Middle school students’ informal reasoning modes and argumentation quality in socioscientific issues: epistemological beliefs and issue familiarity as predictors

2022-6
Uygun, Cansu Başak
The purpose of this study was to examine middle school students’ informal reasoning modes, and argumentation quality regarding three different SSI, namely, space explorations (SPE), genetically modified organisms (GMO), and nuclear power plants (NPP); and to investigate how well middle school students’ epistemological beliefs (the dimensions of source/certainty, development, and justification) and issue familiarity predict their informal reasoning modes and argumentation quality. For this purpose, correlational research design was used. A total of 465 students (7th and 8th grade) from eight public middle schools in Çankaya constituted the sample through convenient sampling. All data were collected in the Fall Semester of 2020-2021 Academic Year. The middle school students’ epistemological beliefs were obtained through Epistemological Beliefs Questionnaire adapted into Turkish by Ozkan (2008), whereas issue familiarity was obtained through Issue Familiarity Form. The middle school students’ informal reasoning modes and argumentation quality were obtained through open-ended questions adapted by Chang and Chiu (2008), and Christenson and colleagues (2012). The data obtained from open-ended questions were analyzed qualitatively first, then transformed into quantitative data. Descriptive statistics showed that middle school students had fairly sophisticated epistemological beliefs, whereas their issue familiarity, informal reasoning modes, and argumentation quality varied across different SSI. Multiple regression analyses indicated that middle school students’ epistemological beliefs (except the dimension of justification) predicted their informal reasoning modes and argumentation quality. Moreover, middle school students’ issue familiarity made statistically significant contribution to the prediction of their informal reasoning modes and argumentation quality regarding space explorations and nuclear power plants.

Suggestions

Preservice Science Teachers' Epistemological Beliefs and Informal Reasoning Regarding Socioscientific Issues
Ozturk, Nilay; Yılmaz Tüzün, Özgül (2017-12-01)
This study investigated preservice elementary science teachers' (PSTs) informal reasoning regarding socioscientific issues (SSI), their epistemological beliefs, and the relationship between informal reasoning and epistemological beliefs. From several SSIs, nuclear power usage was selected for this study. A total of 647 Turkish PSTs enrolled in three large universities in Turkey completed the open-ended questionnaire, which assessed the participants' informal reasoning about the target SSI, and Schommer's (1...
Preservice Science Teachers' Informal Reasoning about Socioscientific Issues: The influence of issue context
TOPÇU, MUSTAFA SAMİ; Sadler, Troy D.; Yılmaz Tüzün, Özgül (2010-01-01)
The purpose of the current study is to explicitly test the extent to which issue contexts affect the informal reasoning processes engaged in by individuals. In order to address the research question framing this study, we engaged 39 Turkish preservice science teachers (PSTs) in interviews designed to elicit argumentation related to multiple socioscientific scenarios. Three scenarios related to gene therapy, another three related to human cloning, and the final scenario related to global warming. The data we...
Operating conditions-induced changes in product yield and characteristics during thermal-conversion of peanut shell to biochar in relation to economic analysis
Liu, Ruijia; Liu, Guijian; Yousaf, Balal; Abbas, Qumber (2018-08-01)
The influences of pyrolysis conditions on the products yield distribution and physico-chemical characteristics of biochar derived from peanut shell in a fixed-bed reactor were investigated in this study. The pyrolysis conditions included the pyrolysis temperature (300-700 degrees C), retention time (15-90 min), heating rate (1-10 degrees C min(-1)), gas flow rate (20-200 mL min(-1)) and feedstock particle size (<0.075, 0.075 0.150, 0.150-0.300 and 0.300-2.00 mm). Various analytical techniques were used to c...
Energy use, carbon dioxide emissions, GDP, industrialization, financial development, and population, a causal nexus in Sri Lanka: With a subsequent prediction of energy use using neural network
Asumadu-Sarkodie, Samuel; Owusu, Phebe Asantewaa (2016-01-01)
The study examines the causal relationship between energy use, carbon dioxide emissions, GDP, industrialization, financial development, and population from 1971 to 2012 in Sri Lanka, using the ARDL regression analysis and a subsequent prediction of energy use using neural network. There was evidence of a long- run equilibrium relationship running from carbon dioxide emissions, GDP, industrialization, financial development, and population to energy use. The Granger causality test shows a unidirectional causa...
A Matter of Education for Sustainable Development Public Opinion about Nuclear Wastes
Alıcı, Şule; Şahin, Elvan (null; 2016-06-03)
This study was conducted to examine the reflections of a local issue about management of nuclear wastes in the context of sustainable development, especially environmental, social and cultural and economic perspectives. In this aspect, the local issue about a nuclear threat in Turkey was analyzed with respect to the opinions of residents’ (n=5) and expert’s (n=1) as well as the documents (such as news, declarations). The analyses of the data revealed that although there were various distinct views about thi...
Citation Formats
C. B. Uygun, “Middle school students’ informal reasoning modes and argumentation quality in socioscientific issues: epistemological beliefs and issue familiarity as predictors,” M.S. - Master of Science, Middle East Technical University, 2022.