of this doctoral thesis research study was first to investigate the needs for a faculty development program in Middle East Technical University (METU). Later, in the second phase, models that explained the linear structural relationships among factors that might be influential on faculty̕s perceived competencies about the skills necessary for the instructional practices, personal, professional and organizational developments were proposed and compared. In this study, a questionnaire considering ...
The third mission of university: Perceptions and practices of faculty members on community service
Altun, Yasin; Emil, Serap; Department of Educational Administration and Planning (2021-8)
Core missions of the universities are currently expressed as teaching and education, research and development, and community service while they have substantially evolved throughout the history. Besides, community service function of the universities has recently begun to attract increasing attention in the field of higher education; despite this growing interest, community service is still an ill-defined and unclear concept. Therefore, the aim of the study is to explore the perceptions and practices of fac...
Citation Formats
M. P. Çakır and C. Acartürk, “A comparative analysis of global and national university ranking systems,” SCIENTOMETRICS, pp. 813–848, 2015, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/31396.