Stylistic Evolution Of Ottoman Mosque Facades In Sinan's Era

Download
1986
Erzen, Jale
This paper has tried to account for facade transformations of Sinan's era, through the analysis of basic structural properties and facade elements of mosques. Mosques being the most socially significant edifices of the time, these transformations indicate the changing attitudes towards space, structure and meaning of buildings and the stylistic changes of Ottoman architecture at large, during the second half of the Sixteenth Century. A detailed analysis of the external influences that have brought about these changes have not been attempted at. However, one can generalize that the basic formation of Ottoman architecture relied on the fact that it developed in Anatolia, a cradle for many cultures. Although Mediterranean influences may be more obvious, one can trace the individual features of the Ottoman mosque back to many regional precedents. The specific developments during Sinan's time, and the gradual evolution from a pre—classical and classical style to an almost mannierist one, makes one think that this may also reflect the first conscious and obvious attempt at Westernization in Ottoman culture. And, in a sense, Sinan's formal inclinations show an understanding of western building concepts that is much more comprehensive than the merely decorative applications of western forms on buildings, during the Eighteenth Century, the period which is formally described as the era of Westernization. The changes Sinan executed within the interior space envisage a new approach to perspective and environmental effects, and his exterior compositions show that he began to regard his buildings and their details as parts of the greater urban order. The Sixteenth Century was almost internationally an era of cultural and aesthetic evolutions. Because of the evidences of new aesthetic, social and urban considerations in Sinan's late executions, we can conclude that in the latter part of the Sixteenth Century Ottoman architecture began to participate within a larger European cultural development. This trend that had begun with the conquest of Constantinople ended with the death of Sinan and so did the classic era of Ottoman architecture. This paper has tried to account for facade transformations of Sinan's era, through the analysis of basic structural properties and facade elements of mosques. Mosques being the most socially significant edifices of the time, these transformations indicate the changing attitudes towards space, structure and meaning of buildings and the stylistic changes of Ottoman architecture at large, during the second half of the Sixteenth Century. A detailed analysis of the external influences that have brought about these changes have not been attempted at. However, one can generalize that the basic formation of Ottoman architecture relied on the fact that it developed in Anatolia, a cradle for many cultures. Although Mediterranean influences may be more obvious, one can trace the individual features of the Ottoman mosque back to many regional precedents. The specific developments during Sinan's time, and the gradual evolution from a pre—classical and classical style to an almost mannierist one, makes one think that this may also reflect the first conscious and obvious attempt at Westernization in Ottoman culture. And, in a sense, Sinan's formal inclinations show an understanding of western building concepts that is much more comprehensive than the merely decorative applications of western forms on buildings, during the Eighteenth Century, the period which is formally described as the era of Westernization. The changes Sinan executed within the interior space envisage a new approach to perspective and environmental effects, and his exterior compositions show that he began to regard his buildings and their details as parts of the greater urban order. The Sixteenth Century was almost internationally an era of cultural and aesthetic evolutions. Because of the evidences of new aesthetic, social and urban considerations in Sinan's late executions, we can conclude that in the latter part of the Sixteenth Century Ottoman architecture began to participate within a larger European cultural development. This trend that had begun with the conquest of Constantinople ended with the death of Sinan and so did the classic era of Ottoman architecture

Suggestions

Understanding the construction technique of Mimar Sinan’s buildings: the case of Lüleburgaz Sokullu Mehmed Paşa Mosque
Etyemez Çıplak, Leyla; Şahin Güçhan, Neriman; Conservation of Cultural Heritage in Department of Architecture (2017)
This dissertation constructs a comprehensive understanding of the construction techniques applied and developed by Mimar Sinan, which underlie the structural characteristics of 16th century Ottoman Architecture. Conducting a research into the literature on Classical Ottoman Architecture and Mimar Sinan’s buildings, the study distinguishes Sokullu Mehmed Paşa Menzil Complexes in Lüleburgaz, Havsa and Payas among the buildings and complexes as known to be designed by Mimar Sinan. It focuses on the mosques of ...
Analyzing the Mimarlik journal: a study on architecture in Turkey in the 1980s
Göloğlu, Sabiha; Altan, Tomris Elvan; Department of History of Architecture (2011)
This thesis aims to examine the transformations that took place in architectural theory and practice in Turkey in the 1980s, and the role of architectural publications in this context, by analyzing the framework that was drawn by the Mimarlık journal. The analysis of Mimarlık is undertaken in relation to architectural developments in the world and in Turkey, and foreign and local counterparts of the journal. The shifting stances of the journal, as the publication of the Chamber of Architects of Turkey, are ...
Theory and practice of geometry in medieval architecture in the middle east (10th-14th centuries)
Özden, Deniz; Peker, Ali Uzay; Department of History of Architecture (2015)
The aim of this research is to investigate the use of geometry in architecture of the Medieval Middle East considering the place of geometry in the classification of sciences in records of medieval Islamic philosophers and the practical application of geometry in the area of architecture through documents on geometric ornaments and geometric analysis of North Dome of Friday Mosque of Isfahan. This thesis discusses the arguments on the meanings of geometric ornaments and on the collaboration of mathematician...
Balconies consigned to oblivion in İranian residential buildings the case of Tehran, İran
Safarkhani, Melody; Erkılıç, Mualla; Department of Architecture (2016)
The present study examines critically the present condition of one of the integral architectural elements; balconies of residential buildings in Iran. Balconies, more than their functional properties serve as a public realm of in-between space, in order to satisfy human physical and psychological needs. Present conditions of the balconies of apartments in Iran-Tehran show that these balconies are consigned to oblivion due to their nonfunctional properties and meaningless presence for their users. Following ...
DEMOLITION VERSUS DECONSTRUCTION: IMPACTS OF FENESTRATION DISPOSAL IN BUILDING RENOVATION PROJECTS
Elias-Ozkan, Soofia Tahira (2014-03-01)
This paper presents findings of a comparative study on the removal and disposal of fenestration units in two separate buildings, belonging to the same period and built with similar construction materials. Demolition techniques were used for removing the fenestration units from a building that was undergoing refurbishment; while, deconstruction techniques were used for dismantling similar units from another building that was being selectively demolished.
Citation Formats
J. Erzen, “Stylistic Evolution Of Ottoman Mosque Facades In Sinan’s Era,” ODTÜ Mimarlık Fakültesi Dergisi, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 105–126, 1986, Accessed: 00, 2020. [Online]. Available: http://jfa.arch.metu.edu.tr/archive/0258-5316/1986/cilt07/sayi_2/105-126.pdf.