Much Ado About Nothing: Toward a Structural Realist Theory of Intentionality

Building upon Brentano's (in: McAlister LL (ed) Psychology from an empirical standpoint. Routledge, London, [1874] Brentano 1995) reintroduction of the concept of intentionality to the contemporary philosophy, Tim Crane has famously presented the intentionality as the mark of the mental. Accordingly, the problem of "intentional existence" (or rather "intentional inexistence") has resurfaced in Crane's revival of the Brentanoian theme (Crane in The objects of thought, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2013; Aspects of psychologism, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 2014). Here, I revise Crane's construal of Brentano's notion of intentional inexistence and reinterpret it in terms of a moderate version of relationalism. My relationalist theory of intentionality is inspired by what goes by the name of Noneliminativist Structural Realism (NSR) in the contemporary philosophy of science. NSR allows for a robust realist interpretation of the role of scientific models. The underlying insight of the paper is that it is best to be realist about the structure of the intentionality, which is the common element of the diverse theories of intentional objects. The Outcome is Structural Realist theory of Intentionality (SRI for short). I argue that SRI is not liable to the notorious objection of the impossibility of relata-less relations. I conclude that SRI fulfils the goal of robust psychological realism more economically and straightforwardly than Crane's application of the notion of models.


Improving sub-contractor selection process in construction projects: Web-based sub-contractor evaluation system (WEBSES)
Arslan, Gokhan; Kivrak, Serkan; Birgönül, Mustafa Talat; Dikmen Toker, İrem (Elsevier BV, 2008-05-01)
One of the most important phases in the construction industry (CI) is the bidding process. During the bidding process, selecting the most appropriate sub-contractors (SCs) for the relevant sub-works is highly critical for the overall project performance. In order to select the most appropriate SCs for the project and prepare the most realistic and accurate bid proposal, general contractors (GCs) have to know all financial, technical and general information about these SCs. Within this context, GCs should co...
Exploration of structural chaos and anarchy in Sinan's domed structures
Selcuk, SA; Akan, AE; Ünay, Ali İhsan (2005-10-14)
The master builder Sinan's domed edifices are known as built with structural ingenuity. Remarkable contribution of Sinan to building art and especially to the development of the dome construction is unquestionable as a theme of the history of architecture. Dimensioning of structural components is ingeniously made and the systems cannot be qualified as poorly designed even in the light of contemporary knowledge. This study has attempted to explore the enchantment behind the structural integrity of Sinan's ma...
Joint Optimization of Maintenance and Spare Part Inventory Policies
Bayındır, Zeynep Pelin; Bakal, İsmail Serdar (2020-07-13)
Joint Optimization of Maintenance and Spare Part InventoryPoliciesZ. Pelin Bayindir, Pinar Bulbul, Ismail Serdar BakalIn this study, we consider maintenance planning and spare part inventoryplanning problem simultaneously. Our main focus is the jointoptimization of preventive replacement and spare part inventory management.We propose an exact dynamic programming algorithm andseveral heuristics for a finite planning horizon situation. In a computationalstudy the heuristics are compared against the optimal so...
Koç, Murat; Demir, Şimşek; Department of Electrical and Electronics Engineering (2021-9-29)
RF power amplifiers have been the essential elements of any transmit/receive block. Especially in the transmit chain, some applications require high RF power, such as radar, jammer, telecommunication signals targeting a wide range of coverage. High power requirements in RF broadcast mean high supply power to feed RF PA. The efficiency parameter of a high-power transmission system becomes an issue due to heating problems and performance degradation depending on rising temperatures. The heating problem is com...
Evaluation of punching shear strength design and modelling approaches for slab-column connections
Zorlu, Merve; Binici, Barış; Department of Civil Engineering (2012)
Flat plate systems are constructed with slabs directly supported on columns. Since there are no beams in the system, the behavior of connections between the slabs and columns play a crucial role. Due to the sudden and brittle nature of punching shear failures, slab-column connection design must be conducted with proper safety precautions. The first part of this study aims to evaluate the safety level of different design expressions in the codes. Fir this purpose, the ability of ACI 318-11, TS-500 and Euroco...
Citation Formats
M. Davoody Benı, “Much Ado About Nothing: Toward a Structural Realist Theory of Intentionality,” AXIOMATHES, vol. 28, no. 3, pp. 293–308, 2018, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: