Tarihselcilik-Tarihsicilik [Historicism]: Bir Mimarlık Terminoloji Tartışması Ve 2000’ler Türkiyesinde Tarihsici Mimarlık

Download
2015-12-15
Gurallar, Neşe
The word "historicism" has mostly been translated as "tarihselcilik" in Turkish architectural history writing and criticism. However, "tarihsicilik" can also be used in the discussions around the concept of the "historicism". This article begins by defining the two terms "tarihselcilik" and "tarihsicilik", which can be helpful to differentiate the different approaches of "historicism". Following these discussions on historicism in Turkish architectural history writing and criticism, the article then suggests that the term "tarihsici", which has been largely neglected, should be used to define the architectural products of Turkey especially in the first decade of the 21st century in which historical references were largely used to produce new architectural forms.

Suggestions

Personifying history: Vernon Lee and re-imagining the Florentine renaissance
Kutluata, Cemre Naz; Enginsoy Ekinci, Ayşe Sevil; Department of History of Architecture (2015)
This thesis analyses the alternative approaches to the history writing that emerged during the later half of the nineteenth century with the re-discovery of Florence as the centre of Renaissance art and architecture. It discusses this topic by focusing on the British writer and critic Vernon Lee (1856–1935) and her works on interpreting the past through a personal and impressionistic viewpoint, including her ‘formal’ studies of the Renaissance Euphorion (1884) and Renaissance Fancies and Studies (1895), and...
Birinci Ulusal Mimarlık Dönemi İzmir Konutu: Yerellik ve Melezlik
Çıkış, Şeniz (Middle East Technical University, Faculty of Architecture, 2011)
The First National Style in Turkish Architecture was formulated during the last decades of the Ottoman Empire, and was the preferred style for the founders of the Turkish Republic in the construction of Ankara as the new capital city. In the historiography of Modern Turkish Architecture, architecture during the Early Republican Era is assumed to have anatopic characteristics. The canonic repertoire of this movement is also produced parallel to this idea. However, housing stock of Izmir constructed during th...
Humorists’ narratives on social role of humor in Turkey in a historical perspective
Eğilmezler Boylan, Melike; Topal, Çağatay; Department of Sociology (2015)
This dissertation analyzes the social role of humor in Turkish society through the narratives of a collection of prominent humorists. The comprehensive field research is conducted with 48 humorists encompassing ages 30 to 74 involved in humor magazines, theatre, cinema, television, radio, social media and writing across all mediums. It contributes to the sociological knowledge base by exploring how humor’s social role changes and shifts within the humorists’ narratives, depending on the sociopolitical conte...
Ankara “Yeni Şehir”in Kuruluşu: “Erken Cumhuriyet Konutu”nu Anlamak
Cengizkan, Ali (ODTÜ Mimarlık Fakültesi, 2022-6)
Bir Şehir Kurmak: Ankara 1923-1933 sergi ve kitap çalışması, erken Cumhuriyet mimarlığı üzerine, özellikle de Ankara ve dönemin mimarisi konusunda çok farklı yönlerden açılımlar getirdi. Dönemin yeni Ankara’sı olan Yeni Şehir’in fotoğraflarla temellendirilerek modellenmesi, bu sırada 1300’e yakın çok özgün sayıda fotoğraf, hava fotoğrafı ve sınırlı da olsa döneme ilişkin mimari proje çizimlerinden yararlanılması, özelde Ankara’daki 350 yapılık Yeni Şehir bölgesine, genelde bütün Türkiye’de söz konusu 1923-1...
Self-reflexivity in postmodernist texts : a comparative study of the works of John Fowles and Orhan Pamuk
Saraçoğlu, Semra; Sönmez, Margaret Jeanne M.; Department of Foreign Language Education (2003)
This dissertation makes a comparative analysis of the self-reflexivity in the novels of one British and one Turkish writer - John Fowles and Orhan Pamuk. The study restricts itself to three novels by each writer. In making this analysis under the light of Robert Scholes₂s theory of "reality, "and making use of Linda Hutcheon's classification of self-reflexivity, and Jacque Lacan's The Mirror Stage, it is argued that both Fowles and Pamuk create worlds within worlds which are similar to but different from ea...
Citation Formats
N. Gurallar, “Tarihselcilik-Tarihsicilik [Historicism]: Bir Mimarlık Terminoloji Tartışması Ve 2000’ler Türkiyesinde Tarihsici Mimarlık,” ODTÜ Mimarlık Fakültesi Dergisi, vol. 32, no. 2, pp. 191–204, 2015, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: http://jfa.arch.metu.edu.tr/archive/0258-5316/2015/cilt32/sayi_2/191-204.pdf.