The specificity of marine ecological indicators to fishing in the face of environmental change: A multi-model evaluation

Shin, Yunne-Jai
Houle, Jennifer E.
Akoğlu, Ekin
Blanchard, Julia L.
Bundy, Alida
Coll, Marta
Demarcq, Herve
Fu, Caihong
Fulton, Elizabeth A.
Heymans, Johanna J.
Salihoğlu, Barış
Shannon, Lynne
Sporcic, Miriana
Velez, Laure
Ecological indicators are widely used to characterise ecosystem health. In the marine environment, indicators have been developed to assess the ecosystem effects of fishing to support an ecosystem approach to fisheries. However, very little work on the performance and robustness of ecological indicators has been carried out. An important aspect of robustness is that indicators should respond specifically to changes in the pressures they are designed to detect (e.g. fishing) rather than changes in other drivers (e.g. environment). We adopted a multi model approach to compare and test the specificity of commonly used ecological indicators to capture fishing effects in the presence of environmental change and under different fishing strategies. We tested specificity in the presence of two types of environmental change: "random", representing interannual climate variability and "directional", representing climate change. We used phytoplankton biomass as a proxy of the environmental conditions, as this driver was comparable across all ecosystem models, then applied a signal-to-noise ratio analysis to test the specificity of indicators with random environmental change. For directional change, we used mean gradients to apportion the quantity of change in the indicators due to fishing and the environment. We found that depending on the fishing strategy and environmental change, ecological indicators could range from high to low specificity to fishing. As expected, the specificity of indicators to fishing almost always decreased as environmental variability increased. In 55-76% of the scenarios run with directional change in phytoplankton biomass across fishing strategies and ecosystem models, indicators were significantly more responsive to changes in fishing than to changes in phytoplankton biomass. This important result makes the tested ecological indicators good candidates to support fisheries management in a changing environment. Among the indicators, the catch over biomass ratio was most often the most specific indicator to fishing, whereas mean length was most often the most sensitive to change in phytoplankton biomass. However, the responses of indicators were highly variable depending on the ecosystem and fishing strategy under consideration. We therefore recommend that indicators should be tested in the particular ecosystem before they are used for monitoring and management purposes.


Ecosystem indicators-accounting for variability in species' trophic levels
Reed, Jodie; Shannon, Lynne; VELEZ, Laure; Akoğlu, Ekin; BUNDY, Alida; Coll, Marta; FU, Caihong; FULTON, Elizabeth A.; Gruss, Arnaud; HALOUANI, Ghassen; HEYMANS, Johanna J.; HOULE, Jennifer E.; John, Emma; LE LOC'H, Francois; Salihoğlu, Barış; VERLEY, Philippe; Shin, Yunne-Jai (2017-01-01)
Trophic level (TL)-based indicators are commonly used to track the ecosystem effects of fishing as the selective removal of organisms from the food web may result in changes to the trophic structure of marine ecosystems. The use of a fixed TL per species in the calculation of TL-based indicators has been questioned, given that species' TLs vary with ontogeny, as well as over time and space. We conducted a model-based assessment of the performance of fixed TL-based indicators vs. variable TL-based indicators...
The Role of Top-Down and Bottom-Up Control for Phytoplankton in a Subtropical Shallow Eutrophic Lake: Evidence Based on Long-Term Monitoring and Modeling
Mao, Zhigang; Gu, Xiaohong; Cao, Yong; Zhang, Min; Zeng, Qingfei; Chen, Huihui; Shen, Ruijie; Jeppesen, Erik (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2020-02-03)
Lake ecosystems are exposed to a range of anthropogenic pressures, particularly eutrophication, and in some cases also stocking and/or overfishing of top-predator fish species, all factors that have implications for the food web structure and which could lead to dominance of nuisance cyanobacteria. Restoration of degraded lakes demands insight into the relative role of top-down for bottom-up regulating forces. While knowledge about these forces in temperate lakes is extensive, comparatively little is known ...
Adopting sustainability assessment criteria to guide urban regeneraton projects: two case studies in Ankara
Seyhan, Zeynep.; Elias Özkan, Soofia Tahira; Department of Architecture (2019)
Increasing awareness of climate change, loss of biodiversity and increase in environmental pollution due to the current trends of consumption in the urban areas have brought about a myriad of schemas to guide environmentally friendly urban developments. These schemes or Neighborhood Sustainability Assessment Tools (NSA Tools) provide a convenient way to establish healthier and sustainable cities. Meanwhile, Turkey is going through a rapid urban transformation process that is being questioned with respect to...
Cascading effects of elevation, soil moisture and soil nutrients on plant traits and ecosystem multi-functioning in Poyang Lake wetland, China
Fu, Hui; Yuan, Guixiang; Ge, Dabing; Li, Wei; Zou, Dongsheng; Huang, Zhenrong; Wu, Aiping; Liu, Qiaolin; Jeppesen, Erik (2020-03-04)
Trait-based approaches have been used to explore ecosystem level consequences of local changes in biodiversity along environmental gradients. Using a novel response-effect trait framework, we seek to identify and explain the mechanisms governing the cascading effects of environment on plant traits and ecosystem multi-functioning in the large Poyang Lake wetland, China. We sampled the above-ground biomass of the plant communities in 129,100 m(2) plots and estimated the community weighted mean (functional ide...
A Proteomic approach to the comparison of two pine species: proteomes of pinus brutia and pinus sylvestris under environmental stress
Yılmaz, Can; İşcan, Mesude; Güray, Tülin; Department of Biochemistry (2013)
Drought and cold are environmental factors that affect the development and dispersion of plant species. In this study, two pine species adapted to different environmental conditions: Pinus brutia Ten. (Turkish red pine) and Pinus sylvestris L. (Scots pine) were subjected to a proteome research under those stresses. 20 trees from each species, located in the same region and elevation at Yalıncak area in METU Campus, were marked and sampled for their needles, three times in a year: at the end of dry and hot s...
Citation Formats
Y.-J. Shin et al., “The specificity of marine ecological indicators to fishing in the face of environmental change: A multi-model evaluation,” ECOLOGICAL INDICATORS, pp. 317–326, 2018, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: