AN ANALYSIS OF HEZBOLLAH’S POLITICAL PRAGMATISM AT THE DOMESTIC AND REGIONAL LEVELS IN THE FRAME OF LIMINALITY

Download
2022-9-2
İnan, Elif
Hezbollah, as a non-state actor, has been a part of the Lebanese political sphere for more than 30 years. However, how to define Hezbollah has been a dilemma because of its complex state of existence. Confining the group within the borders of previously set categorizations may not lend credence since Hezbollah is most likely to continue practicing unexpected and conflicting policies and overstep the limits of the assigned identity. Emancipating Hezbollah from a binary understanding, therefore, is able to give a full understanding of the organization’s intricacy without facing obstacles. Since liminality is a broader and less restrictive concept, the frame of “liminality”, hereby, is used to replace the concept of “transformation” in the literature. This thesis, which is a single case study, is intended to analyze the political pragmatism of Hezbollah at both domestic and regional levels. The political maneuvers of Hezbollah are made through the room created by the consequences of liminality of Lebanese state as well as Hezbollah itself. Since Hezbollah, as a non-state actor, was born into a state of liminality, it was endowed with no necessity of a clear definition of itself because of the suspended state structure. Hezbollah’s victory as a surviving and as the most benefitting one is a consequence of a good reading of the liminal periods and the political acumen. The political developments in Lebanon, in this context, has shaped the group’s mission according to the conjuncture. Hezbollah’s political pragmatism at the regional level, on the other hand, is explained by three cases: Israeli Invasion of Lebanon, Participation to the Lebanese electoral system and the 2019 October Uprising. Hezbollah’s political pragmatism at the regional level is elucidated with its reliance on Iran, its alliance with Syria, and lastly, the Arab Spring & Syrian Civil War. Secondary sources such as news from media outlets and the periodic speeches of Nasrallah were utilized. Critical Discourse Analysis is used for the speeches of Nasrallah to analyze the changes in the narrative of Hezbollah. Keywords: Lebanon, Hezbollah, political pragmatism, liminality

Suggestions

Neo-Iranian Nationalism: Pre-Islamic Grandeur and Shi'i Eschatology in President Mahmud Ahmadinejad's Rhetoric
Fozi, Navid (The Middle East Journal, 2016-03-01)
In 2009, Iranian president Mahmud Ahmadinejad began to invoke nationalist sentiments by paying homage to Iran's pre-Islamic history; a significant shift from 30 years of disparaging this period. Tracing the religious and political genealogies of Ahmadinejad's discourse, this article analyzes the climate that rendered both the Islamic Republic's Shi'i-oriented nationalism and the secular alternative proposed by the Pahlavi dynasty politically inadequate. Such a climate provided conditions to amalgamate, albe...
CAPTURING LEBANON WHILE “SAVING” ASSAD: HEZBOLLAH AND THE CIVIL WAR IN SYRIA, 2010-2020
Elhan, Nail; Tür Küçükkaya, Özlem; Department of International Relations (2022-1)
This thesis aims to analyze Hezbollah’s motivations in intervening in Syria, how Hezbollah as a Lebanese actor justified its intervention in the civil war in Syria, and its extended role in the war and presence in Syria in the past decade. By looking at the whole process from the beginning of the Syrian uprisings until 2020, it looks at stages of Hezbollah’s direct involvement in Syria. By borrowing the concept of win-sets from Robert Putnam’s two-level game theory, it aims to answer how Hezbollah justified...
Consolidation of neoliberalism through political islam and its limits: The case of Turkey
Uzgoren, Elif (Orta Doğu Teknik Üniversitesi (Ankara, Turkey), 2018-12)
The Justice and Development Party (JDP) carries the neoliberal programme with a moderate form of Islam in Turkey since 2002 elections. This article aims to present a political economy reading of Turkey’s state-society formation historically through embarking on Gramscian historical materialism. It then questions how institutionalist and critical political economy literature debate the JDP rule. I shall argue that while the institutionalist political economy literature fails to explicate the JDP rule, c...
Assessing the Astana Peace Process for Syria: Actors, Approaches, and Differences
Cengiz, Sinem (2020-06-01)
Since 2011, numerous peace initiatives have been initiated out by several actors to end the Syrian civil war in a peaceful way. This article presents the "Astana Peace Process" brokered by Russia, Turkey, and Iran in early 2017 as a case study of a mediation and examines its predecessors to understand the reasons for the failures of those attempts and develops an assessment of the Astana peace process itself. To gain a better understanding of the Astana peace process, this article incorporates the efforts o...
The sustainability crisis of Alevis
Tol, Uğraş Ulaş; Özçoban Üstüner, Fahriye; Department of Political Science and Public Administration (2009)
One of the important agendas of Turkey in the 2000s has been the “Alevi Revival”. The subject of this thesis, which claims that Alevis are in a search of identity rather than in a period of revival, is the sustainability crisis of the Alevis. Aleviness which has not been mentioned in the political sphere before has now turned into frequently spoken phenomenon. In this “Open Aleviness” period Alevis felt themselves more free and relieved and with this sense they started to claim more rights and freedoms. The...
Citation Formats
E. İnan, “AN ANALYSIS OF HEZBOLLAH’S POLITICAL PRAGMATISM AT THE DOMESTIC AND REGIONAL LEVELS IN THE FRAME OF LIMINALITY,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2022.