Incorporating complexity into risk management:an integrated risk assessment process formega construction projects

Erol, H. Hüseyin
Complexity and risk are inherent components of mega construction projects due to their unique characteristics. However, existing project management practices fail to incorporate complexity-based thinking into risk management. The lack of integration between complexity and other risk-related concepts leads to unrealistic risk assessments, ineffective management strategies, and poor project performance, which decrease the belief in risk management as a value-adding process in projects. In order to fill this gap, this research aims to unveil the relationship between complexity and risk in mega construction projects and propose a holistic approach that can help to manage the project risk and complexity. For this purpose, a mixed-methods research approach was adopted to analyze the data acquired through interviews with 18 participants from 11 mega construction projects carried out by the Turkish contractors. While the quantitative analysis uncovered the relationship between complexity and risk in numerical terms, the qualitative analysis provided further evidence about the nature of this relationship by exposing their links. By combining the findings of both analyses, the Integrated Risk Assessment Process (IRAP), which includes the concepts of risk, uncertainty, complexity, and vimanagement strategies, was proposed. Then, IRAP was operationalized by linking these concepts via an Analytic Network Process (ANP) model. The weights of the parameters in the ANP model were determined by a two-round Delphi study conducted withthedomainexperts. The data obtained using an interactive data collection tool in the first round were consolidated through an expert panel in the second round.Following the finalization of the model, validation studies were conducted to test both the risk quantification performance of the ANP model by comparing the results with the findings from 11 mega construction projects and the applicability of IRAP in practice with a demonstrative case study.The results revealed the potential of IRAP and the ANP-basedquantitative model in terms of managing and monitoring the risks in mega construction projects.Therefore, the proposed risk assessment approach is expected to contribute both to the literature by explaining the links between risk, uncertainty, complexity, and management strategies and to the practitioners bysupporting risk-informed decision-making process in mega construction projects. Although IRAP has been developed considering the dynamics of mega construction projects, it can also be implemented in other project-based industries to incorporate complexity into the risk management process.


Exploring pattern of complexity in mega construction projects
Bilgin, Gizem; Erol, Hacı Hüseyin; Atasoy Özcan, Güzide; Dikmen Toker, İrem; Birgönül, Mustafa Talat (2022-11-01)
Purpose Megaprojects are known as complex projects that involve high levels of uncertainty. This interpretive study explores and portrays perceived complexity in mega construction projects by lived experiences of project managers. Design/methodology/approach This study utilises a ground theory approach to analyse data gathered from semi-structured interviews with 18 professionals involved in 11 megaprojects. Findings Complexity in mega construction projects is defined as a project property that stems from t...
A knowledge-based risk management tool for construction projects using case-based reasoning
Okudan, Ozan; Budayan, Cenk; Dikmen Toker, İrem (2021-07-01)
Construction projects are often deemed as complex and high-risk endeavours, mostly because of their vulnerability to external conditions as well as project-related uncertainties. Risk management (RM) is a critical success factor for companies operating in the construction industry. RM is a knowledge-intensive process that requires effective management of risk-related knowledge. Although some research has already been conducted to develop tools to support knowledge-based RM processes, most of these tools ign...
An analytic network process model for risk quantification of mega construction projects
Erol, Hacı Hüseyin; Dikmen Toker, İrem; Atasoy Özcan, Güzide; Birgönül, Mustafa Talat (2022-04-01)
Risk, complexity, and uncertainty are inherent components of megaprojects due to their unique features. However, existing project management practices lack a structured synthesis of these concepts, which leads to unrealistic risk assessments, ineffective management strategies, and poor project performance. In order to fill this gap, this research aims to develop a holistic risk quantification approach incorporating risk-related concepts. For this purpose, a conceptual risk assessment process developed for m...
Risk Management of Construction Projects by Implementation of Lean Construction and Building Information Modelling
Coşkun, Cansu; Tokdemir, Onur Behzat (2021-02-01)
Construction projects are exposed to the various risk factors through their life-cycle due to their unique and complex nature. Risk factors in the construction projects can be either country or project related, which may significantly affect the predetermined construction project objectives regarding time, budget, orscope. Therefore, it is inevitable to develop risk mitigation strategies to manage risk factors in advance. There are various risk management methods to manage construction risks, yet this study...
Identification and modeling of critical success factors of portfolio management in construction sector
Hızal, A. Sercenk; Sönmez, Rifat; Department of Civil Engineering (2019)
Project Portfolio Management (PPM) is a good theoretical fit for a multi-dimensional industry like construction, however practical implications are limited. The aim of this thesis is to deeply analyze and investigate the determinant factors on the success of portfolio management in the construction industry. Since few studies have addressed them, both PPM in the construction sector and related success factors could be regarded as newly arising subjects for the literature. Consequently, the main contribution...
Citation Formats
H. H. Erol, “Incorporating complexity into risk management:an integrated risk assessment process formega construction projects,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2020.