“The shop floor is not for every woman”: Narratives on women industrial designers’ relationships with shop floor workers

Although considerable attention has been paid to the role gender relations play in women’s disadvantaged status in technology-related professions, less emphasis has been placed on women’s relationships with manual workers. This study addresses this gap by examining narratives provided by a sample of industrial designers’ working in manufacturing companies in Turkey where their job also includes visiting the shop floor to supervise the workers who build the models of their designs. Exploring the relations between industrial designers and shop floor workers, this study addresses two questions: First, to what extent and in what ways does gender matter in the relationships between male industrial designers, female industrial designers and male shop floor workers? Second, what are the implications of these relationships for women’s status as professional technological workers within their manufacturing organisations? The results show that contrary to the mixed gender office environment, the male dominated shop floor is an explicitly challenging work setting for women who enter there in positions of authority. This situation is created not only by the resistance of male shop floor workers to women’s superior position, but is sustained mainly by men and some women industrial designers’ consideration of the superior position on the shop floor as only 'authentic' for those who can display the necessary masculinity, which is characterised by aggression, self-sufficiency and toughness. Women develop individual strategies to be accepted into the shop floor and to gain the respect of shop floor workers, since the quality and the punctuality of the models which they present to management is directly related to their reputation in the office.
International Journal of Gender, Science and Technology


From gender equality to gender justice : a critical discourse analysis in terms of gender equality in Turkey
Baba, Elif; Ecevit, Fatma Yıldız; Department of Gender and Women's Studies (2019)
The study focuses on the shift in the axis of women's policies from gender equality to gender justice within the last years in Turkey. Gender justice is the reflection of the miscellaneous transformation policy of the neoconservative discourse on women's issues. The study demonstrates that gender justice is designed by the neoconservative discourse to eliminate the role of gender equality on women's policies, by its distortion. Lacking a theoretical background or an effective argument, gender justice reprod...
Stereotyped gender role perceptions and presentations in elemantary schooling : a case study in Burdur(2001-2002)
Kaya, Havva Eylem; Varoğlu, Demet; Department of Gender and Women's Studies (2003)
A schooling system that claims to offer its students the opportunities to develop their talents and help towards self-determination in their adult lives might be expected to have a career structure itself that demonstrated these virtues, one in which there was equality of the genders in positions of influence and leadership, and no gender stereotyping of roles. Apart from the fairness and consistency of that expectation, it is also reasonable to expect the neutral template of teacher employment and textbook...
Are women and men's atypical educational choices punished? gender system justification, ambivalent sexism, and precarious manhood
Kuzlak, Abdulkadir; Sakallı Uğurlu, Nuray.; Department of Psychology (2019)
Current dissertation aimed to investigate whether female or male students are discriminated in university fields when they are gender minority. When a woman or a man study in an opposite-gender-oriented field, she/he could be regarded as a violator of prescriptive gender stereotypes and gender status-quo and could be punished. Because universities are part of gender hierarchy and gender segregation exists at the universities. It is, also, thought that system justification, ambivalent sexism, and precarious ...
Packing women’s compromises and tactics against patriarchy In Mersin Hâl
Sönmez, Simge; Beşpınar Akgüner, Fatma Umut; Department of Social Policy (2014)
The main objective of this study is to understand women's working conditions by examining compromises and daily tactics of working women as packing women who have worked at Mersin Gross Bazaar [Hâl] as highly patriarchal workplace. Packing as a job is described by 'women job' because it requires to sit all day, be docile, and have nimble fingers and a good taste. Therefore, packing women were invited to work in Hâl by employers through 'sergeants'. Although, they are hired because of their 'feminine' featur...
“Silence of Academy”: Expressing Harassment through Collective Design Process
Canlı, Ece; Kaya, Çiğdem (Middle East Technical University, Faculty of Architecture, 2016)
The aim of this research is to investigate how design can be practised to facilitate self-expression of women, suffering from sexual harassment in universities. The underlying statement, of using design to counteract harassment, is to indicate that design activity can be utilised not only for industrial interests, but also in the realm of socio-political issues such as gender activism and women's struggles. With this aim, in a two-year practice-based design research entitled Silence of Academy, a series of ...
Citation Formats
P. Kaygan, ““The shop floor is not for every woman”: Narratives on women industrial designers’ relationships with shop floor workers,” International Journal of Gender, Science and Technology, pp. 55–80, 2014, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/76090.