How to check understanding across languages. An introduction into the Pragmatic Index of Language Distance (PILaD) usable to measure mutual understanding in receptive multilingualism, illustrated by conversations in Russian, Ukrainian and Polish

Date

2014-04-01

Author

Rehbein, Jochen
Romaniuk, Olena

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

203
views

0
downloads

The paper proposes, under the roof-concept of a method abbreviated PILaD, a combination of quantitative and qualitative procedures aiming to clarify the relationship of "closely related languages" (Voegelin and Harris 1951). The method is based on the functional-pragmatic theory of 'Communicative Appa-ratus', a cross-linguistically operating interactive structure, which is modified by Lingua Receptiva communication. The data consist of 4 Russian-Ukrainian, 4 Polish-Ukrainian and 4 Polish-Russian conversations which were recorded with a digital camera and transcribed in a HIAT transcription format under the multiparty data program EXMARaLDA. Cases of 'problematic understanding' defined in terms of problematic utterances are related to the total number of utterances in a discourse. The communicative success is compared across the three language constellations and refined down to every participant. Statistical analysis gives an overall picture of how receptive multilingualism works in the three language constellations. The findings reveal that receptive multilingual communication between Polish, Russian and Ukrainian interactants is generally successful, yet, not symmetric, but depends itself on the direction of intelligibility. A summary of the PILaD method and the data base are attached.

Subject Keywords

Communicative apparatus, Back-channel cues, İngua receptiva (LaRa), Sification of hearer's signals, Receptive multilingualism, Ragmatic index, Language distance, Utterance numbers, Segmentation of discourse, Functional Pragmatic theory of understanding, Triangulation, Quantitative and qualitative analysis of multilingual discourses;, PartiturEditor, Polish, Russian, Russian, Ukrainian

URI

https://hdl.handle.net/11511/64871

Journal

APPLIED LINGUISTICS REVIEW

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1515/applirev-2014-0007

Collections

Department of Foreign Language Education, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

A minimalistic approach to Russian-English-Turkish multilingualism Özağaç, Oya; König, Kurt Wolf; Say, Bilge; Department of Cognitive Sciences (2002) The empirical question which is the focus of present research is: How may the lexicons from different languages interact in the course of one syntactical derivation, resulting in code switching phenomena? We develop the following hypothesis concerning code switching: The units of intrasentential code switching are either heads or functional maximal projections. To get support for this hypothesis, intrasentential code switching instances from Russian-English-Turkish and Dutch- Turkish spoken data are analyze...
Some remarks on vector-valued integration Kadets, Vladimir; Shumyatskiy, Boris; Shvidkoy, Roman; Zheltukhın, Kostyantyn; Tseytlin, Leonid (2002-02-01) The paper continues the study of the notion of Riemann–Lebesgue integral, which was introduced before by two of the authors. The result about the convexity of the limit set of integral sums is generalized to the case of weakly-compactly generated spaces. The notion of Riemann–Lebesgue integral is used to introduce new classes of Banach spaces. The properties of these new spaces are studied.
A discussion of the concepts of validity and reliability in qualitative and quantitative Research Sadık, Olgun (2019-06-01) : The purpose of this paper is discussing the main issues in conceptualizing reliability and validity between qualitative and quantitative research approaches. The researcher examined the arguments about validity and reliability in inquiry methodology and identified three main debates primarily in qualitative research. The first one was about qualitative inquirers’ limited emphasis on the data collection process to increase the robustness of their research efforts. Most of the strategies in qualitative rese...
The Investigation of meaning in life in terms of self-construal, self-concept clarity and gratitude among university students Çebi, Esra; Demir, Ayhan Gürbüz; Department of Educational Sciences (2020) The main purpose of the present study is to test a model that investigates the relationships between meaning in life (presence of meaning, search for meaning),self-construal (integration, differentiation), gratitude and self-concept clarity among university students based on the proposals of Steger’s theory of meaning (2009,2012) and the BID model of İmamoğlu (1998, 2003). Additionally, it is aimed to examine the differences of four self construals of the BID (Balanced Integration Differentiation) model on ...
The syntax of relative clauses in Croatian Gracanın Yüksek, Martına (Walter de Gruyter GmbH, 2013-01-01) In this paper, I propose that Croatian relative clauses (RCs) introduced by the complementizer to 'what/that' do not form a homogeneous class with respect to their derivation: some are derived by movement, and some are derived by a non-movement strategy. Unless the relativized element is the subject, sto-RCs normally require a resumptive pronoun to appear in the site of relativization. However, this requirement is removed under morphological case matching between the head of the RC and the resumptive pronou...

Citation Formats

J. Rehbein and O. Romaniuk, “How to check understanding across languages. An introduction into the Pragmatic Index of Language Distance (PILaD) usable to measure mutual understanding in receptive multilingualism, illustrated by conversations in Russian, Ukrainian and Polish,” APPLIED LINGUISTICS REVIEW, pp. 131–171, 2014, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/64871.