Art of Memories Curating at the Hermitage (Book Review)

2020-07-01
Pamir Dietrich, Ayşe
The Hermitage, is one of the oldest, most prestigious and most active museums in the world, and was founded during the reign of Catherine II the Great in 1764. Over the centuries it has accumulated a permanent collection of more than three million objects. The Hermitage’s vast collection is a microcosm of human history and cultural diversity that includes artifacts from archaeological excavations, art from Classical Antiquity, oriental art, Russian art, Western European art, arms and armor, and coins. Following the October Revolution of 1917, all Russian private art collections were nationalized. In the effort to industrialize the country as quickly as possible between 1930 and 1934, the Soviet government sold some works to finance the purchase of western industrial equipment. However, in the years immediately after the Second World War the Hermitage’s holdings of late 19th and early 20th century European artworks increased noticeably. The dramatic changes in Russia’s economy, politics and society that took place in last years of the 20th century also affected the Hermitage. The loss of much of its state funding following the collapse of the Soviet Union meant that the museum had to rapidly find alternative sources of funding. While many other institutions were unable to survive these political and economic transitions, the Hermitage survived and established links to the West that helped it expand. Art of Memories Curating at the Hermitage is a history of the State Hermitage Museum of Saint Petersburg in Russia. Through his own experience, Lépinay sheds light on the little-known history of the museum and opens the door to the reader to reveal the organizational structure of the museum as a cultural laboratory. In the first chapter of the book, Lépinay discusses the museum’s transformation of items, storage site, mobility of the artifacts, how the authorities determine the selection of items, how they orchestrate new arrivals, how the employees create a balance between selecting what is offered and search for what is needed, and what risks that arise after the new arrivals. The author states that until the recent past, the people who had been bringing objects to the museum had unconsciously set the museums’ scope, and he names this period “spontaneous” accumulation when decisions could be made singlehandedly. In the second chapter, Lépinay talks about the history of the documentation of the collections along the lines of classification, description, recording, and describes both the professional and territorial conflicts that resulted from process of classification In the third chapter, the author discusses the confinement and isolation of the museum following the Revolution of 1917 and talks about the transitions of generations in expertise, doctoral program, functions of keepers, books published by Hermitagers, and the restrictions and censorship imposed during the Soviet Union. In the fourth chapter, he talks about the specific position and the responsibilities of the restorers, how restorers are trained and educated, and the process of restoration in both the Soviet Union and at present. In the fifth chapter, he talks about the training of the guides, their competition, methods in managing the crowds, and their organizational problems in tour guiding. In the sixth chapter, Lépinay talks about the spacial organizations of the museum to manage the Hermitage’s large-scale collections. In his conclusion, Lépinay talks about the issues related to the organization, documenting, protection of museum’s collections and maintaining the museum by the Hermitagers and protection of their community. It is a well-written work for researchers who are interested in the history of art museums, and particularly the Hermitage. It introduces the details of maintaining an art institution and the social mechanisms that orchestrate activities within the whole system.
International Journal of Russian Studies

Suggestions

The British Museum, Muze-i Humayun and the travelling "Greek ideal" in the nineteenth century
Özkaya, Ayşe Belgin (2014-03-01)
In standard architectural history surveys, the British Museum is portrayed as an example of nineteenth-century "neoclassicism": or the "Greek revival:" Usually cited as among the motive factors in this revival are the writings about European travels and archaeological explorations in the then Ottoman lands of ancient Greece, as well as a general interest in Hellenic culture. Yet the cultural and architectural appropriation of the Hellenic is not analyzed in relation to the possible ties and tensions between...
Conservation of Urban Space as an Ontological Problem
Günay, Baykan (Middle East Technical University, Faculty of Architecture, 2009)
The objects of conservation are known in the western languages by such epistemologies as heritage, historical building, monument, site, or beauty. Such a terminology exists in Turkish too, however, either consciously or unconsciously, legislation in Turkey rests on the notion of natural and cultural beings (tabiat ve kültür varlıkları). In spite of such a sophisticated definition, and that Turkey has a well developed legislation concerning conservation; it is hard to say that the society as a whole finds th...
Amasya Bimarhanesi’nin Tamamlanamayan Taçkapısı
İnan Ocak, Zeynep; Tanyeli, Gülsün (Middle East Technical University, Faculty of Architecture, 2019-12-31)
Amasya Bimarhanesi’nin taçkapısının 1950’lerdeki onarımının, Türkiye’deki koruma yaklaşımları bağlamında ayrı bir önemi vardır. Onarımda taçkapının eksik kısmı tamamıyla bütünlenmemiştir. Bunun yerine yalnız bir köşesinden duvar kademeli olarak yükseltilmiştir. Onarımın yapıldığı tarihlerde henüz 7044 sayılı yasa yoktur ve Amasya Bimarhanesi’nin sorumluluğu Vakıflar Genel Müdürlüğü’nde (VGM) de değil; Maarif Vekâleti Eski Eserler ve Müzeler Genel Müdürlüğü’ne (EEMGM) aittir (2). Bu tarihlerde müdürlüğün Abi...
Reconstructing Authenticity The Erimtan Archaeology and Arts Museum in the Ankara Citadel
Savaş Sargın, Ayşen (null; 2015-10-09)
Three modest houses that were transformed into Erimtan Museum at the Citadel of Ankara were dated to the late seventeenth century and found in a state of demolition due to neglect over the years. The major goal of the architectural interventions was the preservation of the historical and material qualities of the existing houses and the surrounding historical fabric. If the old houses were conceived as ‘authentic’, their reconstructed version was based on a body of information about the functional layout an...
New Or Transformed: Design Approaches Of Antakya Houses In The French Mandate Period
Rifaioğlu, Mert Nezih (Middle East Technical University Faculty of Architecture, 2021-12-01)
Antakya, known as Antioch during the ancient period, has been inhabited continuously and formed/re-formed and transformed from antiquity to the present by different cultures and empires. It had an organic city form organized with culs-de-sac towards the end of the Ottoman Period. Previous research particularly conducted on its multi-layered urban identity together with on certain buildings from antiquity focuses on the study of the architecture that formed throughout the Ottoman period until it ended. On th...
Citation Formats
A. Pamir Dietrich, “Art of Memories Curating at the Hermitage (Book Review),” International Journal of Russian Studies, vol. 9, no. 9/2 2020, pp. 106–107, 2020, Accessed: 00, 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.ijors.net/issue9_1_2020/reviews/aysedietrich.html.