Comparison of undrained shear strength by pressuremeter and other tests, and numerical assessment of the effect of finite probe length in pressuremeter tests

IŞIK, Nihat Sinan
Doyuran, Vedat
There is a wide body of research reported in the literature which compare the undrained shear strength determined from various field and laboratory tests. The pressuremeter testing equipment and the related design techniques have been continuously refined. However, the undrained shear strength (S (u)) determined from the pressuremeter test (PMT) is generally higher than that obtained from other field or laboratory tests. In this study, numerical methods to consider the effects of length to diameter ratio (L/D) of the pressuremeter probe, and the procedural implications of soil disturbance and testing depth on the undrained shear strength determined from the PMT were investigated and possible correction factors depending on L/D ratio were established. In addition, in order to compare the variations in undrained shear strength of a clayey material with depth and testing method, a lightly overconsolidated and highly plastic clay, called "Eymir Lake clay" near Ankara (Turkey), was selected as the material of the study, and its values of undrained shear strength (S (u)), which were determined by PMT, field vane shear (FVT), conic penetration test (CPT), and laboratory tests, were compared. Based on the numerical analysis results, the correction factors depending on the L/D ratio of the conventional probes were suggested. The correction factors ranged from 0.83 to 0.96 for L/D ratios of 5.3 to 11, respectively, and they were determined to be independent of the rigidity values ranging from 25 to 200. It was also shown that overestimation of S (u) is independent of depth. In addition, due to very low permeability values of the Eymir Lake clay, it is concluded that for soils with coefficients of permeability lower than 10(-10) m/s, partial drainage around the pressuremeter probe is unlikely. Based on the comparison among the results from laboratory and different field tests, the values of S (u) determined from the theoretical Palmer's solution are higher than those from CPT, FVT, and CU tests. If the correction for L/D ratio is applied to the values of S (u) determined from the Palmer's solution, S (u) from pressuremeter approaches S (u) obtained from FVT; however, there is still a slight overestimation in S (u) obtained from PMT. This overestimation is probably due to the differences in the mode of failure and the presence of a disturbed zone around the pressuremeter probe. However, S (u) determined from the PMT by empirical methods is close to those determined from CPT, FVT, and CU tests.


Comparison Of Formulae For Shear Strength Of Unsaturated Soils
Zehtab, Kaveh Hassan; Toker, Nabi Kartal; Ahmadiadli, Mohammad (2012-06-30)
During last 60 years many research studies have been conducted on calculation of shear strength of unsaturated soils and effects of matric suction on it. Several formulae are developed for predicting shear strength of unsaturated soils, based on strength tests on unsaturated soils. A variety of experimental techniques and laboratory equipment are used for unsaturated shear strength characterization. This study discusses the accuracy of shear strength prediction for unsaturated soils with three different for...
Rutting Potential of Asphalt Mixtures Using Concept of Shear Resistance
Güler, Murat (2006-06-12)
In this study, correlation between rutting potential of hot asphalt mixtures and shear resistance is investigated using Gyratory Load Cell Plate Assembly (GLPA). The GLPA was developed to measure shear resistance of asphalt mixtures with the Superpave gyratory compactor. To demonstrate a possible correlation between shear resistance and rutting, unconfined triaxial repeated load tests were conducted on specimens compacted by varying gradation, asphalt content and fine aggregate angularity. Results of MnRoad...
Experimental study on stress concentration factors in single and groups of end bearing and floating stone columns
Çekinmez, Zeynep; Erol, Ahmet Orhan; Toker, Nabi Kartal; Department of Civil Engineering (2014)
In this study, small scale model tests were performed in order to observe effects of column length and undrained shear strength on settlement reduction ratios at different zones, as well as the stress concentration factor. In these tests different loading conditions, i.e. single stone column loading, unit cell loading and group loading, were studied. Stress carried by stone columns under various foundation pressures were directly measured by soil pressure transducers. Surface and subsurface settlements were...
Prediction of organizational effectiveness in construction companies
Dikmen Toker, İrem; Birgönül, Mustafa Talat (American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 2005-02-01)
Investigation of literature on organizational effectiveness (OE) reveals that the researchers have been in consensus for the difficulty of defining, modeling, and measuring OE, which is important for attaining high performance. Major focuses of this paper are, therefore, to construct a conceptual framework to model OE, to derive major determinants of OE from this framework, and to measure OE by constructing prediction models based on artificial neural network (ANN) and multiple regression (MR) techniques. B...
Comparison of response surface methodology and the proposed Weibull model for inactivation of Listeria innocua by high hydrostatic pressure
BUZRUL, Sencer; CEVIK, Mete; Alpas, Hami (Wiley, 2008-02-01)
Published inactivation data of Listeria innocua by high hydrostatic pressure (HHP) were used to compare the prediction capabilities of response surface methodology (RSM) and the proposed Weibull model. A quadratic function was used for the secondary modeling of the reduced Weibull model's time constant parameter so that this model consisted of pressure, temperature and time just like RSM equation. Application of each model was shown separately. The usability, differences and similarities of these models wer...
Citation Formats
N. S. IŞIK, R. ULUSAY, and V. Doyuran, “Comparison of undrained shear strength by pressuremeter and other tests, and numerical assessment of the effect of finite probe length in pressuremeter tests,” BULLETIN OF ENGINEERING GEOLOGY AND THE ENVIRONMENT, pp. 685–695, 2015, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: