The Comprehension of Place Awareness in a Historical Context: Metaphors in Architectural Design Education

Download

metujfa2019107.pdf

Date

2019-9-25

Author

Özkan Yazgan, Esra
Akalın, Aysu

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

316
views

149
downloads

This study examines cognitive operations in the design studio - the main component of architectural education - and reviews these operations with regard to a design problem. It also develops an argument for performing an analysis of place awareness in historic context while considering the characteristics of the place where the project will be located and accepting that these characteristics affect the architectural design process. Accordingly, the processes experienced by second-year architecture students on architectural design courses will be analyzed, and the contributions of the data collected from the place to their designs will be evaluated. The educational concept of the design studio, which was also examined in this study, focuses on the design problems in historical environments and implies place awareness. Importance is attached to the idea that students experience and assess the place by developing body-sensory relationships in order to acquire place awareness during the design period. The process of assessing aims to grasp the secret and unexplored spirit of the place and obtain clues regarding the design. The analyzed architectural design cases are related to the study of Aizanoi - an ancient settlement in Anatolia (cavdarhisar) - conducted by the second-year students in the spring term of the 2016-2017 academic year. Different student approaches emerged at the end of the design process, which lasted fourteen weeks. Some of the students emphasized the spirit of the place with a metaphorical reasoning. These projects were analyzed under the context of cognitive operations; application, analogy, combination and abstraction as defined by Welling (2007). The approach, imitating an already-existing object, which is also regarded as "application", is not a method that is supported in regard to the educational approach of the design studio. According to the results of the analysis of the projects in the other three categories, place awareness is low in the analogical approaches. In addition, evidence indicates that place awareness significantly increased in the studies in the "combination" group and reached the highest degree in those projects containing "abstraction". Regarding the projects that did not present a metaphorical reasoning, graphical perfection was prioritized but the scale of the urban texture was neglected. The priority for graphical perfection is to fulfill the functional requirements and solve the accessibility problems. To sum up, both metaphorical and structural attitudes were developed by the contributions from the students' current knowledge and experiences regarding the place, but evidence suggests that metaphorical approaches are concerned with belonging to the "place" in a deeper sense.

Subject Keywords

Architecture, Place awareness, Historical context, Aizanoi, Architectural design education, Cognitive operations

URI

http://jfa.arch.metu.edu.tr/archive/0258-5316/articles/metujfa2019107.pdf
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/50602

Journal

ODTÜ Mimarlık Fakültesi Dergisi

DOI

https://doi.org/10.4305/metu.jfa.2019.1.7

Collections

Department of Architecture, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

An Agentic account of design intentionality in computational architecture Tüntaş, Duygu; Mennan, Zeynep; Department of Architecture (2018) This thesis aims at understanding alterations in the conceptualization of design intentionality in relation to technological advances that bring new synthetic configurations to the world of design. The concept of intentionality used to be defined as central to human consciousness hence design intention regarded as exclusive to the human mind. The contemporary technological/ontological condition seems to displace this conceptualization of design intentionality sustained in conventional design processes, to t...
The position of three-dimensional modeling and visualization techniques in industrial design education COŞKUN, MERVE; Akiner, Dilem (2012-05-04) The purpose of this research is to determine the position of three-dimensional modeling and digital visualization within the scope of concept and product development process in the undergraduate education in Middle East Technical University Faculty of Architecture Department of Industrial Design, designate the problems that the students encounter during the integration of these methods to the design process, and finally question how these methods can be incorporated into design education in order to influen...
Design Instructor’s Perspective on the Role of Computers in Architectural Education: A Case Study Çil, Ela; Pakdil, OYA (Middle East Technical University, Faculty of Architecture, 2007-6-01) This paper reports the findings of a case study aimed to explore the design instructors’ opinions on the role of computers in architectural education. A qualitative research, incorporating a survey and semi-structured interviews, have been conducted. The objective of the research is to explore and identify the instructors’ conceptualizations and evaluations of the relationship between design and computers in education. We aimed to understand whether there is a certain divide among the design faculty between...
The Redesign Studio: An Intensive Evidence-Based Approach for Ideating Product and UX/UI Improvements Pedgley, Owaın Francıs; Şener Pedgley, Bahar (2022-09-08) This paper describes a six-week design studio that set out to make ‘redesign’ an educationally rewarding activity, whilst developing students’ skills in evidence-based designing. Final year industrial design undergraduates chose a personally owned household electrical or electronic product that they considered in need of improving or updating. The redesign studio guided students through five consecutive stages of briefings, activities, and critiques: (i) product anatomy analysis and part labelling, (ii) mar...
A computational architecture methodology for design in traditional tissue: the case of Kalkan Karabağ, Kutay; Asatekin, Gül; Department of Architecture (2010) This study targets to address the problem of 'new building in a traditional setting', utilizing computational design tools. The intention is to provide a methodology for analysis of architectural features of a traditional tissue and moreover propose computational design strategies utilizing algorithms for processing analytical data serving new building design. In the introduction part, this goal is exposed as well as a critic discussion based on a conservationist perspective for contemporary examples of com...

Citation Formats

E. Özkan Yazgan and A. Akalın, “The Comprehension of Place Awareness in a Historical Context: Metaphors in Architectural Design Education,” ODTÜ Mimarlık Fakültesi Dergisi, vol. 36, no. 1, pp. 183–202, 2019, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: http://jfa.arch.metu.edu.tr/archive/0258-5316/articles/metujfa2019107.pdf.