Do staged maturity models result in organization-wide continuous process improvement? Insight from employees

Date

2017-05-01

Author

Uskarci, Algan
Demirörs, Onur

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

214
views

0
downloads

During the last two decades, staged models have been successfully used by software organizations for process improvement. However, the relationship between these models and organization-wide continuous process improvement has not been studied extensively. This study questions the continuity, extent and participation characteristics of software process improvement by analyzing the software process improvement activities and employee perceptions within two different software companies that has CMMI level-3 certification. In order to perform this analysis a multiple case study in two phases were performed. In the first phase the process improvement suggestions submitted by the employees are analyzed from three aspects, namely the submitter, timing, and content characteristics. In the second phase, the employees' perception regarding the organization wide continuous process improvement activities are analyzed by performing a factor analysis on questionnaire results obtained from the employees. The results of the multiple-case study show that there are shortcomings with respect to organization-wide continuous process improvement. It is seen that the software process improvement activities are not performed in a continuous manner. In addition, the contribution of employees to these activities and their perspectives of process improvement are highly dependent on their role within the organization. Based on these findings, it is concluded that staged maturity models fail to enable organization wide continuous process improvement. Organizations employing these models display a case of process-wise oligarchy where a minority manages the processes for a majority who use them. We believe that these findings should generate the incentive to more deeply analyze these shortcomings and determine improvement opportunities for staged models.

Subject Keywords

Software process improvement, Staged maturity models, Employee participation, Continuous improvement

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/57678

Journal

COMPUTER STANDARDS & INTERFACES

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.csi.2017.01.008

Collections

Graduate School of Informatics, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

A Case Study on Employee Perceptions of Organization Wide Continuous Process Improvement Activities Uskarci, Algan; Demirörs, Onur (2012-05-31) Staged models for software process improvement have been extensively used by organizations. However the relationship between these models and organization wide continuous process improvement has not been studied extensively. This study builds upon a previous study that aims to fill in this gap by analyzing the software process improvement activities within a software company that has CMMI level-3 certification. The employees' perception regarding the organization wide continuous process improvement activiti...
Causes of Continuity and Participation Problems in Process Improvement with Staged Maturity Models Uskarci, Algan; Demirörs, Onur (2015-06-17) Staged maturity model based process improvement have been widely employed and analyzed over the past few decades. However the participation of the employees and the continuity of process improvement activities while employing these models is an unexplored aspect of software process improvement research. In this paper we try to identify the causal factors resulting in the shortcomings of staged maturity models with respect to the continuity, extent, and employee participation of process improvement activitie...
Continuous process improvement in software organizations utilizing maturity models Uskarcı, Algan; Demirörs, Onur; Department of Information Systems (2017) During the last two decades, staged process maturity models have been successfully used by software organizations for process improvement. However, the subject of how effective these models are in terms of organization-wide continuous process improvement has not been extensively studied. This study aims to fill this gap by performing a multiple case study to answer questions such as “Are software process improvement activities continuous?”, “Is there an organization wide commitment to process improvement ac...
A review on capability and maturity models of building ınformation modelling Yılmaz, Gökçen; Akçamete Güngör, Aslı; Demirörs, Onur (null; 2017-07-07) Process assessment and maturity models in software engineering are widely used for process improvement. Likewise, assessing BIM capability and maturity have important effects on increasing BIM performance and enhancing benefits of BIM usage. Thus, there are various BIM capability and maturity models in the literature which are important for users to be able to select appropriate model for their BIM assessment purposes. This study aims to identify and analyse BIM capability and maturity models in the constru...
Proposing an ISO/IEC 15504 Based Process Improvement Method for the Government Domain Gökalp, Ebru (2015-06-17) Model based process improvement has been successfully applied for software organizations. After observing this success, customizing it to specific domains/sectors becomes one of the most critical challenges. On the other side, there are some quality problems in government domain as: low efficiency and process performance, employee and citizen dissatisfaction, high cost and defect rates. Assuming that successful processes will be reflected in higher quality, the government processes have to be improved. Howe...

Citation Formats

A. Uskarci and O. Demirörs, “Do staged maturity models result in organization-wide continuous process improvement? Insight from employees,” COMPUTER STANDARDS & INTERFACES, pp. 25–40, 2017, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/57678.