Lacanian Implications of Departures in Zemeckis's Beowulf from Beowulf, the Old English Epic

2021-11-01
Although Robert Zemeckis's film Beowulf (2007) is a re-writing of the Old English epic Beowulf with a shifting of perspective, certain details in the film can only be understood by referring to the poem. That is, a better understanding of the film is tied closely to an awareness of certain narrative elements in the epic. The emphasis on Beowulf in the poem shifts to the Mother in the film. This shift obviously leads to a recontextualization of the narrative elements of the former text. In the epic, Grendel is left without a father; however, in the film, he is fathered by Hrothgar but this biological fathering does not lead to linguistic castration. In their case, things are reversed: rather than the infant being castrated by the Law/language, the biological father is led to a psychic regression due to the son. This appears to be a dramatization of the conflicts between the (m)Other and the shared Other/the representative of the paternal metaphor: that is, Hrothgar. This time, the (m)Other conquers the representative of the paternal metaphor and annuls his masculinity, which radically changes the way in which we evaluate the course of events in the film. These departures make more sense if they are analyzed against the background of Lacanian epistemology. This paper aims to explore the film's departures from the poem by approaching it from a Lacanian perspective.
TEXT MATTERS-A JOURNAL OF LITERATURE THEORY AND CULTURE

Suggestions

Hermeneutics of Lack of Lack and the Dyad of the (m)Other and the Shared Other, in Zemeckis's Beowulf
Birlik, Nurten (Springer Science and Business Media LLC, 2018-04-01)
Beowulf (2007), the film directed by Robert Zemeckis, retells the story in the Old English epic Beowulf with a shifting of perspective. While the epic looks at the conflict between Beowulf and Grendel from a patriarchal vantage point, the film offers a view of things from Grendel's Mother's perspective. In the film Grendel represents the return of the repressed violating the order of the symbolic in Heorot. Thus, Grendel's Mother appears as the subversive heroine who resists the humanizing/castrating elemen...
Renaissance dance patterns in shakespeare’s Italian plays: An analysis of dialogues
Çıkıgil, Fatma Necla (2006-01-01)
This article proposes a relationship between the patterns of Renaissance dances and the shaping of significant passages of dialogue in Shakespeare’s ‘Italian’ plays, Romeo and Juliet, The Taming of the Shrew and Much Ado About Nothing. It pays particular attention to corantos, galliards, la voltas and pavanes. © Intellect Ltd 2006.
Vestiges of Greek tragedy in three modern plays - Eequus, A View from the Bridge and Long Day's Journey into Night
Yazgan (Uzunefe), Yasemin; Norman, Ünal; Department of Foreign Language Education (2003)
This thesis analyses three modern plays that are identified as modern tragedies, Equus, A View From the Bridge and Long Day̕s Journey Into the Night, to find out whether they share certain themes with classical Greek tragedies. These themes are namely values and conflict, hamartia and learning through suffering. Three Greek plays, Agamemnon, Oedipus Rex and Medea will be used as foils to conduct this comparative study. The study will aim to support the view that these major themes appear both in ancient Gre...
Imagination, metaphor and mythopoeia the poetry of three major English romantic poets
Karadaş, Fırat; Sönmez, Margaret Jeanne M.; Department of English Literature (2007)
This thesis studies metaphor, myth and their imaginative aspects in the poetry of William Wordsworth, Percy Bysshe Shelley and John Keats. The thesis argues that a comprehensive understanding of metaphor and myth cannot be done in the works of these poets without seeing them as faces of the same coin, and taking into consideration the role of the creating subject and its imagination in their production. Relying on Kantian, Romantic, and modern Neo-Kantian ideas of imagination, metaphor and myth, the study t...
Hopeless Romantics: Reality versus Imagination in Gustave Flaubert’s Madame Bovary and Joseph Conrad’s Lord Jim
Korkut Naykı, Nil (2017-03-01)
Although Gustave Flaubert’s Madame Bovary (1856) and Joseph Conrad’s Lord Jim (1900) are highly distinct novels in many respects, they are strikingly similar in the way they portray their protagonists. Both Emma Bovary and Lord Jim are hopeless romantics with a major tendency to set up highly unrealistic dream worlds for themselves. Both novels are widely interpreted as seriously critical of their protagonists, whose wide capacity for imagination eventually causes their ruin. This paper acknowledges the val...
Citation Formats
N. Birlik, “Lacanian Implications of Departures in Zemeckis’s Beowulf from Beowulf, the Old English Epic,” TEXT MATTERS-A JOURNAL OF LITERATURE THEORY AND CULTURE, vol. 11, no. 11, pp. 178–185, 2021, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://hdl.handle.net/11511/94943.