An investigation of post-teaching conferences: politeness in receiving criticism

Gümüşok, Fatma
This study examined the discourse of student teachers in post-teaching conferences. More specifically, the study sought to analyze the politeness strategies Turkish student teachers of English language utilized while responding to criticisms addressed to one specific student teacher or the whole group by their supervisor. Given that receiving criticism is a face threatening act, it is of vital importance to examine how student teachers behave in such situations while addressing to a more-powerful person, their supervisor. The naturally occurring data for this study come from 145 minutes-long post-teaching conference sessions. The researcher analyzed the data through Brown and Levinson’s politeness strategies (1987). The results revealed that student teachers accepted nearly all of the criticism the supervisor delivered. Student teachers mostly resorted to positive politeness strategies to create a sense of solidarity within their groups. They also employed negative politeness strategies to dissociate themselves from the criticized act. Consequently, the findings suggest that Turkish student teachers do not have specific preferences for positive or negative politeness strategies in the case of responding to criticism. They utilized similar strategies in both responding to criticisms addressed to one specific student teacher and to the whole group
ELT Research Journal


The nature of the relationship between teaching concerns and sense of efficacy
Boz, Yezdan (2010-01-01)
This study examined the relationship between prospective teachers' concerns about their teaching and their beliefs about their sense of efficacy. Three hundred and thirty-nine prospective teachers participated in this study. Two instruments, the 'Teaching Concerns Checklist' and the 'Teachers' Sense of Efficacy Beliefs Scale', were used to elicit the participants' teaching concerns and their sense of efficacy. Canonical correlation analysis, conducted to explore the relationships between these two construct...
An Investigation of preservice middle school mathematics teachers’ formative assessment approaches through lesson planning
Kaplan, Gözde; Haser, Çiğdem; Department of Elementary Science and Mathematics Education (2015)
The aim of this study was to investigate the views and practices of early childhood teachers on differentiation. In order to explore the research questions, 19 pre-kindergarten and kindergarten teachers of an International Baccalaureate (IB) world school in Turkey were interviewed about differentiation, their written curriculum documents were analyzed, and the classrooms were observed. This study was designed and conducted as a qualitative case study. As the case, an authorized International Baccalaureate P...
An ethnographic account of identity formation in school: the role of institutional habitus
Özgün, Betül Sümeyy; Göktürk Ağın, Duygun; Department of Educational Sciences (2019)
This study explores the relationship between school institutional habitus and identity formation of students. The school institution engages in multi-dimensional interplay with the society. As being the product of many social structures, school also hold the power to reproduce these structures. Therefore, fieldwork departing from the interaction between school and identity formation of students progresses concerning the other structures in the region. In addition to these, the study discusses which identiti...
A phenomenological study on curriculum development process in Turkey: critical periods and issues
Kürkçü, İrem; Engin Demir, Cennet; Department of Educational Sciences (2021-3-11)
The aim of this study was to explore curriculum development practices in Turkey through experiences and perceptions of prominent curriculum academics who were involved in curriculum studies during the Republican Period. These experiences are invaluable as they shed light on the history of curriculum development studies in Turkey as well as providing future prospects for the field. Phenomenological design was utilized in order to explore curriculum development concept with an in-depth analysis. Data consiste...
The Relationship between teacher reflection and teacher autonomy with respect to certain variables
İpek Şahin, Derya; Aksu, Meral; Department of Curriculum and Instruction (2017)
This study aims to investigate whether there is a significant relationship between teacher reflection and teacher autonomy and among their subscales; and whether there is a significant difference in teacher reflection and teacher autonomy scores according to gender and years of teaching experience. The sample of the study, which is determined by means of cluster random sampling, is 284 classroom teachers (1-4 grades) in 15 elementary schools in three districts (Yenimahalle, Altındağ, Keçiören) of Ankara in ...
Citation Formats
F. Gümüşok, “An investigation of post-teaching conferences: politeness in receiving criticism,” ELT Research Journal, pp. 116–137, 2017, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: