An evaluation of needs, design, implementation, and outcomes of development and learning course enriched with critical thinking based instruction

Download
2008
Yücel, Banu
This study aimed to evaluate the development process of Development and Learning course according to critical thinking based instruction in the Faculty of Commerce and Tourism Education at Gazi University by using Stufflebeam’s Context, Input, Process, and Product evaluation model. Data were collected from various sources through qualitative and quantitative methods such as questionnaires, individual and focus group interviews, student journals, achievement test, and California Critical Thinking Disposition Inventory (CCTDI). The context evaluation results showed that there were problems in the attainment of course objectives and in the application of the effective instructional strategies for learning and improving thinking skills. Thereupon, at the input evaluation stage, the course was redesigned according to critical thinking based instruction. Pretest-posttest experimental study was carried out while implementing the redesigned course. Concerning the process evaluation, student journals pointed out that while critical thinking based instruction was effective on learning, thinking and metacognitive skills, students experienced some difficulties. Regarding the product evaluation, according to achievement pre-posttest and retention test results and CCTDI pre-posttest results, students in both groups showed a significant progress within a semester. However, there was no difference between treatment and control groups. On the other hand, in the focus groups interviews, the students from the treatment groups expressed the contributions of the course to their teaching and thinking skills, understanding and participation. In conclusion, though quantitative data addressed that critical thinking based instruction did not create difference compared to the traditional instruction, qualitative data delineated positive effects of this approach.

Suggestions

An investigation of the effectiveness of the theme-based curriculum in the 2003-2004 academic year at the department of basic English at Middle East Technical University
Topçu, Tansu; Daloğlu, Ayşegül; Department of English Language Teaching (2005)
This study examines the implementation of the theme-based curriculum in the 2003-2004 academic year to meet the goals and objectives of DBE students at METU. The research design of the study includes questionnaires and focus group interviews with former DBE students and DBE teachers. At the first stage, 231 students and 60 teachers took the questionnaire. Then, 19 students (in groups) and teachers (individually) were interviewed. The results indicated that there was a big difference between the perceptions ...
The Evaluation of Secondary Education Basic Mathematics Curriculum through Stake's Responsive Evaluation Model
Avci, Nevin; Erikci, Begum; Ok, Ahmet (2021-01-01)
The major aim of this study is to evaluate the 11th grade Basic Mathematics (BM) Curriculum implemented at a Vocational and Technical Anatolian High School (Tourism and Hotel Management) through Stake's Responsive Evaluation Model, and to depict to what extent it responds to the needs and career plans of its students. In this study, qualitative case study design and criterion sampling methods were employed. The data were gathered via observation schedules, document analysis, and semi-structured interviews w...
A needs analysis study for the English-Turkish translation course offered to management students of the Faculty of Economic and Administrative Sciences at Başkent University
Mutlu, Özlem; Şimşek, Hasan; Department of Educational Sciences (2004)
The purpose of this study was to identify and analyze the needs of the third year Management students of the Faculty of Economic and Administrative Sciences at Baskent University with regard to the English-Turkish Translation Course through the perceptions of the students; course instructors including the course designer; graduates who took the course; subject-area instructors of the Department of Management; and the professionals practicing in different fields of management and business administration. Bas...
An examination of the relationship between content familiar texts derived from readers' interest and reading performance of English language learners at University level
Öztürk, Nesrin; Aksu, Meral; Department of Educational Sciences (2010)
This study aimed to examine the relationship of background knowledge in relation to topic interest and reading performance of English language learners at TOBB University of Economics and Technology. For that, a reading interest questionnaire and three reading comprehension tests, which were accompanied with a 2-item background & interest questionnaire, were developed by the researcher. These instruments were implemented on 75 English language learners studying at TOBB ETU Preparatory School. The results ob...
Teaching Logarithm by Guided Discovery Learning and Real Life Applications
Çetin, Yücel; Çakıroğlu, Erdinç; Department of Secondary Science and Mathematics Education (2004)
The purpose of the study was to investigate the effects of discovery and application based instruction (DABI) on students̕ mathematics achievement and also to explore opinions of students toward DABI. The research was conducted by 118 ninth grade students from Etimesgut Anatolian High School, in Ankara, during the spring semester of 2001-2002 academic year. During the study, experimental groups received DABI and control groups received Traditionally Based Instruction (TBI). The treatment was completed in th...
Citation Formats
B. Yücel, “An evaluation of needs, design, implementation, and outcomes of development and learning course enriched with critical thinking based instruction,” Ph.D. - Doctoral Program, Middle East Technical University, 2008.