On the Onto-Epistemological Status of the Empty Set and the Pure Singleton

Date

2021-01-01

Author

Birgül, Osman Gazi

Metadata

Show full item record

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Item Usage Stats

174
views

0
downloads

This article discusses the quiddity of the empty set from its epistemological and linguistic aspects. It consists of four parts. The first part compares the concept of nihil privativum and the empty set in terms of representability, arguing the empty set can be treated as a negative and formal concept. It is argued that, unlike Frege’s definition of zero, the quantitative negation with a full scope is what enables us to represent the empty set conceptually without committing to an antinomy. The second part examines the type and scope of the negation in the concept of nihil privativum and the empty set. In the third part the empty set is interpreted as a rigid abstract general term. The uniqueness of the empty set is explained via a widened version of Kripke’s notion of rigidity. The fourth part proposes a construction for the pure singleton, comparing it with Zermelo’s conception of singletons with the Ur-elements. It is argued that the proposed construction does not face the criterion and ontological inflation problems. The first conclusion of the article is that the empty set can be construed as a negative, formal and unique abstract general term, with quantitative negation full in scope. The second conclusion is that the pure singleton constructed out of the empty set construed in this way overcomes the criterion and ontological inflation problems.

URI

https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?partnerID=HzOxMe3b&scp=85108801562&origin=inward
https://hdl.handle.net/11511/91279

Journal

Axiomathes

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1007/s10516-021-09571-6

Collections

Graduate School of Social Sciences, Article

Suggestions

OpenMETU
Core

Predication in Aristotle's Categories: A Response to Plato's Theory of Forms Duran, Zeynep; Güremen, Refik; Department of Philosophy (2021-10-4) This study aims to provide a textual evidence to the idea of reading the Categories of Aristotle as a criticism of the Platonic Theory of Forms, by means of Metaphysics, A, 9, 990b22-991a8 and Alexander’s commentary on it (88,5-95,2). According to the main examples of this reading from the contemporary literature, the predication theory of the Categories, conceiving being as “being something” and holding the idea that “being is said in many ways,” denies the Platonic predication theory that is expounded by ...
The visual formation of cartesian subject in modern metaphysics : a critique of Cogito philosophy Ganioğlu, Zafer; Akçay, Ali Adnan; Department of Sociology (2006) This thesis scrutinizes modern metaphysics through a specific reading and critique of Cartesian Philosophy. In the study, the concepts of metaphysics, ideology, modernity, subject and modern science are re-examined in their relations among them and in that the peculiarity of modern metaphysics is attempted to be revealed. At the core of the thesis, Descartes’ understanding of subject is inquired to be modern subject, and its role in the transformations happened in Western world with the advent of modern age...
Knowing Wrongly: An Obvious Oxymoron, or a Threat for the Alleged Universality of Epistemological Analyses? Baç, Mutlu Murat (2011-01-01) The traditional tripartite and tetrapartite analyses describe the conceptual components of propositional knowledge from a universal epistemic point of view. According to the classical analysis, since truth is a necessary condition of knowledge, it does not snake sense to talk about "false knowledge" or "knowing wrongly." There are nonetheless some natural languages in which speakers ordinarily make statements about a person's knowing a given subject matter wrongly. In this paper, we first provide a brief an...
On the possibility, necessity, and practicability of Leopold's land ethic Özer, Mahmut; Sol, Ayhan; Department of Philosophy (2012) In this work, I scrutinize Leopold’s land ethic and Callicott’s interpretation of it both from normative and meta-ethical perspectives by making textual and conceptual analyses. Leopold suggests that an ethic which makes us responsible for the protection of whole nature is evolutionarily possible and ecologically necessary. Callicott tried to buttress Leopold’s land ethic by developing a nonanthropocentric axiology and some meta-principles. Moreover, in his view, Leopold’s views are not only compatible with...
On some consequences of the isomorphic classification of cartesian products of locally convex spaces Kızgut, Ersin; Yurdakul, Murat Hayrettin; Department of Mathematics (2016) This thesis takes its motivation from the theory of isomorphic classification of Cartesian products of locally convex spaces which was introduced by V. P. Zahariuta in 1973. In the case $X_1 times X_2 cong Y_1 times Y_2$ for locally convex spaces $X_i$ and $Y_i,i=1,2$; it is proved that if $X_1,Y_2$ and $Y_1,X_2$ are in compact relation in operator sense, it is possible to say that the respective factors of the Cartesian products are also isomorphic, up to their some finite dimensional subspaces. Zahariuta ...

Citation Formats

O. G. Birgül, “On the Onto-Epistemological Status of the Empty Set and the Pure Singleton,” Axiomathes, pp. 0–0, 2021, Accessed: 00, 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?partnerID=HzOxMe3b&scp=85108801562&origin=inward.